The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Dimming Index

MS 3737.43 · Practices and doctrines

The Dimming Index is a numerical scale, maintained since Tower Year 9,871, by which the depth and duration of a reduction in luminous signature are expressed as a single figure. It runs from 0.00 (no measurable reduction; the scale's custodians resist the term "full light") to 1.00 (complete withholding for a period not exceeding the term of the reading). Values are recorded to two decimal places; a third place may be noted but is not citable, and the Office of Unrounded Figures has petitioned against this rule at every recension since the Index was standardised, without success. The Index is not a measure of darkness as such. It measures the proportion of a holding's registered luminance that has been formally accounted for as absent — a distinction that has produced eleven centuries of argument and at least one duel.

Origin and standardisation

The Index was devised during the long inventory of the Upper Stacks that followed the collapse of the Fifth Recension of the Floor Ledger. Clerks recording intermittent failures in the reading-lamps of floors 4,012 through 4,088 required some common notation, and the scale now in use — degrees of tenths, subdivided by hundredths — appears complete in the working notes of the clerk Maude Vessel, who is generally credited with its arithmetic though never with its name. Formal adoption came by Concordance 21, which fixed the Index to the Attenuation Lens readings and declared that "no reduction of light within the Tower shall be recorded otherwise than by the Index, nor recorded at all until read twice" (Concordance 21, Clause 6).

Subsequent amendments altered the scale's application without altering its arithmetic. The most consequential was the Codification of 11,190, which extended the Index from lamps and lanterns to "any holding capable of a luminous signature," thereby bringing mirrors, polished stone, and certain documents under its authority for the first time. The extension was contested by the Guild of Signal-Keepers, whose members argued that a mirror is not a source and cannot therefore be dimmed; the Guild lost the point and, in 11,208, the argument.

Relationship to scheduled dimming

An Index reading is descriptive and carries no authority to act. Authority lies with a Notice of Scheduled Dimming, without which any reduction is irregular regardless of its Index value. This separation is frequently misunderstood, and much of the routine business of the Bureau of Attenuation consists of correspondence explaining that a reading of 0.74 does not require a Notice, while a planned reading of 0.31 does. Concordance 19 governs the procedure, and its Dimming clauses — pronounced by the Index Cantor at the Great Dimming ceremony — remain the standard formulary for any reading above 0.50.

The distinction was drawn sharply, and at some cost, following the Great Dimming of 11,304. The event had no Notice on file, and the Index readings taken during the eighteen-hour interval of 17–18 Nimbus, Cycle 11,304, were entered under a provisional heading that no recension has since regularised. The Master Index for Provisional Holdings retains them at 0.88, "for reference only, and with the reservation of the Luminist School as to their admissibility." The School, which studies and rectifies that event, has declined four times to accept the figure as final.

Dispute with the Office of the Index Cantor

A standing disagreement divides the Office of the Index Cantor from the Bureau of Attenuation over what an Index value measures. The Office holds that the Index registers a property retained by the holding — "once dimmed, a holding remembers its dimming" (Index Cantor's Instruction 14, Annex 2) — and that a later reading at or near 0.00 should be understood as the holding's recovered state, not as a different holding. The Bureau maintains that the Index has always measured present luminance as read, and that the Office's doctrine, if adopted, would require the Index to be re-taken across some forty thousand holdings and "would render the scale historical rather than descriptive" (Bureau memorandum, Bureau of Attenuation, folder 9/Lumen).

No Concordance resolves the point. Concordance 21 is silent; Concordance 19, read strictly, favours the Office; and a gloss added to Concordance 27 by the scribe Osric Pell appears to favour the Bureau only because Pell copied a clause from the wrong annex. The Retrograde Lumine controversy has lately attached itself to the argument, the Office contending that a retrograde reading must carry a higher Index value than the forward reading of the same surface, and the Bureau contending that this is not arithmetic.

Method of reading

Readings are taken by the Lens, twice, by two clerks, neither of whom may read in the other's presence. The readings are then compared in a third chamber; if they differ by more than 0.05 the pair is void and the reading is repeated, and if they differ by more than 0.20 the clerks are examined by the Standing Committee on Instrumental Doubt. Readings taken between the hours of Vespers and Compline are not admitted, on the ground that the Lens has been known to hold a charge overnight. Clerks carry their own wicks.

A reading is entered in the Master Floor Index against the relevant floor number, which — as the Index's custodians note with some weariness — is rarely the floor on which the reading was taken, since luminous signatures travel. On floors whose numbers cannot be reconstructed, the reading is entered against the nearest reconstructable floor and a marginal note is made. The note itself must be numbered.

Corrections and known deficiencies

Since the Codification of 11,190 the Index has been corrected downward seven times and upward twice, the most recent correction (11,288) arising from a miscalibration of the Lens following the relocation of the Central Index Column by some eleven feet. The correction affected 2,104 recorded readings, all of which were re-entered without alteration to their narrative entries, producing the unusual sight, in the Index registers, of a holding described as "dimmest of its corridor" against a corrected value of 0.12.

The scale's known deficiencies are three, and are acknowledged in its front matter: it cannot distinguish a dimmed source from a distant one; it cannot express a dimming that has not yet ended; and it cannot record a reading above 1.00, though eleven such readings have been submitted and are held, unnumbered, in the care of the Keeper of the Upper Register. The Grand Concordance Review last considered these deficiencies in 11,301 and deferred them to the following cycle, which was the cycle of the Dimming.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Master Floor Index: what does it set out?

The Master Floor Index is the principal registry of floor designations, names, and numerical assignments maintained for the whole of the Tower, held on The Index and administered jointly with the Master Index. Unlike the…

Master Floor Index
Central Index Column: what is it for?

The Central Index Column is the administrative, physical, and referential nexus for index management, as defined by The Index Column Protocol. It is the singular instantiation of the Index Column concept from which all p…

Central Index Column
Great Dimming: what happened?

The Great Dimming was a significant luminous disturbance occurring from 17–18 Nimbus 11,304, officially recorded as a mis-calibration of the annual annealing cycle. The event caused illuminated text within the Tower’s no…

Great Dimming
Retrograde Lumine: what is it for?

Retrograde Lumine is the luminous byproduct precipitated during defective cycles of Annealing in the Principal Luminous Conduits, and the substance generally held responsible for The Great Dimming of Tower Year 11,304. I…

Retrograde Lumine

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.