The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Index of Auditory Phenomena

MS 8418.65 · Practices and doctrines

The Index of Auditory Phenomena is the Tower's secondary finding-aid for sound-based subjects, maintained on Floor 2 041 by the Office of Indexical Reception under licence from the Auditory Permit Office. It is distinct from, and perpetually confused with, the older and larger Index of Harmonic Anomalies, a confusion the Index has never formally contested and has never quite corrected. Where the Harmonic Index records pitch, timber and periodicity, the Index of Auditory Phenomena records only whether a phenomenon was heard, on what floor, and by how many witnesses — a deliberately narrower brief adopted in 4 117 after the Harmonic Index was found to contain 900 pages of entries for a single draught in the Whispering Stair.

Function and place in the auditory cycle

The Index sits downstream of Auditory Cataloguing and upstream of the Resonance Index, acting as the interim register through which a confirmed phenomenon must pass before its Catalogue Number is struck. A phenomenon enters the Index only after completion of the Auditory Phase and must not be entered on the authority of a single witness, except where the witness is a Receiver of the second grade, in which case a single account suffices and a second account is treated as confirming evidence of the first.

Entries are made in duplicate, one leaf for the Index proper and one for the Grand Ledger of Auditory Potential, where unconfirmed phenomena wait under the anomaly heading. The scribes of Floor 2 041 refer to this practice as the paired hand, though the phrase appears in no Concordance and its use has twice drawn a reprimand from the Auditory Permit Office.

Dispute over the Index's founding

The Index does not agree with other offices about its own origins. Annex 4 to Concordance 47 fixes the Index's commencement at the winter of 4 088, citing a recension held in the Vestibule seal-room. The Auditory Proscriptions office has since annotated this clause twice, first in 4 146 and again in 4 203, on both occasions to move the date earlier.

A minority view put forward by the Office of Indexical Reception argues that no Concordance can establish what a document is, only what it may not do, and that the Index's competence therefore derives from usage rather than from any numbered clause. The argument has never been formally answered. It has been formally recorded, at length, in the margins of Annex 4.

"An index that dates its own beginning by reference to a regulation may, upon inspection, be found to be regulating rather than beginning."

— attributed to the Marginal Recension of Concordance 47, Annex 4, hand unknown, seal illegible

Admission of an entry

A phenomenon is admitted to the Index when its witnesses agree that it was heard on a named floor, that it possessed a beginning and an end, and that it did not arrive from an adjoining entry. Disagreement over the last point accounts for the bulk of the Index's backlog. The Vestibule of Auditory Phantoms retains the substance of contested cases while the Index retains only the question, so that a reader may find an entry recording a dispute over a phenomenon that the Index itself no longer holds.

In the winter of 4 318 the Index admitted a phenomenon described by no fewer than forty-one witnesses as occurring in the Whispering Stair and corresponding to no stair in the survey. The entry was struck in 4 320 and restored in 4 322. The Index has not, in its own account, ever removed an entry; the strike of 4 320 is described in the register as a recess, and the marginal note reads only, "Resumed under the same number. The stair was there. 4 322."

Relationship to adjacent holdings

Readers frequently arrive at the Index seeking the taxonomic classification of an auditory phenomenon. That description lives with the Auditory Phantasma Taxonomy, not here. Similarly, entries for sounds reported during dream-states are referred to the Oneiric Resonances register and are not indexed by floor, since the floors concerned are not consistently held to exist. The Index's own holdings contain a cross-reference to Impossible Lullabies and no explanation of it.

Where a phenomenon has been denied a subject altogether, the Index points to the Index of Denied Subjects, which maintains its own numbering and, by long convention, refuses to correspond with this Index in writing. The two indexes have not reconciled their numbering since 4 091.

Physical description

The Index is kept in twelve folio volumes, bound in a green cloth that has been described by no one as pleasant. Each volume carries a gilt number on the spine and a second number, unexplicated, on the fore-edge. The fore-edge numbers do not run in the spiral order of the volumes and have never been read together with them; a note pasted into Volume VII reads, "The fore-edge is not for reading. It is for placing."

Volume XII, which covers the disputed period from 3 990 to 4 088, has been missing since at least 4 167, when its absence was first noticed. Its place on the shelf has been maintained, dusted weekly, and shown to visiting Librarians, who inspect the gap without comment and mark the inspection in a register kept for that purpose alone. The Index's own entry for Volume XII reads, "Not consulted. It is not necessary to consult it."

A summary inventory of the volumes currently shelved, exclusive of Volume XII:

  • Volumes I–VI: floors 100–1 800, with annex material in a separate folio.
  • Volumes VII–XI: floors 1 801–2 040, including the Vestibule annex, and the paired hand from 4 122 onward.
  • Volumes IX–X: floors 3 300–3 302 only, a span the Index defends as disproportionate.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Index of Denied Subjects: what does it set out?

Index of Denied Subjects, officially designated as Corpus Rejectorum by Clause 12.7.a, is a dynamic triennial register maintained by the Scriptorium of the Fixed Ladder. It catalogs entities, phenomena, and conceptual fr…

Index of Denied Subjects
Receivers: what is it for?

Receivers are a distinct class of auditory phenomena classified under Auditory Anomalies and governed by the stipulations of the Thirteenth and Forty-Second Concordances. They are defined as permanently silent Apertures …

Receivers
Auditory Anomalies: how is it conducted?

Auditory Anomalies encompass all phenomena of sound, vibration, and related perceptual effects whose ontological status is unresolved or contested within the administrative framework of the Tower. Governed primarily by C…

Auditory Anomalies
Grand Ledger of Auditory Potential: what does it set out?

The Grand Ledger of Auditory Potential (GLAP, Tower Designation: Ledger-413-α) is the canonical and exhaustive register of all phenomena whose existence is contingent upon or validated by the principle of Auditory Confir…

Grand Ledger of Auditory Potential

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.