The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance Clause 8812-Γ

MS 0095.52 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance Clause 8812-Γ is a standing provision of the Concordance Clause series governing the transfer of catalogued material between floors of the same vertical band. It is among the most cited clauses in the Tower and among the least read in full, a circumstance its own text anticipates and, unusually, excuses.

Text and structure

The clause runs to two sentences and an unnumbered closing paragraph. The operative sentence provides that no object entered on a floor register may be moved to a floor of a different band without a countersigned transfer slip, "the slip to be countersigned by whichever officer signed the register, or by the officer's successor, or, where neither is available, by the Keeper of the Transfer Ledgers." The second sentence sets the countersignature window at eleven days.

The closing paragraph is not numbered and has never been treated as operative, though the Bureau of Clause Numbering has twice declined to rule on whether it is. It reads:

"Where the eleven days have run out, the object remains where it is. This is the ordinary case and no fault attaches to anyone."

— Concordance Clause 8812-Γ, closing paragraph

The Γ designation distinguishes it from the earlier 8812- and 8812- recensions, neither of which survives in full; the Office of Recension holds only the numbering sheets.

History

The clause was drafted in the winter of the year the archive records as 5,904 following an incident on Floor 2,208, where a case of mineral specimens was moved ninety-one floors in a single season by four successive clerks, each acting on the authority of the clerk before and none of whom had signed anything. When the case was finally opened, six of its fourteen compartments were empty and the remainder held a quantity of gravel. The inquiry, convened under Third Concordance, Clause 22.1, declined to assign fault to any of the four, observing that "each acted as the register would have had him act" (Inquiry of Floor 2,208, Findings).

The drafters' solution was not to forbid transfer but to slow it. The eleven-day figure was chosen, according to the drafting minutes, "for the length of a stair and a half at a walking pace," which is the only surviving explanation of the number and is not arithmetically consistent with any stairwell the Tower has surveyed.

The countersignature dispute

A long disagreement turns on whether the countersignature validates the transfer from the moment the slip is signed or from the moment the slip is deposited. The Fourth Recensionists hold the former, and cite Concordance 47, Clause 9 — the shortest clause in that document, three words — in support. The Depositary Party holds the latter, and cites Seventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1 as amended by the Seventh Concordance, Clause 4.

The dispute has practical consequences only for objects in transit across the midnight bell, of which the Tower records an average of forty-one a year. Concordance 89, Clause 14 requires that any misrecitation arising under Concordance Clause proceedings be noted in the margin of the transfer slip itself, which the Depositary Party has taken as evidence that the slip has no force until deposited, since a document in transit cannot be margined. The Fourth Recensionists reply that the clause concerns misrecitation generally and not transit, and have filed no further argument since 6,113.

Application and exceptions

Concordance 12, Clause 7 formally defines Archivists with reference to the countersignature, and in doing so supersedes the earlier provisional definitions, including those in Third Concordance, Clause VII. The effect is that an officer who countersigns without authority does not merely act irregularly; the officer is not an Archivist for the purpose of the act, and the transfer is void, though the object's location is not thereby reversed. The Tower holds a standing inventory of roughly two hundred such void transfers whose objects are, in the language of the Ledger Office, "where they are and not otherwise."

Two exceptions are recorded. Objects wholly contained within a single floor — a fixture, a walled cupboard, a clerk's effects — fall outside the clause and may be moved by the floor's own authority. And the Temporary Maintenance Clause 882 permits limited movement without a slip during what it calls works, which it does not define, and which the Works Office has interpreted since 6,077 as including "the carrying of a thing from one end of a floor to the other in both hands."

Enduring effect

The clause's reputation rests less on its text than on its closing paragraph, which is quoted in the induction of every new clerk and has acquired a currency beyond its original scope. It is cited in disputes about unrecorded repairs, unmade appointments, and at least one question of inheritance. A gloss attributed to the Scriptorium of the Ninth Landing and now held to be a misrecitation under Concordance 88 F Clause 3 — and therefore noted under Concordance 89, Clause 14 — supplies the reading most often repeated aloud: "the Tower keeps what it keeps, and eleven days is eleven days." The Scriptorium has formally disowned the gloss. It remains in circulation.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…

Seventh Concordance
Concordance 88 F Clause 3: what does it set out?

Concordance 88 F Clause 3 is the provision of the Concordance 88 F concerning the recitation of unavailable subjects, and is the only clause of that document to have been amended by a floor resolution rather than by a su…

Concordance 88 F Clause 3
Third Concordance, Clause 22.1: what does it set out?

Third Concordance, Clause 22.1 is the first numbered sub-clause of Clause 22 of the Third Concordance, and the instrument by which the Office of Voluntary Correspondence derives its standing to open, read, and decline ma…

Third Concordance, Clause 22.1
Concordance 12, Clause 7: what does it set out?

Concordance 12, Clause 7 is the foundational administrative statute defining the role, qualifications, and primary duties of an Archivist within the Tower's bureaucratic hierarchy. Promulgated during the Ninety-Third Ses…

Concordance 12, Clause 7

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.