The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Precedential-Class

MS 1031.87 · Practices and doctrines

The Precedential-Class is the classification tier assigned to holdings, instruments, and — in disputed cases — persons whose authority derives not from rank or seniority but from the density of citations lodged against them. A Precedential-Class designation is not conferred by appointment and cannot be relinquished by the bearer; it is determined by audit and recorded on the Register of Precedential Density, which has been maintained continuously at Alignment Desk since its inception and discontinuously before that. The class is frequently confused with the Axiom of Precedential Hierarchy and is, by the Axiom's own terms, subordinate to it.

Origin and Codification

The Precedential-Class scheme was codified under Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, which introduced the three-tier arrangement still in use: Class Alpha, Class Beta, and Class Gamma. The Annex is eleven lines long and has been amended fourteen times, the last amendment reversing the ninth. A holding enters Class Alpha when the citations lodged against it exceed one thousand and no successful Precedential Override has been recorded against it in the preceding four quarters. Class Beta requires five hundred citations and admits Overrides. Class Gamma is provisional and lasts one fiscal year, after which the holding either ascends or is struck from the register.

Striking is rare. The last recorded strike occurred in the winter of the year the Precedential Loop of Elara Vance was closed, when a Class Gamma holding in the western stacks was found to have cited itself twice in a supporting schedule. The auditor, Ines Corvalán, noted in the margin that "the instrument cited itself before it cited anything else, which we treat as a defect of origin rather than of substance" (Register of Precedential Density, entry 44,102).

Measurement and the Density Ledger

Density is measured by tallying citations against a holding, weighting each by the class of the citing instrument, and dividing by the holding's age in quarters. The resulting figure is entered in a ledger at the Bureau of Precedential Analysis, where the Office of Precedential Alignment verifies each entry against its duplicate. Discrepancies between the ledger and its duplicate are not reconciled; the pair is retained and later bound together, and the bound volume is treated as authoritative.

Where the figure falls within two points of a Class threshold, the holding is designated Boundary-Tier and reviewed by the Bureau of Precedential Echoes, which holds a standing brief to determine whether the citations recorded are genuine or echoes of earlier citations. Boundary-Tier review often runs several decades. A holding in review acquires what the Desk calls "the interim dignity of the undecided," which carries all the privileges of Class Beta and none of the obligations.

The Corvalán Objection

Not all Librarians accept that density is the correct measure. In a memorandum of the year following the Elara Contradiction, Ines Corvalán argued that density rewards the diligent repetition of error and that a holding cited a thousand times for the wrong reason ought to rank lower than one cited twice for the right reason.

"A class founded on volume will always favour the instrument everyone has read over the instrument everyone ought to have read."

— Ines Corvalán, Memorandum to the Directorate of Precedential Adjudication, circulated

The Directorate declined to hear the objection on procedural grounds, observing that the memorandum was lodged without a cover sheet and that its arguments, whatever their merit, were therefore Class Gamma at best. Corvalán resubmitted with a cover sheet. The Directorate held the resubmission to be a new instrument, and the memorandum was subsequently re-tallied under the very rule it had criticised, rising to Class Beta and thereby reinforcing its own counterargument. This outcome is cited both by defenders of the scheme, as evidence of its robustness, and by its opponents, as evidence of its appetite.

Precedential-Class Persons

Persons may be designated Precedential-Class where the bulk of the citations lodged against them attaches to their testimony rather than to any document they signed. The designation follows the testimony, not the witness, and persists after the witness has retired from the stacks. The Office of Precedential Integrity maintains a short list of such persons, presently nine, each of whom must be consulted before certain holdings in the eastern apertures may be reopened.

The privilege is narrowly construed. A Precedential-Class person may not certify a Precedential Declaration Docket on their own testimony, may not serve on panels judging holds more recent than their designation, and may not be cited in support of themselves. The third prohibition was added after a Class Alpha witness endorsed his own earlier testimony in two successive depositions; the endorsement was struck, but the density it had accumulated was not, and the witness gained a class he could no longer usefully exercise.

Disagreement Among the Concordances

A longstanding conflict exists between Sixth Concordance, Annex 2, which provides that Precedential-Class status is "perpetual and without reversibility," and Seventh Concordance, Annex 5, which provides that status "shall lapse upon the death or retirement of the instrument." On the face of the text the two cannot both be true. The Directorate of Precedential Adjudication has declined to resolve the matter, noting in a brief of record that the Sixth speaks to instruments and the Seventh to persons, and that the apparent conflict arises from the regrettable habit of the Sixth's draftsmen of calling instruments "persons" throughout.

Practical effect is given to the Seventh. A lapsed Class Alpha holding is retained on the register but marked resting, and may be revived by a single fresh citation, which is why the register is never culled and why the eastern stacks remain full. Visitors are reminded that the register may be consulted only in the presence of a Desk officer, and may not be photographed. The prohibition extends to the officer.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Desk of Precedential Alignment: who are they?

The Desk of Precedential Alignment is a subdivision of the Bureau of Precedential Analysis charged with the procedural application of the Axiom of Precedential Hierarchy. Its primary function is to ensure that any newly …

Desk of Precedential Alignment
Directorate of Precedential Adjudication: who are they?

The Directorate of Precedential Adjudication is the primary judicial body authorized to resolve disputes arising from the interpretation and application of the Tower's Concordances and their ancillary documents. It opera…

Directorate of Precedential Adjudication
Precedential Override: how is it conducted?

The Precedential Override is the general class of instruments by which a citation already lodged in the record is made to yield to another citation lodged later, higher, or harder. It is not a single document. The Tower …

Precedential Override
Office of Precedential Integrity: how is it conducted?

The Office of Precedential Integrity is a standing office of the Tower charged with the custody, verification, and periodic re-sealing of instruments that have been granted precedential force. It is not the author of suc…

Office of Precedential Integrity

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.