Directorate of Quantitative Ontology
MS 4008.54 · Guilds, orders and offices
Scope and standing
The Directorate of Quantitative Ontology is an administrative organ of the Custodians of Measurement, charged with the assignment, retention, and revision of numerical values to entities catalogued elsewhere in the Tower. Its stated function is narrow: to ensure that every quantity bearing a Measurement seal corresponds, at the moment of affixing, to the entity it describes. Its actual function, as recorded in the Forty-First Concordance, Annex 9, is "to decide, in cases of dispute, which of two incompatible figures shall be permitted to remain in circulation."
The Directorate is seated on Floor 883, a floor whose number is disputed by the Bureau of Provisional Ontology on the grounds that halves are not properly floors. The dispute has been pending since the drafting of the Manual of Jurisprudential Ontology and is generally considered unresolvable without amending the numbering scheme itself, which no office has yet been empowered to do.
History
The Directorate was constituted in 4,412 by consolidation of three smaller desks: the Desk of Retained Figures, the Desk of Withdrawn Figures, and the Desk of Figures Nobody Had Asked For. The third desk was dissolved in 4,419 after its entire holdings were found to consist of a single number, 7, recorded against an entity that no longer appeared in any index. The figure was not withdrawn. It was reclassified as an Applied Forensic object and remains in the archive under seal.
Relations with the Office of Quantitative Verification have been formal but frosty since the incident of the Winter of Recounting, in which the Office rejected 3,118 Directorate figures in a single season on the grounds that they had been "assigned while the underlying quantity was still moving." The Directorate replied that quantities are always moving and that the Office's position, if adopted, would leave the Tower without figures at all. The Oversight Committee for Quantitative Integrity declined to rule, noting that its own charter did not extend to the metaphysics of motion.
Correspondence
The Directorate maintains active correspondence with the Custodians of Static Artifacts and the Custodians of the Aperture, both of which hold that quantities affixed by the Directorate acquire permanence upon contact with an artifact or an aperture. The Directorate does not accept this position in writing but has twice declined to deny it, in 4,433 and again in 4,451. The Bureau of Quantitative Esoteria has objected on the record that quantities "in motion" are its own jurisdiction and that the Directorate's retention of moving figures constitutes an encroachment; the objection is filed under the Bureau's Index of Regrettable Omissions as item 1,204, which is itself an omission and therefore cannot be cited without contradiction.
Method
Figures are assigned by a process the Directorate calls provisional settling. A quantity is observed, a value is proposed, and the value is held in abeyance for a period determined by the Third Concordance — ninety days in the case of lengths, one year in the case of counts, and "until further notice" in the case of anything described as a degree of intensity. During the abeyance the figure may be cited but not enforced. At the close of the period the figure is either sealed or withdrawn.
In practice the sealing is frequently deferred. The Directorate's ledger for Floor 1,204 records 41 figures still under abeyance, the oldest of which was proposed in 4,388 and concerns the width of a corridor that has since been widened twice. The figure has been cited in eleven separate disputes and enforced in none.
"A figure held in abeyance is not a wrong figure. It is a figure whose time has not come."
— Directorate of Quantitative Ontology, procedural memorandum, 4,429
Disputes
The principal standing disagreement concerns whether the Directorate or the Guild of Quantitative Idealists holds authority over the singular optimal value of a phenomenon. The Guild holds that every phenomenon possesses one true quantity, discoverable; the Directorate holds that quantities are assigned, not discovered. The two positions have coexisted without resolution for so long that the Subcommittee on Procedural Ontology has classified the disagreement itself as a procedural matter, placing it beyond the reach of either party's substantive arguments.
Separately, the School of Jurisprudential Ontology has twice attempted to fold the Directorate's settling process into the Memorandum on Procedural Ontology, with the result that a figure's validity would depend on the order in which it was proposed rather than on its value. The Directorate has resisted on the grounds that this would make correctness a matter of queue position.
Notes on visiting
Visitors to Floor 883 are asked to leave their own figures at the stairwell. Pencils are provided; the Directorate does not supply erasers.
See also
-
MS 6789.84
Custodians of Tangibility
The Custodians of Tangibility constitute an administrative body tasked with the classification, measurement, and verification of t…
-
MS 4632.33
Guild of Quantitative Botanists
The Guild of Quantitative Botanists (GQB) is a chartered body of the Tower concerned with the enumeration, measurement and reducti…
-
MS 2802.42
Custodians of Coherence
The Custodians of Coherence are an administrative body responsible for quantifying, certifying, and maintaining the logical and ma…
-
MS 9374.08
Containment Protocol Assignment
Containment Protocol Assignment is the administrative act by which a catalogued subject, on being entered into the holdings, is bo…
-
MS 2714.93
Bureau of Appointments
The Bureau of Appointments is an administrative sub-directorate within the Department of Internal Affairs on Floor 3,127 (the Hall…
-
MS 1611.80
The Directorate of Apertural Integrity
The Directorate of Apertural Integrity is the branch of the Tower's administrative order charged with the maintenance, measurement…
Referenced by
- MS 5329.67 Static Measurement
Readers also asked
Oversight Committee for Quantitative Integrity: who are they?
The Oversight Committee for Quantitative Integrity is a standing committee of the Librarians concerned with the correctness of numbers as they are written rather than as they are measured. It is not to be confused with t…
Oversight Committee for Quantitative IntegrityOffice of Quantitative Verification: how is it conducted?
The Office of Quantitative Verification is a permanent body within the Bureau of Registry, charged with the arithmetic audit of figures already entered into the Tower's registers. Its mandate is underpinned by the core p…
Office of Quantitative VerificationApplied Forensic Ontology: how is it conducted?
Applied Forensic Ontology is a sub-discipline of the School of Jurisprudential Ontology, dedicated to the investigation of ontological anomalies and their causal or procedural vectors. Its practitioners, known as Forensi…
Applied Forensic OntologyBureau of Quantitative Esoteria: who are they?
“To know the names of things is a pleasure. To know their numbers is the only truth.”
Bureau of Quantitative EsoteriaPassages cited from this record
-
A figure held in abeyance is not a wrong figure. It is a figure whose time has not come.
Directorate of Quantitative Ontology, procedural memorandum, 4,429
Because you consulted