The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Principle of Non-Ascendancy

MS 1832.94 · Practices and doctrines

The Principle of Non-Ascendancy is the governing doctrine of interpretive restraint in the Tower, set out in full at Clause 711-δ.4 of the Seventh Concordance and reaffirmed, with amendments, at every recension since. It holds that no single interpretive claim may conclusively dominate the descriptive field of an inherently unresolved holding. In practice the Principle is invoked whenever a cataloguer wishes to say what a thing is, and is the standard ground on which such a wish is refused. Holdings found to violate the Principle are not corrected but reclassified: they are entered as non-interpretable, a category that carries no interpretive weight and is filed, for reasons no one has satisfactorily explained, immediately above the floor it describes.

Text and Origination

The clause is short and has never been shortened further. Its operative sentence reads:

"No reading shall ascend above another in the descriptive field of a holding whose resolution is not given."

— Clause 711-δ.4, Seventh Concordance

The drafting history is disputed. The Office of Ancillary Drafting maintains that the clause was composed in a single sitting on Floor 4411 during the long winter of 962 of the Lower Counting, and that the original text contained a fourth sentence on precedence which was struck before sealing. The Bureau of Sealed Recensions denies that any fourth sentence ever existed and produces a sealed duplicate — Recension C, undated — in which the clause occupies two lines and no more. Neither office will accept the other's copy as authentic, and the dispute has been referred eleven times to the Central Registry without resolution. The Registry's standing note on the matter reads, in its entirety: "Filed. Referred. Not ascended."

Relation to Central Ascendancy

The Principle is frequently confused with the doctrine of Central Ascendancy, and the confusion is not discouraged at the lower levels. The two are distinct. Central Ascendancy concerns the jurisdictional precedence of central entities and procedures, and is formally expressed in Precedent 14-; the Central Luminary interprets it and oversees the Central Cartulary. Non-Ascendancy concerns interpretation only, and expressly refuses to establish precedence of any kind. Where a holding falls within a Central Foliate zone — that is, where the principle of Central Ascendancy is in immediate procedural effect — the two doctrines operate in sequence: Central Ascendancy determines who may read, and Non-Ascendancy determines that the reading, once made, may not be promoted.

Confusion arises because both doctrines use the word ascend, and because the Central Ascendancy has on three recorded occasions cited Clause 711-δ.4 in support of a jurisdictional claim it does not make. The most recent occasion, in the spring of 1274, drew a written objection from the Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony, which noted that the Office enforces the Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology and had no wish to enforce anything else, but that a clause about readings could not be made to serve as a clause about rooms. The objection was acknowledged and filed without answer.

Invocation and the Ascendancy Register

Invocation is by written submission to the floor's senior cataloguer, on a form held in the Schedule of Restrained Readings. The submission must name the holding, state the interpretive claim proposed, and demonstrate that the claim does not ascend. Demonstration is by counterexample: the cataloguer must produce at least one reading of equal standing that the proposed claim would displace, and must show that the displaced reading is not manifestly inferior. A submission that fails this test is not rejected; it is entered as evidence that the holding was never unresolved, and the holding is reclassified as ordinary.

Successful invocations are entered in the Ascendancy Register, which is rebound every forty years and has never been read in full. The Register records the date, the holding, the claim refused, and the counterexample offered. Entries are cross-indexed by counterexample rather than by claim, a system introduced by Clerk Amaranth Vey in 1188 and never explained. Vey's grievance, recorded in the Register's marginalia for that year, was that her own submission concerning a holding on Floor 209 had been refused on the ground that no equal reading existed, when she had personally catalogued two. The Office's reply, also in the margin, occupies one line: "Both were yours."

Application and the Question of Non-Interpretable Holdings

A holding found to violate the Principle is not thereby judged false. It is judged unresolved, which is a different matter, and it is listed among the Non-Interpretable Holdings with a note of the reading that was attempted. An inventory of one such floor, as returned by the expedition of 1301, reads as follows:

  • Floor 3388 — one door, unopened, with a reading affixed to the frame.
  • Floor 3388, upper landing — the same door, unopened, with no reading.
  • Floor 3389 — absent from the return; the party's account ends at 3388.

The inventory was filed without comment. Its second entry has been cited in every recension since as the standard demonstration that an unresolved holding may present twice without resolving.

Controversy

Scholarly disagreement turns on the reach of the Principle. The School of Bounded Readings holds that Non-Ascendancy applies only to holdings already entered as unresolved, and that applying it to settled holdings would paralyse the descriptive field entirely — a view set out at length in its Memorandum on Descriptive Paralysis of 1290. The rival Loose Construalists argue that any holding may become unresolved on the discovery of a second reading, and that the Principle therefore applies whenever a reader is present. The Loose Construalists are in the majority among floor cataloguers and in the minority everywhere else.

A third position, advanced by the Office of Ancillary Drafting and never formally withdrawn, maintains that the Principle is not a doctrine at all but a filing instruction mistakenly sealed into the Concordance, and that its proper place is in the Manual of Authorized Depiction, among the rules for drawing a thing one has not settled. The Office has not acted on this view since 962, and does not intend to. Readers are reminded that Clause 711-δ.4 is in force on all floors except where a local suspension is posted at the stairhead.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Clerk Amaranth Vey: who were they?

Clerk Amaranth Vey is a stack-clerk of Floor 89 and the current registrar of the SAP Register, whose service began in the Year of the Fourth Recension. Across a career spanning the Third Scriptorium and the Office of Adm…

Clerk Amaranth Vey
Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology: how is it conducted?

The Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology (often abbreviated PNO) is a foundational tenet of cataloguing within The Tower, establishing that a subject cannot be simultaneously catalogued as both definitively existing a…

Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology
Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony: who are they?

The Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony is an administrative body of the Tower charged with the enforcement of the Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology and the practice of Non-Interactivity. It considers Contradictory On…

Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony
Central Ascendancy: how is it conducted?

Central Ascendancy is a doctrinal principle governing the hierarchical precedence of catalogued entities and procedures deemed "central" within the Tower's administrative architecture. It posits that for any given admini…

Central Ascendancy

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.