The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Department of Potential Traversal

MS 5658.19 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Department of Potential Traversal is a standing administrative body of the Tower responsible for the preliminary assessment and authorization of all non-routine vertical movement. It does not move anyone, and it does not maintain stairs. It determines, in advance, whether a given ascent or descent is a traversal that might occur, and issues findings accordingly. The Department occupies Floors 318 through 322 of the Western Stack, although its correspondence is dated from Floor 311, a discrepancy the Office of Discrepancy Management has classified as expected.

The Department was constituted by Seventh Concordance, Clause 7, which expanded the Tower's regulatory scope to include "the potential of traversal" — a phrase whose drafting history remains disputed but whose consequences are not. Its first Commissioner was Lysandra of the Unwritten Stair, who established the precedent for closing "potential traversal" files and, by that precedent, the Department's habit of never quite concluding anything. Clause 7 remains the Department's statutory foundation and is cited in the preamble of every finding it issues, whether or not the finding concerns traversal at all.

Mandate and method

The Department's work proceeds by assessment rather than inspection. A party proposing a non-routine vertical movement files notice with the Department, which assigns the matter to a Registrar of Potential, who rates the movement on the Departmental scale of likelihood. Ratings run from Nil to Approaching, in eight grades, and are stamped with the Stamp of Latent Potential in the presence of two witnesses. The stamp is applied to the notice, not to the traveller. It has never been established what happens if a traveller is stamped by mistake; the practice is to re-stamp the notice and record the error as Nil.

Where a movement is found to have been abandoned, the file is closed under Seventh Concordance, Annex Q, Paragraph 12, which requires a Form Q-12 for the formal abandonment of a potential traversal. Files not so closed are retained indefinitely. The Department retains approximately 41,000 open files, of which some 900 concern movements proposed before the current recension of the Concordances and therefore before anyone now employed by the Department.

The Commissioner's precedent

Lysandra of the Unwritten Stair served as Commissioner for thirty-one years and closed every file she touched. Her reasoning, recorded in the Department's first minute-book, was that a potential traversal kept open is a potential traversal unaccounted for, and that the Department's function was to account rather than to facilitate.

"The file that remains open is a stair that remains possible, and a stair that remains possible is a stair on which someone may yet fall. Close it. If they wish to fall, they may apply again."

— Lysandra of the Unwritten Stair, minute-book of the Department, first entry

Her successors have generally followed the precedent while disagreeing about what it means. The Office of the Pending has twice objected that closure under the precedent effectively pre-empts its own register of suspended matters, and on both occasions the Department has replied that a closed potential is not pending but concluded, which the Office of the Pending has called "a distinction without a file."

Relationship with the Empiricists

The Department's ratings were, for most of their history, a matter of the Registrar's judgement. This changed with Concordance 12/9, which constituted the Empiricists of the Calibrated Stair in the 1,104th year of the Concordance Register and empowered them to calibrate the instruments by which traversal is measured. The Empiricists hold that the Department's eight grades are not a scale but a vocabulary, and have proposed replacing them with a continuous index derived from the Potential Resonator Array on Floor 318. The Department has declined, noting that the Array's readings vary by as much as two grades when the west windows are open, and that the west windows are opened daily for ventilation.

A joint recension committee was convened on Floor 319 in the winter of the 1,137th year and sat for nine days. It produced a concordance of the two positions which both parties accepted and neither has since applied. The committee's chair, Registrar Ospreth Vane, recorded in his journal that the discussion had been "conducted in good order and produced a document of which the Department is justly proud," and that he had not read it.

Interaction with other bodies

Because the Department assesses movement before it occurs, its findings are routinely requested by offices whose work begins only afterward. The Department of Structural Verifications surveys established holdings for potential conceptual contiguity when a new unreality is accessioned, and will not begin a survey until the Department has rated the accession's approach. The Department of Anticipatory Acquisitions may invoke Anticipatory Phantoms by protocol where potential utility justifies provisional materialization, a procedure on which the Department's Nil rating is treated as a formality and, on at least four recorded occasions, ignored.

Movements through specified installations are governed by separate instruments and are outside the Department's ordinary assessment. Use of the Vanishing Stairwell requires an Intent of Traversal filed with the Custodian of Conditional Passage. Unsupervised traversal of the Canted Halls requires an Oblique Access Permit, which the Department neither issues nor recognizes but which it has been asked to countersign eleven times, and has countersigned twice.

Criticism and the 1,142nd-year audit

The Department's principal critics are the Office of Normative Pathways, which maintains that potential traversal is a category the Tower can do without, and that the Principle of Sequential Propriety already governs the order in which movements may occur. The Department's answer, repeated in every annual return since the 1,120th year, is that the Principle governs sequence and the Department governs possibility, and that the two cannot conflict because a thing that is not possible has no sequence.

The audit of the 1,142nd year examined 6,300 findings and found 5,911 of them consistent with the Department's own precedents. Of the remainder, 388 were traced to a single Registrar who had rated movements by the phase of the moon and defended the practice on the grounds that the Department's scale was ordinal. The Registrar was reassigned to the Incinerator of Lapsed Potential, where his methods attracted no further comment. The final finding of the audit, entered without remark, is that the Department's archive has no room for further shelving and that the next recension must be conducted on Floor 311, where the Department does not officially sit.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Discrepancy Management: who are they?

The Office of Discrepancy Management (ODM) is a sub-department of the Clerks of the Gap, created under the provisions of Concordance 7.4.12 and charged with the exclusive custodianship, maintenance, and procedural oversi…

Office of Discrepancy Management
Anticipatory Phantoms: how is it conducted?

Anticipatory Phantoms constitute a provisional ontological class of entities generated by the procedural machinery of The Tower in advance of a formal cataloguing decision. They are characterized by their existence withi…

Anticipatory Phantoms
Custodian of Conditional Passage: how is it conducted?

The Custodian of Conditional Passage is a local office of the Tower charged with receiving, registering, and adjudicating the Intent of Traversal, the instrument by which a petitioner declares a wish to use the Vanishing…

Custodian of Conditional Passage
Office of Normative Pathways: who are they?

The Office is the principal regulatory authority for Citation Mapping, tasked with defining and enforcing the “Normative Pathways” — the officially sanctioned sequences of bibliographic and archival traversal deemed stab…

Office of Normative Pathways

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.