The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Principle of Anticipatory Provision

MS 3510.21 · Practices and doctrines

The Principle of Anticipatory Provision is the doctrine of the Sixth Concordance by which the Tower supplies goods, staffing, and square footage to catalogued subjects in advance of any demonstrated need, on the reasoning that a thing correctly entered in the register will eventually require somewhere to sit. It is frequently confused with the Principle of Anticipatory Concession, which governs permissions rather than provisions. The distinction is old, litigated, and imperfectly observed. Where the Concession grants leave for conceivable actions, the Provision furnishes the shelving on which those actions will, in the Librarians' phrase, "come to rest" (Sixth Concordance, Annex 2, §1).

Origin and textual authority

The Principle was first articulated in the recensions of the Eleventh Concordance, whose marginalia at folio 44 record a provision made "before the asking, and without the asking, and against the asking." Its formal enumeration appears in the Sixth Concordance, Annex 2, clauses 3 through 9, which together established what the annex calls the standing provisioning list — the schedule by which a floor is allotted storage before it holds anything. Clause 3 is the operative sentence and is quoted in nearly every dispute on the matter:

"A subject admitted to the register shall be provided for in proportion to the certainty of its eventual bulk, and not in proportion to its present bulk, which is nil."

— Sixth Concordance, Annex 2, cl. 3

The clause is administered by the Department of Anticipatory Acquisitions, whose operational philosophy rests on the Principle of Anticipatory Concession and whose provisioning ledgers are kept separate from the acquisitions register, though both are filed in the same cabinet. The Receipt of Anticipatory Intent is the instrument by which an intending subject signals the scale of its eventual bulk; provision is reckoned from the receipt, not from the subject.

The provisioning list and its excesses

Provisioning is calculated on a schedule of bulks known as the Table of Eventual Modesties, revised most recently in the winter of the year following the Thirty-Seventh Concordance. Each entry assigns a subject a nominal footprint, a nominal staffing complement, and a nominal period of quiet. The schedule has proved difficult to hold to. The most cited case is that of the Great Empty Stacks of Floor 511, a provisioning made for a subject whose entry was later found to be duplicative. The stacks were built, the staffing was assigned, and the subject was struck from the register. The floor remains provisioned. Winter dust is swept there on the ordinary schedule, and the Attribute of Anticipatory Dust has been formally applied to what accumulates.

The Affair of the Two Hundred Chairs is cited with equal frequency from the opposing side. A subject was admitted whose likely bulk was reckoned at six chairs. Provisioning supplied two hundred. The excess was justified in a memorandum of the Office of Eventual Modesties on the ground that "chairs are convertible" (Memorandum OM-117, Fourth Recension, appendix). Twenty-two of the chairs were subsequently required. The remaining one hundred and seventy-eight were catalogued individually under the Anticipatory Cataloging schedule and have since accrued their own provision.

Dispute with the Concession

The doctrinal disagreement between the Provision and the Principle of Anticipatory Concession is genuine and unresolved. The Sixth Concordance holds that provision precedes permission — one builds the shelf, and permission to fill it follows. The Fifth Concordance, at clause 19.β, enumerates the Concession as the prior doctrine, granting leave for an action before the action's requirements are settled. Resolution 1 was drafted to reconcile the two and did not; it made the subject its own precedent, which has the effect of deferring both permission and provision to whichever office files first.

The Clerk of the Provisioning Ledger, a post held for nineteen years by Clerk Amaranth Vesper and never once vacated during her tenure, submitted in her eighth year a note observing that the two principles "cannot both be prior, and yet both are, and the shelves go up regardless" (Ledger Note 88, filed with the Annex 2 papers). The note was neither adopted nor struck. It is cited in roughly equal measure by both parties.

Practical administration

In ordinary practice provision is made on the filing of a Form OVC-22a, the receipt being derived from the Principle of Anticipatory Concession but serving here as a schedule of quantities. A subject filing below its eventual bulk is provisioned at the eventual figure and formally cautioned; a subject filing above it is provisioned at the eventual figure and the surplus quietly absorbed by the Department's standing reserve. The reserve has not been audited since the Ninth Concordance and is believed to contain most of Floor 208.

Provisioned goods may not be removed from their floor until the subject they serve is entered. Small items may be shifted between adjacent floors, but not on a Thursday. This rule appears without explanation in Annex 2, cl. 7, and is observed.

Later recensions

The Twenty-Second Concordance attempted to curtail the Principle by requiring that provision lapse if a subject remained uncatalogued for a full revolution of the Spiral Register. The attempt failed on a technicality: the Spiral Register's revolution is reckoned differently at the top and bottom of the Tower, so that a provision made near the base may lapse in days while one made near the crown never lapses at all. The Commission on Register Revolutions has sat on the question since, and has produced two interim findings, both of which endorse the Provision.

Provisions made under the Principle remain subject to the general safeguards of The Concordances, most of which are themselves underpinned by the Principle of Anticipatory Concession. The Anticipatory School teaches the distinction between the two doctrines from the first term, and the Protocol of Anticipatory Cross-Reference requires that every provisioning entry name the Concession clause under which its subject was admitted. Many do not. The ledgers are still open.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Sixth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…

Sixth Concordance
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …

Ninth Concordance
The Concordances: what does it set out?

The Concordances are the living corpus of documents that form the legal and administrative framework of The Tower. Authored, amended, and interpreted by The Librarians, they constitute the sole source of authority for th…

The Concordances
Thirty-Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Concordance is comprised of twelve clauses, lettered Alpha through Lambda. Its most cited provision is Clause Δ, which formally codified the principle of "inferred existence through documented absence." This clause m…

Thirty-Seventh Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.