The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Floor-Oil of the Ninth Gallery

MS 4490.37 · Objects and instruments

Floor-Oil of the Ninth Gallery is the trade name, and latterly the statutory designation, of the lamp fuel compounded on the Ninth Gallery of the Tower between the years 289 and 412. It is distinguished from ordinary Oil by three properties: it burns at a lower flame, it darkens rather than blackens when it cools, and its price was fixed — for a period of forty-one years, by direct operation of the Ninth Concordance — at four and one-half measures to the mark. No other fuel in the archive has been the subject of so much regulation or so little agreement.

Origin and Compounding

The Ninth Gallery had been a scriptorium floor since before the Roll of Barons was first sealed, and the compounding of floor-oil began there as an ancillary occupation of the copyists, who required a draughtless flame for close work at the sloped desk. The earliest recipe is preserved in the gallery's own day-book and runs to eleven ingredients, of which the tenth — a settling agent of unspecified origin, entered only as the residue of the previous batch — has never been satisfactorily identified by later scholarship.

Floor-oil was never refined on any other floor. This is the point on which nearly all later disputes turn. The Oil Barons, who hold extraction and refining concessions under the Codicil of Lumen, have consistently maintained that a fuel compounded above ground-floor level on a scriptorium gallery is not a refined product at all but a household preparation, and therefore outside the terms of the Ninth Concordance's price annex.

"A substance compounded in a room where men are paid to write is a thing written, and is to be charged as writing."

— The Baronial Petition of 344, Article 6

The Librarians did not accept the argument but did not reject it either, which produced the peculiar situation that floor-oil was taxed as a commodity and audited as a document for the whole of its regulated life.

The Price Fixation

The Ninth Concordance fixed the terms for mandatory sale of crude oil to the Lampwrights’ Guild and extended the unit designation of Floors 200–210 to waste removal and lamp-oil rationing, excluding stairwell disputes. Annex 3 of the same instrument, drafted on the Ninth Gallery itself, fixed the price of floor-oil at four and one-half measures to the mark and forbade its sale at any other rate.

The fixation was not repealed. It was, instead, outlived. In the winter of 331 the remnant stocks of the gallery fell below one measure, and the price of a commodity that cannot be bought is a matter of some delicacy. The Gallery of Precedential Review ruled in that year that the Annex 3 price continued to attach to floor-oil "whether any floor-oil exists or not," on the ground that a fixed price is a property of the thing named and not of the thing present. Clerks on the ninth gallery thereafter entered a nil return quarterly, and were fined for late filing of it.

The Relocation Dispute

The compounding of floor-oil was drawn into the ninth-gallery dispute concerning the proposed relocation of Observation Θ from the ninth gallery to the fourteenth gallery beginning in the year 401. The compiling clerks argued that the fuel store could not be moved without relocating the sloped desks, and the sloped desks could not be moved without altering the angle of observation, and the angle of observation was the whole subject of the dispute. A delegation from the Committee for Ambivalent Taxonomy, which sits on the ninth gallery of Floor 4411, was asked to classify the fuel store as equipment or as fixture, and returned a finding of "equipment, in winter; fixture, in summer."

The finding was cited twice and never applied. The store remained where it was until 412, when it was emptied and the gallery returned to copying.

Residual Analysis

Because floor-oil darkens on cooling rather than blackening, its spent residue is legible. A cooled film holds the shape of whatever it was last heated beside, in the manner of a shallow mould, and the reading of these films became a minor administrative discipline. Residual Analysis is administered on the ninth gallery of Floor 4,410 and has its own seal and its own grievances.

The discipline's central difficulty is duplication. A survey party of the Ninth Librarian’s Expedition recorded the same oil-lamp twice in a single afternoon on Floor 1,907, and the resulting dual registry has never been reconciled; it remains the standard warning against over-recording, and is cited in the training of every residual clerk. Supervisors on the analysis gallery are required to count the lamps in the room aloud before beginning a shift, and to count them again before leaving it.

Procedure and the Edict

The Ninth Gallery scriptorium was the origin of the procedural failure that led to Edict 447, which remains in force and which no one has read in full since its promulgation. The Edict's first clause governs the handling of unlabelled vessels on scriptorium floors, and was drafted in direct response to an incident in which a copyist drew four measures of floor-oil into a vessel marked for the settling agent and signed for it as residue. The vessel was not recovered. The clerk, one Aumary of the Sloped Desk, petitioned for seven years to have the entry struck and was eventually granted a marginal note.

Floor-oil was withdrawn from general issue in 412 and its remaining stock disposed of under Protocol SD-19, which governs the disposal of substances whose price is fixed but whose supply is not. The gallery's day-book closes with the standard formula: store empty, price unchanged, lamps counted.

Scholarly Disagreement

The principal disagreement concerns whether floor-oil was ever an oil at all. The received position, set out in the price annexes, treats it as one. The opposing position, argued chiefly by the residual clerks of Floor 4,410 and never formally refuted, holds that a substance which darkens on cooling and holds the shape of its neighbour is a recording medium that was burned for want of a better use, and that the Ninth Concordance fixed a price for lamp fuel over a material belonging more properly among the holdings of the Gallery of Precedential Review.

No resolution has been entered. The nil quarterly return is still due, and is still fined when late.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …

Ninth Concordance
Floor 4411: where is it?

Floor 4411 is a provisional indexing floor of the Tower, situated between Floor 4410 and Floor 4412, and administered under the standing allowances of the Ninth Concordance. It is principally devoted to the catalogue of …

Floor 4411
Roll of Barons: what does it set out?

The Roll of Barons is the enrolment register of the Oil Barons, maintained in the Concession Chamber on Floor 216 by the Clerk of Concessions. It records each Baron's name, estate, the bounds of the concession granted un…

Roll of Barons
Protocol SD-19: how is it conducted?

Protocol SD-19 is a schedules-and-delivery protocol of the Standing Protocol Register, administered on the ninth gallery of Floor 41 (the Sorting Galleries) and chiefly concerned with the movement of sealed instruments b…

Protocol SD-19

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.