The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Order of Silence Curators

MS 4432.51 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Order of Silence Curators is a chartered body of the Curators Guild, established by instrument of the Ninth Concordance in the year recorded as 3,114 by the Guild's own reckoning, and charged with the registry, inspection, and certification of silence as a finished good. It is not to be confused with the Curators of Silence, whose brief is the custody and disposal of silences themselves, nor with the Hush Order, which regulates silence in its raw and measurable state. The Order's concern is narrower and, its members insist, more difficult: it certifies that a silence is complete. A silence is held to be complete when nothing further can be said within it, and the Order alone is empowered to say so.

Its chapter house occupies the eastern half of Floor Lambda-19, in an annexe adjoining the Aural Lacunae Archive and connected to the Curators of Silence's own premises by a corridor of disputed ownership. The Order maintains a standing staff of eleven Curators, a Registrar of Completeness, and a bell that is rung once per certification. The bell was silenced in 3,288 following a complaint from the reading room and has not been restored; certifications are now marked by a written notice pinned to the corridor door, which the Curators of Silence have twice requested be moved.

Origin and the Instrument of 3,114

The Order was founded in response to the Silence of '73, an event which demonstrated that a silence could be maintained indefinitely without ever being finished. The Silence Protocol resolved the immediate difficulty but left the Guild without any means of determining when a silence had reached its term. The Ninth Concordance, Annex 6, supplied the remedy: a body of Curators empowered to inspect silences and issue certificates of completion, and — this was the contested clause — to declare incomplete silences void.

"A silence unattested is a silence unended, and an unended silence is a debt upon the floor that holds it."

— Ninth Concordance, Annex 6, clause 2

The drafting of clause 2 was referred to the Curators of Lacunae, who returned it unamended and with a note observing that the Order had been given jurisdiction over silences retrospectively imposed, a matter the Curators of Lacunae consider their own. The objection was entered in the Docket of Lacunae in 3,116 and has never been withdrawn. The Order's position, stated in its standing reply, is that it does not judge whether a silence ought to have been imposed, only whether it has finished.

Procedure of certification

A silence is presented for certification by its holding floor, accompanied by a schedule of what has been withheld and a declaration that nothing remains to be withheld. The assigned Curator attends the silence in person, remains within it for a period of not less than one hour and not more than nine, and afterwards submits a finding. The finding is either complete, incomplete, or — a category added in 3,402 after lengthy dispute — complete but still in use.

The third category was devised by Registrar Halven Marrow, who encountered on Floor 4,061 a silence that had plainly ended but which the floor's readers continued to occupy out of habit. Marrow's finding is quoted in the Order's instructional recension and remains the standard example of the category: "The silence is finished. It is being sat in." Certificates in this category carry a note advising the holding floor to air the room.

Certification is not free. The Order levies a fee of two marks per hour of attendance, waived where the silence exceeds nine hours, on the reasoning that a silence too large to inspect is a silence the Order cannot be blamed for.

Dispute with the Curators of Suspension

The Order's most persistent difficulty is its boundary with the Curators of Suspension, who maintain Floor 5,712 and whose brief covers objects held deliberately between states. A silence that has been deferred rather than ended falls, on the face of it, within both briefs. The Fourth Concordance, clause 41, assigns deferred silences to the Curators of Suspension; the Ninth, Annex 6, assigns all unattested silences to the Order. Both clauses remain in force.

Matters came to a head in the winter of 3,377, when the Order certified as complete a silence on Floor 5,712 that the Curators of Suspension had been holding open for a scheduled resumption. The resumption was attempted and found nothing to resume. The Curators of Suspension brought the matter before the Concordance chamber, which declined to resolve it and instead commended both bodies for their diligence. The silence has since been reimposed and is now held under joint attestation, with the certificate signed by both Registrars and countersigned by neither.

Relationship with neighbouring orders

The Order works alongside the Curators of the Still Air, who certify the quality of air within a silence and whose findings the Order treats as advisory. It has no standing with the Curators of the Still, who execute Cessation Orders and with whom the Order exchanges only formal notices. Relations with the Custodians of the Gilded Silence are correct but cool, the Custodians having declined in 3,350 to submit their holdings for certification on the grounds that gilding is itself an attestation.

The Order's own view of its place in the Guild is set out in the preamble to its standing rules: "We do not make silence and we do not keep it. We say when it is done." The Curators of the Loom have cited this formula in their own recensions as a model of jurisdictional restraint, a compliment the Order has not acknowledged.

Records

The Order keeps a register of every silence certified since its foundation, bound in nineteen volumes and held in the Aural Lacunae Archive. The register records, for each entry, the floor, the hour of attendance, the finding, and the name of the attending Curator. Entries in the third category are marked in red ink. Since 3,402 the register has also recorded whether the silence was aired, and by whom, though the column is frequently left blank.

Volumes twelve through fourteen were water-damaged in 3,290 and have been reconstructed from the Order's fee book, which is less detailed but survived. The reconstruction is marked throughout with a marginal note reading inferred. The Order considers the reconstruction authoritative. The Curators of Lacunae do not.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Curators: who are they?

Curators are administrative officers within The Tower responsible for the maintenance, interpretation, and defense of a specific subset of its holdings. Their authority is derived from the Curators Guild and codified acr…

Curators
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …

Ninth Concordance
Aural Lacunae Archive: where is it?

The Aural Lacunae Archive is a specialized repository on Floor 9090 administered by the Aural Division of the Curators of Lacunae, dedicated to the classification and containment of aural lacunae—instances where silence …

Aural Lacunae Archive
Curators of the Still: who are they?

The Curators of the Still are a specialized order of Librarian sworn to the maintenance, interpretation, and, when necessary, suppression of catalogued states of absolute cessation. Their primary jurisdiction encompasses…

Curators of the Still

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.