The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Folio Anomaly Assessment Register

MS 1899.96 · Practices and doctrines

The Folio Anomaly Assessment Register (FAAR-A) is the secondary register maintained by the Office of Volumetric Assessment for folios whose classification cannot be settled at first inspection. It is distinct from the earlier Frequency Anomaly Assessment Register, to which it is frequently confused and to which it is procedurally subordinate. Entries in the FAAR-A record the folio's assigned designation, the date of suspension, the assessing officer, and — where applicable — the reason the folio was returned to circulation unclassified. The Register has been kept in continuous if uneven series since folio 9,300 of the Interior Cataloguing Series and is presently bound in eleven volumes, the eleventh remaining open.

Origins and the dispute of the ninth volume

The FAAR-A was instituted following the assessment of Algernon’s Folio, which could not be entered into either the contained series or the general holdings on account of its returning inconsistent page counts on successive examinations. The examiner of the day, a junior assessor named Mireille of the Third Aperture, proposed a holding register for folios "which are not what they were when first they were written down" — her phrase, recorded at folio 9,301 — and the proposal was accepted under Concordance 44, clause 7, without debate.

The ninth volume is the subject of a prolonged disagreement between the Office and the Scriptorium of the Lower Stacks. The Scriptorium holds that volume nine was closed in the winter of the year recorded as 3,142 and sealed with the crimson cord; the Office maintains it was never closed at all, and that the cord belongs to volume eight. The matter has been referred twice to the Concordance Bench and remains unresolved, with the practical consequence that folios entered between those dates are filed in both volumes. Neither volume has been consulted for assessment purposes since 3,151.

Procedure of entry

A folio is entered in the FAAR-A when two assessors independently disagree as to its contents. The disagreement need not be material: in the Echoing Folio matter the entry was triggered by a difference of one word on a single leaf, and in the Ξ-909 Folio by a disagreement as to whether a leaf existed at all. The entry is made in triplicate, the third copy being retained by the assessing officer personally and not lodged with the Register, a practice the Office has defended as "consistent with the usage of long standing" (Office of Volumetric Assessment, circular of 3,166) and which the Amendment Logging Register records as never having been formally adopted.

Entries are numbered in sequence and annotated with the volume and folio of first suspension. Where a folio passes through the Register more than once, the later entries carry the mark recurrent; where it passes through more than four times, the mark habitual, and the folio is thereafter assessed only at the close of each catalogue year. Eleven folios presently carry the habitual mark, of which seven are blank.

Relation to the ghost-inscription categories

The FAAR-A is often cited alongside the Frequency Anomaly Assessment Register because both employ the classification benign echo. The two registers do not agree on what the term denotes. In the Frequency Register, a benign echo is a faint mark of uncertain provenance; in the FAAR-A, the same classification is applied to a folio that produces a faint mark of uncertain provenance on inspection, the mark ceasing when the assessor looks away. The Office has declined to reconcile the definitions, noting in its circular of 3,170 that the registers "serve different floors and need not speak the same language." Hesperus of the Unbound Folio has argued the opposite in the Deferred Holding Register, contending that a term used in two registers without reconciliation is not a classification but a courtesy. The Office has not replied.

Known irregularities

Three entries in volume six are recorded in a hand not otherwise attested in the Register, and the assessing officer named against them — one Corvin Ash, Assessor — does not appear in the personnel rolls of the Office for any year. The entries themselves are unremarkable and concern folios since reclassified. The Office's position, stated in a marginal note at folio 6,404, is that the hand is "an earlier form of the same hand" and that the officer's absence from the rolls is a matter for the rolls.

In 3,178 an assessment team returned from Floor 71 with an entry already written in the Register in their own names, dated four days before their departure. The return was recorded as a Reception Anomaly and the Atrium cleared for assessment; the entry was allowed to stand. It remains the only entry in the FAAR-A with a date preceding its own commission, though the Register of Reversed Causality carries it also, at folio 12,114, under a different designation.

Access and present condition

The Register is consulted in the presence of a duty assessor. Readers may not turn more than two leaves without pausing, a rule introduced after the incident of 3,155 and never rescinded. Photographic reproduction is permitted for volumes one through five only; volumes six through ten may be copied by hand, and the eleventh may not be copied at all, on the grounds that it is not finished.

The Office has twice proposed amalgamating the FAAR-A with the Frequency Register into a single consolidated series, and twice withdrawn the proposal, in 3,161 and again in 3,174, in each case after discovering that the two registers disagreed as to how many entries the consolidated series would contain. The current Keeper of the Register, Anselm Vey, has stated that he will not put the question a third time, and that the eleventh volume will be closed when it closes.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Volumetric Assessment: who are they?

The Office of Volumetric Assessment (designated OVA in internal correspondence) is the administrative body responsible for the practical execution and adjudication of Volumetric Assessment, the quantification of spatial …

Office of Volumetric Assessment
Register of Reversed Causality: what does it set out?

The Register of Reversed Causality is the authoritative ledger of incidents and artifacts proven to exhibit reversed temporal causality. It is maintained by the Department of Material Causality as a sub-register of the P…

Register of Reversed Causality
Reception Anomaly: how is it conducted?

Reception Anomaly denotes any significant deviation from the standard procedures and environmental conditions of Floor 120, the primary reception floor for returning descent and ascent teams. Governed by Annex C of the D…

Reception Anomaly
Algernon’s Folio: what does it set out?

Cross-reference: Algernon’s Folio is distinct from the Algernon-Haversham Thesis, the Folio of Perpetual Inventory, and the notional Spectral Folio. It is also not to be confused with the designated Red Folio series.

Algernon’s Folio

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.