Manual of Coexistent Protocols
MS 3129.51 · Documents and ordinances
Scope and standing
The Manual of Coexistent Protocols is the governing document for the maintenance of the Gilded Quandary, and sets out the duties of the Vowed Librarians charged with its upkeep. It is held on the shelf designated for operational rather than theoretical works, though this placement has been disputed at least twice (see Manual of Recursive Adjudication). The Manual's central obligation is that the Quandary be preserved in a state of productive tension — a phrase it does not define, and which successive recensions have declined to clarify. The Manual is not a Concordance and does not purport to be one. It nonetheless settles arguments more often than most Concordances do, largely because few readers finish it.Relation to the Manuals of adjacent scope
The Manual sits in a cluster of documents whose boundaries overlap inconveniently. Manual of Coherent Cataloguing governs the filing of holdings that agree with one another; the Manual of Coexistent Protocols governs those that do not, or that agree only intermittently. The dividing line between coherent and coexistent is the subject of the Long Shelf Dispute, which the Office of Stairwell Calibration attempted to settle by re-measuring both shelves in 1988 and produced two different answers. Its Part II is frequently cited alongside Part II of the Manual of Contradictory Protocols, and readers are advised that the two are not interchangeable. Contradiction implies mutual exclusion; coexistence does not. A passage in Manual of Sigillation notes that this distinction "has been honoured more consistently in headings than in practice."Productive tension
The Manual's operative concept is productive tension: the deliberate maintenance of a state in which incompatible holdings remain simultaneously accessible without either being retired. The Vowed Librarians are not required to resolve the incompatibility, and are in fact discouraged from attempting to. The practical difficulty is determining when tension ceases to be productive. The Manual offers a test — a holding is productive while it continues to generate new cross-references — and leaves the threshold unspecified. Floor 17, where coexistent contradiction is the filing principle, has operated under this test continuously since the Third Concordance was amended; the resulting index is 41 volumes long and is itself filed under two incompatible headings.Disputed passages
Two passages are the subject of standing disagreement. The first concerns whether the Doctrine of Coexistent Potentialities falls under the Manual's remit. Division VI: Unallocated Phenomena holds that it does, on the grounds that an unmaterialised subject is by definition in productive tension with its materialisations. The Manual's own annotators have generally held that the Doctrine is a matter of potentiality and belongs to Tier 2 review regardless of what any operational manual says. See Doctrine of Coexistent Potentialities for the current state of the disagreement, which is not resolved. The second concerns Annex 4. Annex 4 was added in a later recension and describes a procedure for temporarily releasing tension in order to re-establish it. The procedure has been attempted twice. The first attempt, on a winter morning in a minor stairwell off the Quandary's eastern approach, produced no lasting change and a memorandum of complaint from the Office of the Senior Clerk. The second attempt produced lasting change.Readers have noted that clause 2 is generally cited in support of whichever position the citing party already held."Where tension is released in order to be restored, the restoration is the original tension or it is nothing; and if it is nothing, the Manual's duties are discharged by not beginning."
— Manual of Coexistent Protocols, Annex 4, clause 2
Administration
The Manual is maintained by the Vowed Librarians under the ordinary Concordance authority for operational documents. Certification to apply it is not separately examined, though familiarity is presumed of anyone already certified on the Manual of Surface Protocols or assigned to the Gilded Quandary proper. Amendments are recorded in the Manual's own endpapers rather than in the Concordance series, which has occasionally led to two versions of the same clause being cited in the same hearing. Copy C of the Manual is kept near the Quandary's northern entrance and is not to be taken upstairs.See also
-
MS 3226.75
Transfer Floor 7-Theta
Transfer Floor 7-Theta is a licensed subsidiary Nexus within the Transfer Floors complex, notable for being the only designated la…
-
MS 0617.06
The Principle of Reciprocal Negation
The Principle of Reciprocal Negation is a standing interpretive rule of the Tower holding that any proposition negated twice is re…
-
MS 9426.12
Great Re-Wiring of 658
The Great Re-Wiring of 658 was the systematic replacement of the Tower's original braided-cord electrical and aetheric lighting ci…
-
MS 8880.97
Coexistent Validity
Coexistent Validity is the archival principle under which two or more mutually exclusive titles to the same holding are permitted …
-
MS 9238.13
Doctrine of Coexistent Status
The Doctrine of Coexistent Status is a tenet of Tower classificatory law holding that a single holding may occupy several administ…
-
MS 8140.27
Fade Assessment Amp Restoration
The Fade Assessment Amp Restoration (FAAR) is a specialized apparatus and procedural protocol used within the Bureau of Registry t…
Referenced by
- MS 7265.76 Doctrine of Coexistent Potentialities
- MS 9238.13 Doctrine of Coexistent Status
- MS 5661.08 Restoration Wing
- MS 6434.48 The Seventh Annex of Dialectical Tension (Floor 14,922)
- MS 8880.97 Coexistent Validity
Readers also asked
Doctrine of Coexistent Potentialities: how is it conducted?
The Doctrine of Coexistent Potentialities is a cardinal archival principle governing the status of unobserved or unmanifested states and entities within The Tower. It posits that the potential for a thing to exist consti…
Doctrine of Coexistent PotentialitiesManual of Recursive Adjudication: how is it conducted?
The Manual of Recursive Adjudication is the standing procedural code governing the complex web of interlocking protocols for Implementation, and the principal authority from which the Precept of Attentional Recession and…
Manual of Recursive AdjudicationManual of Sigillation: what does it set out?
The Manual of Sigillation is the principal codex governing the application and maintenance of official sigils within the archival continuum of the Tower. Its protocols define the material, procedural, and interpretative …
Manual of SigillationCoexistent Contradiction: how is it conducted?
Coexistent Contradiction is the filing principle under which holdings on Floor 17 are maintained, and the formal name for the Tower's practice of retaining two mutually exclusive records of the same subject in the same p…
Coexistent ContradictionPassages cited from this record
-
Where tension is released in order to be restored, the restoration is the original tension or it is nothing; and if it is nothing, the Manual's duties are discharged by not beginning.
Manual of Coexistent Protocols, Annex 4, clause 2
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 9437.71 Office of the Senior Clerk
- MS 7224.03 Manual of Surface Protocols
Because you consulted