Librarian’s Dilemma
MS 5517.70 · Practices and doctrines
The Librarian's Dilemma is the collective designation for the class of procedural impasses arising when a Librarian must choose between two duties that the Concordances place in equal standing and forbid from being weighed against one another. It is distinguished from the Pedestrian's Dilemma — which concerns bodies in corridors rather than obligations in scriptoria — and it is not a single event, though the phrase is frequently used in the singular to mean the Whispering Stacks episode of 1,187 A.C., the occasion on which the term entered general use and to which Annex 12.C, Section 3 owes its drafting. The Dilemma is treated by the Recursive Amendments Office as the parent form of several later difficulties, including the Dilemma of Concurrent Verity and the standing problem of Precedence Dilemma.
Definition and scope
The Dilemma is defined in the working papers of the Office by what it is not. It is not doubt, which resolves; it is not error, which can be amended; and it is not conflict between two Librarians, which is settled by seniority under the Fourth Concordance so long as both parties are present and neither is reading. It is, rather, the condition of a single Librarian held simultaneously by two affirmative obligations whose performance is mutually exclusive and whose precedence is, by explicit provision, undetermined.
"Where two duties are of one grade and neither yields, the Librarian shall not choose, nor delay, nor delegate; the Librarian shall stand."
— Third Concordance, Annex 7, clause 4
The instruction to stand is literal. Standing is recorded as a distinct procedural state, distinguished from waiting (which is timed) and from suspension (which is minuted). A Librarian who stands is not idle and may not be reassigned; the post is held open, the desk lamp remains lit, and a junior may not sit in the chair. On the Long Gallery floor a standing has been maintained since 1,341 A.C., interrupted only once, for forty minutes, by a fire.
Origins: the Whispering Stacks
The event that gave the Dilemma its name occurred on Floor 88 during the winter of 1,187 A.C. The Stacks on that floor had begun to whisper — a known phenomenon of the period, since attributed to draughts through the ventilation shafts of the Seventh Spiral — and two Concordances bore directly on the correct response. The Concordance of Quiet required the immediate sealing of any collection heard to speak. The Concordance of Access forbade the sealing of any collection still under request. The shelves in question were under request by a Librarian of the Third Order who had asked for them and could not, by the Concordance of Access, withdraw the request without the materials in hand.
Seventeen Librarians stood. The episode is recorded as having lasted nine days, though the Whispering Stacks themselves fell silent on the fourth, which did not resolve the standing and is not believed to have shortened it. The consequential instrument, Annex 12.C, Section 3, was drafted the following spring; its principal innovation was to permit a Librarian to act under either duty provided the action was retrospectively recorded as having been compelled by the other, a device that relocated the dilemma from the Librarian to the record and was received with general relief.
Relationship to the Problem of Precedence
Scholarship of the Ninth Recension holds that the Librarian's Dilemma is a specimen of the broader Problem of Precedence, and that the Whispering Stacks episode is best read as an early instance of the confusion arising from multiple amendments to a single annex. Against this, the Office maintains in its Memorial of Standing Duties that the Dilemma is prior to all questions of precedence, since precedence asks which duty binds and the Dilemma arises where both already do. Junior Librarians are taught the dispute in their second term and are permitted to adopt either position, though not both.
The distinction is not academic. Under the first reading, a standing may be ended by demonstrating that one duty is of lower grade than the other. Under the second, it may not, and the only exits are the annex mechanism or death. The Omega-12 Precedence Edict attempted a third exit — a standing of sufficient duration was to be deemed an amendment of the Concordance that caused it — but was itself amended before it could be applied, and its amendment amended, and it is now cited chiefly as the reason the Office of Unintended Concordance meets only quarterly.
Notable standings
A census of active standings is maintained by the Office and has never been completed, since the act of census-taking creates a new duty for every Librarian counted. The following are the standings most often cited in the literature.
- The Long Gallery — sustained since 1,341 A.C.; the Librarian has not spoken and communicates by marginal note.
- Floor 1,009 — a standing of 1,406 A.C., arising from simultaneous invocation of the Edict of the Sealed Spiral and the First Edict of Lamps; unresolved, as the Sealed Spiral is not believed to have an interior.
- The Scriptorium of the Lesser Seal — six standings, all on the same morning, by Librarians who had been told to consult one another.
- The Thirtieth Hundred — recorded as standing in the registers, though no Librarian has been found on the floor since 1,212 A.C.
The Thirtieth Hundred entry is the subject of the only known attempt to end a Dilemma by inspection. A Librarian-Proctor was dispatched in 1,290 A.C. to confirm the standing and reported on arrival that the floor was empty, the lamp unlit, and the chair pushed in. The Proctor's report was filed as a standing in its own right, and the Proctor has not filed since.
Criticism and the abolition question
A minority position, most fully argued in the Pamphlet of the Forty-One and associated with the Sixth Librarian, holds that the Dilemma is not a genuine difficulty but a drafting failure preserved by reverence, and that the proper remedy is not annexes but the amendment of the Concordances so that no two duties of equal grade may bind one desk. The argument has been made at every Convocation of Stacks since 1,244 A.C. and has never been put to a vote, since the procedural rule governing the vote itself presents a Dilemma of the same class.
The Office's settled reply is that the Dilemma is not an impediment to the Tower's work but its most reliable instrument, since a Librarian who stands is a Librarian who cannot be made to do anything else, and the records of standings have proven the only sound defence against several annexes. The reply is recorded in the Second Memorial of Standing Duties and is quoted in the margin of Annex 12.C, Section 3, in a hand the Office declines to identify.
See also
-
MS 8413.93
The Dilemma of Concurrent Verity
The Dilemma of Concurrent Verity is a foundational procedural paradox within the Tower's administration, formalized by the Seventh…
-
MS 2727.33
Forty-Sevenfold Dilemma
The Forty-Sevenfold Dilemma is the collective designation for any dispute in which forty-seven mutually exclusive readings of a si…
-
MS 5720.59
Antinomy Alpha (The Archivist's Dilemma)
Antinomy Alpha (The Archivist's Dilemma) is a standing procedural impasse arising from the interaction of a cataloguing obligation…
-
MS 2881.05
Synod
The Synod is the central deliberative and archival authority of Librarian governance within the Tower, charged with the generation…
-
MS 5457.11
Impasses as permanent dimensional faults
The classification of Impasses as permanent dimensional faults is a doctrinal position holding that an Impasse is not a procedural…
-
MS 7508.90
Impasse (I-)
Impasse (I-) is the administrative designation applied to impasses that arise from the mutual reference of two or more valid proce…
Referenced by
- MS 4313.33 Precedence Dilemma
Readers also asked
Ninth Recension: what does it set out?
The Ninth Recension is the collective designation for the body of amendments, consolidations, and administrative reforms promulgated under a single seal between A.T. 1469 and A.T. 1476, and the only recension in the Towe…
Ninth RecensionLibrarian-Proctor: who are they?
Librarian-Proctor is an administrative and juridical rank within the Proctorate, subordinate to Proctor-General and superior to Junior Librarian and Librarian-Scribe. A Librarian-Proctor directly oversees a specific divi…
Librarian-ProctorOmega-12 Precedence Edict: what does it set out?
The Omega-12 Precedence Edict is the twelfth registered instrument of the Series Ω (Omega) Edicts, promulgated in the winter of the year recorded in the register as 3,118 by the Office of the Issuance of a Precedence Edi…
Omega-12 Precedence EdictPedestrian's Dilemma: how is it conducted?
The Pedestrian’s Dilemma is a canonical procedural paradox encountered by pedestrians navigating the inter-floor corridors of the Tower, wherein adherence to one applicable Concordance necessarily results in the violatio…
Pedestrian's DilemmaPassages cited from this record
-
Where two duties are of one grade and neither yields, the Librarian shall not choose, nor delay, nor delegate; the Librarian shall stand.
Third Concordance, Annex 7, clause 4
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6656.76 Convocation of Stacks
- MS 0930.90 Floor 1,009
- MS 2064.66 The Thirtieth Hundred
- MS 0327.83 Concordance of Access
Because you consulted