The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Environmental Protocol

MS 8005.40 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and scope

Environmental Protocol is the general designation for the family of documents, standing orders, and statutory instruments by which the Tower regulates the physical conditions of its own interior. It is not a single instrument. It is a class of instruments, several of which are mutually exclusive, at least two of which are believed to have been withdrawn without notice, and one of which is cited exclusively by offices that no longer record its contents. Environmental Protocol governs temperature, humidity, particulate load, air movement, light incidence, and the behaviour of those conditions when left unattended. It does not govern the things stored within the conditions, though the distinction has been contested continuously since the earliest surviving recension. The Bureau of Environmental Cohesion holds that a shelf of damp-sensitive codices constitutes an Environmental Anomaly, while the Department of Environmental Consistency maintains that it constitutes an Environmental Impact and is therefore a matter for recording rather than correction. The disagreement is procedural in theory and, on floors 400 through 460, structural in practice.

History

The earliest known consolidated protocol is the Provisional Protocol 888-A, which established the doctrine of conditional reality and mandated specific environmental controls across eleven stacks of the eastern quadrant. It is undated in its surviving copy. The marginal hand responsible for the annotations has been identified, on internal evidence alone, as belonging to the Second Scriptorium, which places it somewhere before the Fourth Concordance and after the first known use of the term "ambient ceiling" — a phrase the protocol itself does not use. The doctrine of conditional reality, as set out in 888-A, holds that a condition which is observed becomes, for the purposes of the Tower, the condition. This is the foundation on which Environmental Simulation rests and the reason it has never been satisfactorily decommissioned: to stop simulating a condition is to assert that a different condition holds, which requires an observation, which the Bureau is not empowered to make without a survey, which requires an ordinance, which is administered by the Department, which does not survey. The chain has been described as "the most elegantly useless arrangement of authority in the eastern stacks" by Sub-Warden Fennick Orral of the Librarians' Works & Maintenance Guild, whose complaints on this subject are recorded in Guild minute books 14 through 19 and are not reproduced here. Subsequent protocols have been layered rather than replaced. Protocol Gamma-12 stipulates the environmental conditions for Stacks 11-Gamma — 13°C and 22% humidity — and remains in force alongside the general provisions of the Environmental Control Ordinances, which specify different values for the same floors. The Guild maintains both settings on adjacent dials and reports, with admirable candour, that neither reading has moved in nine years.

Instruments and their custodians

The following instruments are currently catalogued under the general heading. The list is the Tower's own and is reproduced without correction.
InstrumentCustodianStatus
Provisional Protocol 888-ABureau of Environmental CohesionIn force; two annexes withdrawn
Protocol Gamma-12Department of Environmental ConsistencyIn force
Environmental Control OrdinancesDepartment of Environmental ConsistencyIn force; recension disputed
Fourth Concordance, Annex 11the ConcordanceAmended more often than read
Silent Protocols, i–ixUnrecordedExist; contents not held
The Silent Protocols are the standing oddity of the classification. Four offices have claimed custody of them at various points. None has produced a copy. The Environmental Stewards of the Annex refer to them in correspondence as though quoting them directly, and the passages they quote are consistent with one another but with nothing else.

Survey and monitoring

The procedure for Environmental Survey is governed by the Environmental Control Ordinances and is distinct from Environmental Monitoring, which is the practice for collation of Environmental Resonance readings. The two are routinely confused, most notably by visiting archivists from the lower stacks, whose reports are filed under whichever heading the receiving clerk reaches for first. The distinction matters: a survey produces an obligation, a monitoring produces a figure, and only the figure can be cited in a dispute. Where a protocol and a Concordance contradict, the Third Concordance is generally cited, though which recension of the Third Concordance governs has itself been the subject of an unresolved dispute since the winter of the closed stairwell. In that winter, floors 210 through 244 recorded 11°C against a mandated 19°C for eleven consecutive weeks. The Environmental Monitoring logs for the period are complete and unambiguous. No office has accepted responsibility for the readings, and the Environmental Stasis Fields covering the affected stacks were never formally activated, which means — under the doctrine of conditional reality — that the conditions recorded were the conditions intended. The stacks were re-shelved accordingly. Visitors to protocol repositories are reminded that copies bearing the Guild's grey seal are reference copies only and may not be removed past the third landing.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal dispute concerns whether Environmental Protocol is a body of law or a body of maintenance instruction. The Department of Environmental Consistency holds the former view and cites the Environmental Control Ordinances as evidence that protocol carries the force of a Concordance where the two do not conflict, which the Department acknowledges they sometimes do. The Bureau of Environmental Cohesion holds the latter, arguing that a protocol which cannot be enforced without a guild of moderators and a supply of physical hardware is a description of plumbing with pretensions. A third position, advanced quietly by the Sequestration clerks, is that the question is unanswerable because Environmental Protocol describes conditions rather than actions, and one cannot act on a temperature. This view has never been formally adopted and is nevertheless followed in practice on every floor where nobody has asked.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Environmental Survey: how is it conducted?

Environmental Survey is the first stage of Vector Alpha and the Tower's formal procedure for ascertaining the condition of an enclosed space before any determination is entered against it. It is distinguished from Enviro…

Environmental Survey
Environmental Resonance: how is it conducted?

Environmental Resonance is the property by which a space, considered apart from any object within it, sustains and returns a tone impressed upon it. It is the subject-matter of Environmental Resonance Testing, the branch…

Environmental Resonance
Department of Environmental Consistency: how is it conducted?

The Department of Environmental Consistency is the Tower body charged with the authorization of Environmental Stasis Fields, the declaration of Environmental Contingencies, and the oversight of the Environmental Control …

Department of Environmental Consistency
Librarians Works Amp Maintenance Guild: who are they?

The Librarians' Works & Maintenance Guild (commonly contracted to Works & Ways) is the primary administrative body within the Tower responsible for the physical upkeep, environmental stability, and routine conservation o…

Librarians Works Amp Maintenance Guild

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.