The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Fact 188 (The Silent Bell)

MS 9758.13 · Objects and instruments

Definition

Fact 188 (The Silent Bell) is the one hundred and eighty-eighth entry in the Standing Register of Established Objects, and concerns the bell in the Northwest Carillon of Floor 1201. Its operative clause records that the bell rings every hour with a sound of perfect silence. The entry is among the most frequently cited in the Register, and among the least agreed upon in its interpretation.

Fact 188 was inscribed during the consolidation of the Register under the Eleventh Concordance, and has been amended four times without the original wording being struck. The current text therefore contains, superimposed, both the pre-amendment assertion that the bell "sounds hourly" and the amendment's substitution of "a sound of perfect silence." Both are read aloud when the Fact is invoked. This is not considered an error.

Text and citations

The operative text, as recited under Determination 102, runs:

"The bell of the Northwest Carillon, Floor 1201, rings each hour. Its ring is a sound of perfect silence, which is to say, it rings and no sound is heard, which is to say the ringing is complete."

— Fact 188, clause 1, as amended by Eleventh Concordance, Annex C

The Inquest of the Silent Bell spent eleven sittings on the relative order of the second and third clauses. The faction holding that "which is to say" introduced a definition was ultimately outvoted by the faction holding that it introduced a consequence, though the Silent Choirs record both readings as concurrent in their own minutes.

Relation to Specimen 881-422

Fact 188 is frequently confused with, and occasionally deliberately conflated with, Specimen 881-422 ("The Silent Bell"), the brass bell held in the Anechoic Galleries. The distinction is maintained by the Office of Auditory Custody and is considered material: the specimen is silent by reason of its crystalline structure, whereas the bell of Fact 188 is silent by reason of its ringing. The former does not ring; the latter rings constantly and unheard.

Attempts to apply the custody provisions of Case File 2001-44/B: The Silent Bell to the Northwest Carillon have been refused on four occasions, most recently under the reasoning that an object whose audible state changes hourly cannot be assigned a fixed jurisdictional category. See Dispute over the Silent Bell Harmonics.

Disputed points

Three matters remain unresolved.

First, whether "perfect silence" describes the absence of sound or the presence of a particular sound. The Silent Choirs hold the latter, and have petitioned for the Northwest Carillon to be transferred to their jurisdiction on the grounds that it produces, hourly, a note of ceremonial significance. The petition was returned unmarked under Year of the Quiet Bell.

Second, whether the bell's hourly ringing can be observed. The Scribes of the Third Aperture maintained that observation was possible and merely uninformative; a visiting clerk was stationed on Floor 1201 through the winter of theAntinomy Omega-7 and reported, in sequence, forty-one hours of ringing. Their log was accepted as a record of the hours and rejected as a record of the bell.

Third, whether Fact 188 and Intrinsically Un-Rung describe the same object. The Concordances contradict each other directly on this point, and no recension has been issued to settle it.

Custody and access

The Northwest Carillon is maintained by the Keepers of Floor 1201, who are responsible for winding the mechanism and for recording the hour of each ring. Visiting hours are unrestricted, though readers are asked not to stand within the arc of the bell during a strike. The Anechoic Reliquary maintains a standing copy of Fact 188 at the foot of the carillon stair, so that a visitor arriving at an odd minute may confirm what is about to occur.

Under Determination 102, the Fact itself is classified as settled. Under the Eleventh Concordance, it is classified as provisional. Both classifications appear on the same plate, which is displayed.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Intrinsically Un-Rung: how is it conducted?

Intrinsically Un-Rung is an acoustic-philosophical classification of a bell whose capacity to produce sound is absent not as a matter of history or circumstance, but as a core, ontological property. Unlike a Silent Bell,…

Intrinsically Un-Rung
Dispute over the Silent Bell Harmonics: how is it conducted?

The Dispute over the Silent Bell Harmonics is the collective name for the long-running disagreement among the Acoustic Logistics Division, the Department of Temporal Harmonics, and the Silent Choirs concerning the harmon…

Dispute over the Silent Bell Harmonics
Determination 102: what does it set out?

Determination 102 is a supplementary ruling within the Third Concordance, issued by the Silent Choirs in the Year of the Silent Bell. Its primary function is to define custodial responsibilities and jurisdictional bounda…

Determination 102
Year of the Quiet Bell: what happened?

Year of the Quiet Bell is a designation officially applied to the 4,793rd year of Archive Reckoning, though its associated events are noted to have precipitated a calendar reset from the Year of the Silent Bell. The Year…

Year of the Quiet Bell

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.