The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Moderation Decree

MS 2190.63 · Documents and ordinances

A Moderation Decree is a formally titled document issued by a Moderator of Record that establishes a single, binding record superseding contradictory entries. Unlike the Concordances, which accumulate amendments in layers and are expected to conflict, a Moderation Decree is intended to leave exactly one account standing. It does not reconcile the archive; it removes the rivals. The distinction is regarded as fundamental by the Librarians and as a distinction without a difference by nearly everyone else who has had to work under one.

"Where two entries contend, the Decree does not weigh them. It appoints one survivor and grants the other the dignity of having never been written."

— Ordinance of Single Record, Clause 6

Origin and instrument

Moderation Decrees are among the older instruments of the Tower, predating the systematic numbering of floors and considerably predating the Decree of Luminous Stewardship family, whose annexes later borrowed the Decree's form without its authority. The earliest surviving example, the Moderation Decree of the Ninth Landing, was issued to resolve a dispute over the length of a corridor that had been recorded as both forty paces and thirty-eight by two Survey Chapters working the same winter. The Decree did not measure the corridor. It declared the corridor thirty-eight paces and struck the forty-pace survey from the register, whereupon the corridor became thirty-eight paces within the year, as corridors do.

A decree is written on a single sheet, never on a roll, and is signed only by the Moderator of Record presiding. It requires no countersignature and admits no appeal. The seal used is the plain embossed seal of the issuing office rather than the chased seals of the decrees in the Luminous Stewardship line, a fact that clerks of the scriptorium have cited for four centuries as evidence of the Moderation Decree's seniority, and that clerks of the Office of Seals have cited for four centuries as evidence of the issuing office's poverty.

Procedure and the doctrine of plenitude

A Moderator of Record may issue a decree on any subject that has accumulated two or more irreconcilable entries. The procedure is short. The Moderator reads the entries, chooses one, and writes it as the record. Everything else is then described in the register as having been "moderated," a term whose meaning the Glossary of the Ninth Floor gives as "set aside; retained in the archive; not to be consulted; still, of course, present."

This last qualifier has caused the instrument's principal difficulty. Moderated entries are neither destroyed nor moved. They remain where they were shelved, in the same hand, on the same paper, and are frequently rebound into the same volumes. A decree therefore does not remove a contradiction so much as give the contradiction a rank. Conditionalists argue, with some textual support, that the Moderator's act is prospective only, and that a reader who encounters the moderated entry first is under no obligation to notice the decree that follows it. The Second Concordance on Precedence, Annex 2, takes the opposing view: "The record is moderated from the moment of its moderation backwards, and the reader is mistaken, not misled."

Notable decrees

The Moderation Decree of the Ninth Landing remains the standard example in the Tower's teaching manuscripts. Of greater consequence was the Moderation Decree on the Measured Shelf, issued in the winter of the year recorded as 4411, which fixed the depth of the shelf at a single measured value and thereby suspended a great deal of survey work then in progress. Its relationship to the Decree of the Measured Shelf is a matter of persistent confusion; the two are unrelated documents that share a name, and the Catalogue of Annexes notes that they have been misbound together eleven times.

The most contentious is the Moderation Decree of the Clasped Gauntlet, so called for the seal it bears, which moderated no fewer than two hundred and six competing entries concerning the position of a certain stairhead. The Curators of Resonance were consulted on the decree's vibrational implications and returned a finding, Resonance Finding 88-C, that the decree was sound but should not be read aloud on the stair in question.

The unread decrees

Moderation Decrees are not printed in the ordinary sense and are not distributed. A decree takes effect on signature. Readers learn of it by discovering that an entry they had trusted is no longer correct, and by inquiring, and by being shown the sheet. The average interval between signature and first consultation was recorded by the Bureau of Inquiry as nine years and four months, a figure that has risen steadily since the Bureau began keeping it.

The practical consequence is that a great many moderated entries remain in daily use. The Office of Correct Use has recommended since 4402 that a Moderator of Record announce each decree by striking the moderated passages in red, but the recommendation has never been adopted, on the ground that the archive does not permit a record to be altered after shelving. The Office's own copy of the recommendation bears a red strike through its third paragraph.

Disputes

The central disagreement concerns whether a Moderation Decree can itself be moderated. The Fourth Concordance holds that it cannot, since the instrument would otherwise have no terminal state, and that a decree's only remedy is a later decree on a different subject. The Concordance of Amended Records, Annex 9, holds that it can, and cites the celebrated case of a Moderator of Record who issued a decree and, on finding his own earlier decree on the same matter still standing, moderated both and issued a third, which was later found to be the first read backwards.

A lesser dispute concerns naming. The Registrar of Decrees maintains that every Moderation Decree is the Moderation Decree and that the titles in common use are annotations rather than names, a position that would require the re-cataloguing of some six thousand sheets and has accordingly been deferred at each of the last fourteen sittings. In the meantime, decrees are cited by their distinguishing feature, and the register records that no two have yet collided.

The sheets are kept flat, in the north stacks, in boxes of forty. They are not to be folded.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Concordant Law: how is it conducted?

Concordant Law constitutes the primary, and some argue the sole, legitimate basis for formal governance within The Tower. It is distinguished from advisory precedent and temporal regulation by its derivation from, and am…

Concordant Law
Moderator of Record: who are they?

The Moderator of Record is the certified professional within the Librarian order tasked with supervising the resolution of mutually exclusive assertions within the Tower's holdings, employing a specialized and non-public…

Moderator of Record
Decree of the Measured Shelf: what does it set out?

Decree of the Measured Shelf, formally catalogued as Annex Gamma, Subsection 14(b) of the Obsidian Decree, is the primary regulatory instrument governing the proper dimensional assessment, classification, and periodic re…

Decree of the Measured Shelf

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.