Justifications for Temporal Anchoring
MS 7928.23 · Documents and ordinances
The Justifications for Temporal Anchoring is a document of the Division of Temporal Consistency, now held in eleven fragmentary recensions and one partial summary, which sets out the reasoning by which the First Concordance was selected as the non-arbitrary administrative origin for the TSC epoch. No complete copy survives. The longest single recension, Recension Delta, breaks off mid-clause at the words "and therefore, since no earlier instrument can be shown to have been—", and the remainder of the argument is known only from a marginal rebuttal in the Second Concordance, which quotes it in order to disagree.
That a document so poorly preserved should remain load-bearing is a matter of some irritation within the Division. Form P-9.4 — the instrument by which a Chain of Non-Origin is initiated — requires the applicant to cite the Justifications in a dedicated field, and the Manual of Referential Protocol advises that the citation be given "with sufficient precision to survive the loss of a further two recensions." The advice is generally ignored. The Office of Spiral and Aperture Records returns an estimated four hundred Forms P-9.4 annually on the ground that the applicant has cited "the Justifications, in general."
Contents of the surviving recensions
The argument reconstructed from the fragments proceeds in three movements. The first establishes that an administrative epoch must be anchored to an instrument rather than to a person, a season, or a natural event, on the ground that instruments are dated and persons are only remembered. The second sets out the criteria by which a candidate instrument is to be judged: it must be sufficiently old to precede all disputes about it, sufficiently recent to be legible, and sufficiently dull that no one has troubled to amend it. The third applies these criteria to the instruments then available and finds all wanting except the First Concordance.
The third movement is the most fragmentary and the most contested. Recension Beta retains the clause "and the First Concordance is dull to the point of silence," which is the only surviving sentence in which the criteria are applied to the eventual choice with anything like approval. The corresponding passage in Recension Eta calls the same property "a silence that will not hold" and the surrounding context is lost.
"The candidate instrument must be older than the dispute it settles, and the dispute must be older than the clerk who raises it, and the clerk older than the room, and the room is not part of the argument."
— Justifications for Temporal Anchoring, Recension Delta, f. 41r
Use in the Rite
Because the Rite of Temporal Anchoring may be performed only in a Primary Vestibule, the Justifications is rarely consulted in the place where it is most needed. The vestibules hold no document cases; copies must be requested in advance, and the request is itself a form of nine pages. The Division of Temporal Consistency has twice proposed that the relevant extracts be carved into the vestibule lintels of the Fourth Spiral, and twice withdrawn the proposal after the Division of Rites and Fabric objected that the lintels are not structural and the extracts are not short.
Practitioners in the field have evolved a workaround. In an anchoring conducted on the Floor of Low Water in 1187 TSC, the officiating Librarian Berrin the Elder recited the whole of Recension Delta from memory, at the door of a vestibule that had been locked for the winter, and declared the rite performed. The resultant anchor held for a term and two-thirds. The Office of Anchoring Discipline later found the procedure irregular but not void, and the finding has been cited in every subsequent case of a rite performed against a closed door.
Dispute: number and order of the recensions
The recensions are conventionally numbered by the order of their copying in the Little Scriptorium, and the copying order is set out in a register that the Scriptorium itself describes as "provisional, since 1180." The eleventh recension, styled Eta, is numbered after two recensions that the Scriptorium had provisionally numbered Nu and Omicron, and the Deputy Registrar of the Spiral has declined to reconcile the sequence, on the ground that the sequence is a finding of the office and not a property of the documents.
The Division of Contextual Anchoring has taken a different position. Its Catalogue Board has ruled that any recension numbered after Eta cannot be reliably dated, and that the Justifications cannot be cited as the sole authority for any anchor laid before the present date, since a document of uncertain order cannot be a document of certain age. The Division of Temporal Consistency does not accept that this ruling is within the Board's gift. It has continued to accept citations from the recensions indiscriminately, and a proposed amendment to the Third Concordance on the point has been standing on the order paper for eleven years.
The Anchoring Register holds a note, unsigned, rubbed almost to the paper, reading: "The whole question is whether the document was dull before it became short, or dull because it became short. The former is a disaster. The latter is a filing problem."
Requirement
Form P-9.4 requires, in addition to the citation, the applicant's Librarian's spiral and aperture, and these have themselves been checked against the recensions in two cases of disputed apostrophe and one case of a duplicate recension filed under the aperture of the actinic lamp. The form is not accepted in any other format, and the corrected version must be returned to the Office of Spiral and Aperture Records by hand. Applicants are reminded that the office is closed on the first day of the TSC year, when the First Concordance is read aloud in the Long Shaft and no one is admitted or excused.
See also
-
MS 9246.46
Temporal Anchoring
Temporal Anchoring is the formal practice by which an object, record, or floor is fixed to a stated date of origin, so that subseq…
-
MS 8595.05
Cross-Referential Anchoring
Cross-Referential Anchoring is a procedural discipline within the Department of Cataloguing Consistency, employed to stabilize hol…
-
MS 7593.84
The Division of Temporal Consistency
The Division of Temporal Consistency is a regulatory body chartered under the Third Concordance to ensure all internal processes, …
-
MS 9013.50
Proactive Anchoring
Proactive Anchoring is an anchoring procedure in which a term is secured to a designated floor before the floor has been observed …
-
MS 9767.41
Manual of Temporal Cartography
The Manual of Temporal Cartography is the standing procedural handbook of the Subbureau of Temporal Reconciliation, issued in rece…
-
MS 7405.10
Conceptually Fragmentary
The designation Conceptually Fragmentary is a legally recognized status under the Fifth Concordance, Annex 4, Clause 12(b). This s…
Referenced by
- MS 4312.13 Chain of Non-Origin
- MS 9246.46 Temporal Anchoring
- MS 4762.38 Fragmentary Holdings
- MS 6430.13 Rite of Temporal Anchoring
Readers also asked
Fourth Spiral: where is it?
Fourth Spiral is the designation of a major vertical sector of the Tower, bounded below by the unnamed vestibule of the Lower Coils and above by the sealed lintel of the Gallery of Un Light. It is the only spiral whose i…
Fourth SpiralChain of Non-Origin: how is it conducted?
Chain of Non-Origin is a procedural framework within the Provenance of Holdings system that treats the absence of a verifiable external source as a formal, documented pedigree for an object or concept catalogued within T…
Chain of Non-OriginDivision of Temporal Consistency: who are they?
The Division of Temporal Consistency (DTC) is the primary regulatory body charged under the Third Concordance with ensuring all internal processes, cataloguing durations, and perceived flows of time adhere to Temporally …
Division of Temporal ConsistencyForm P-9.4: what does it set out?
“The perfect form is one that has been lost, then found in triplicate.” — Librarian Second Class Aris Thorne, marginalia on a recovered draft of Form M-7b (Rev.)
Form P-9.4Passages cited from this record
-
The candidate instrument must be older than the dispute it settles, and the dispute must be older than the clerk who raises it, and the clerk older than the room, and the room is not part of the argument.
Justifications for Temporal Anchoring, Recension Delta, f. 41r
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7004.31 Office of Spiral and Aperture Records
- MS 8856.40 Berrin the Elder
- MS 7969.49 Office of Anchoring Discipline
- MS 4807.52 Catalogue Board
Because you consulted