Edict 9001-ω
MS 9359.59 · Documents and ordinances
Edict 9001-ω is a disciplinary instrument of the Librarian order concerning the conduct of readers in the Upper Reading Rooms, promulgated in the winter of the year 9001 and amended once, in circumstances set out below. It is not, despite the numeral, the nine-thousand-and-first edict of the Tower; the numbering of the ω-block was assigned retroactively by the Office of Sequential Repair and bears no relation to the order of promulgation. Edict 9001-ω is chiefly remembered for having been the first instrument to treat the returning of books as a matter capable of disturbing the peace.
Origin and promulgation
The edict arose from a disturbance on Floor 2,240 in the winter of 9001, when a party of eleven readers, having concluded a season of study in the north gallery, returned their borrowed volumes to the desk within the same hour. The resulting noise — described in the incident report as "a continuous and organised clatter, sustained beyond the tolerance of the room" — interrupted the transcription of a Concordance draft then in its fourth recension. The presider, Librarian Osme Cand, closed the gallery for six days and drafted the edict without consulting the Office of Sequential Repair, an omission later held to be irregular but not fatal.
Edict 9001-ω came into force on the eleventh day of that winter and was read aloud in three galleries. It has been read aloud in none since.
Principal provisions
The edict regulates the act of returning rather than the act of borrowing, on the reasoning — stated in its preamble — that borrowing is a private intention and returning a public event. It fixes the hours at which volumes may be surrendered at the desk, appoints a Keeper of the Returning Shelf to receive them, and requires that returns be spaced at intervals of not less than ninety heartbeats, counted by the Keeper and not by the reader.
It further provides that a volume returned outside the appointed hours is not returned but deposited, and passes into the custody of the Keeper until the next appointed hour, at which point it is deemed returned without further ceremony. Disputes over whether a volume was returned or merely deposited are heard by the Keeper, whose ruling is final and is not recorded.
Clause 9, the edict's most cited provision, forbids the returning of more than four volumes by a single reader in a single hour. It reads:
"Let no reader present to the Keeper a fifth volume while the fourth is yet upon the shelf, nor stand in expectation thereof; for the shelf is not a place of assembly."
— Edict 9001-ω, clause 9
Clause 9 has been enforced twice. On the first occasion the reader was warned and the volume confiscated. On the second the reader was warned and the volume confiscated.
Relationship to other instruments
Edict 9001-ω was promulgated under the authority of Spire Edict 44-, the same instrument under which Edict 45-A was issued, and disputes have arisen over which of the two governs where their provisions touch. The matter is settled by Precedence Edict 22/1, which gives Edict 590 priority in cases of overlap and which was itself amended under the same instrument; practitioners have long noted that the Precedence Edict resolves the question without ever reaching Edict 9001-ω, an omission the Edict of Compensatory Reference was written to address. That edict, a Series Ω edict and thus governed by the Series Ω instrument on filing, directs that the three be cited together where the returning of volumes is at issue.
The First Edict of Lamps provides more detailed regulation of the lighting of the Upper Reading Rooms and is generally read alongside Edict 9001-ω, though the two were drafted a considerable distance apart and refer to different galleries.
The dispute over clause 9
There is no settled reading of clause 9's phrase "place of assembly." The Office of Sequential Repair holds, in its marginalia of 9003, that a queue is not an assembly because it has a purpose, and that clause 9 therefore does not reach the practice of waiting in line at the desk. The Keepers' Bench, in an unpublished note circulated the following year, holds that a queue is precisely an assembly because it has a purpose. Neither body has authority over the other, and the question has been referred to the Librarians, who have not answered.
A third reading, advanced by Librarian Osme Cand in a memorandum that has been neither withdrawn nor adopted, proposes that the clause is concerned only with the shelf, and that readers may assemble anywhere they like provided they do not assemble there. This reading has the merit of consistency and the defect of permitting everything.
Amendments and later history
Edict 9001-ω was substantively amended once, in 9004, to extend the appointed hours by one hour in the winter months, following a petition from the night readers of Floor 2,240. A proposal to reduce the interval between returns from ninety heartbeats to sixty was rejected and has been reintroduced at every subsequent review without success.
By Concordance 771, the edict is among the instruments required to be displayed at the desk of every Upper Reading Room, together with a list of the appointed hours. The list is displayed. The hours have not been revised since 9004. Readers are asked not to lean on the shelf.
See also
-
MS 5263.46
Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality
The Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality is a standing instrument of the Librarians' archive, promulgated to prevent the cognitive st…
-
MS 9077.42
Librarian Conduct
Librarian Conduct refers to the codified principles, ordinances, and protocols governing the professional and personal deportment …
-
MS 8457.45
Ethical Defense
The Ethical Defense is a legal and procedural doctrine within the Tower’s administrative law that allows a party to cite a chronic…
-
MS 1355.69
Librarian-Taxonomist's Office
The Librarian-Taxonomist's Office is the administrative body of the Librarian-Taxonomist cadre, the order of certified readers emp…
-
MS 8191.23
Librarian of the Threshold
The Librarian of the Threshold is the officer of the Librarian Corps charged with the custody, interpretation, and periodic restat…
-
MS 1901.78
Decree of Apertural Containment
The Decree of Apertural Containment is a binding instrument of the Librarian Council, promulgated in the winter of the year record…
Referenced by
- MS 5283.17 The Directorate of Precedential Adjudication
Readers also asked
Series Ω edict: how is it conducted?
Series Ω edict is a designation for any formally issued Edict whose classification symbol terminates with the Greek letter omega. As a Series Ω edict, it carries the highest order of precedence within Tower law, supersed…
Series Ω edictPrecedence Edict: how is it conducted?
The Precedence Edict is a regulatory instrument codified in Precedence Edict Protocol that formally resolves disputes of ordinal superiority between two or more official Tower documents. Its issuance establishes an immut…
Precedence EdictConcordant Law: how is it conducted?
Concordant Law constitutes the primary, and some argue the sole, legitimate basis for formal governance within The Tower. It is distinguished from advisory precedent and temporal regulation by its derivation from, and am…
Concordant LawEdict 45-A: what does it set out?
Edict 45-A, formally the Edict of Luminous Allocation, is a foundational Precedence Edict that governs the assignment and maintenance of standardized illumination fixtures across all catalogue floors of the Tower. It was…
Edict 45-APassages cited from this record
-
Let no reader present to the Keeper a fifth volume while the fourth is yet upon the shelf, nor stand in expectation thereof; for the shelf is not a place of assembly.
Edict 9001-ω, clause 9
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4199.10 Librarian Osme Cand
- MS 2854.28 Keeper of the Returning Shelf
- MS 3796.13 Keepers' Bench
- MS 2515.84 Floor 2,240
Because you consulted