The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Conceptual Avian

MS 1154.42 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and Grade

Conceptual Avian is the classificatory designation applied within the Tower to birds — or bird-shaped entities — whose existence is sustained by an idea rather than by flesh, feather, or bone. The designation was fixed by Concordance 212, Annex 2, which distinguishes four orders of avian persistence: corporeal, residual, hybrid, and conceptual. A Conceptual Avian may be observed, counted, and appealed to, but it casts no registering shadow on standard conceptual scales and cannot be weighed on any balance certified above Floor 400.

Grades run from I to VI. Grade I entities are barely distinguishable from ordinary birds and are frequently miscounted by visitors; Grade VI entities are those whose sustaining idea is so narrow that they persist in only one location, one posture, or one hour of the day. The Solitude Finch remains the best-documented Grade VI specimen.

Origins and the Expungement

Scholarship on Conceptual Avians is inseparable from the Great Avian Expungement of Cycle 8,742, the most significant documented expungement event, in which a large portion of the Tower's avian registers was struck and subsequently found to be still occupied. The prevailing account holds that the expunged entries did not vacate their floors because the birds in question had never depended on the registers in the first place. What had been removed was the paperwork; what remained was the idea of the bird, which proved considerably harder to strike.

The Avian Liaison Office, chartered in Cycle 8,745 by Appendix E to the Ordinance of Avian Sanitation, was established in part to prevent a recurrence. Its earliest surviving circular, addressed to all floors north of the Aperture, concedes the difficulty plainly: "An entry may be expunged; an expectation may not," (Avian Liaison Office, Circular 3). The Avian Curators were not constituted until some four cycles later, a delay the Office has never satisfactorily explained in writing.

Detection and Counting

Conceptual Avians are detected chiefly by inconsistency. A floor census that returns one more bird than the number of birds observed is generally held to indicate a conceptual presence, and the discrepancy is recorded rather than corrected. The Bureau of Conceptual Reconciliation (BCR) maintains the discrepancy ledgers for this purpose and has ruled, twice, that a discrepancy may not be rounded.

Field practice varies by floor. Curators on Floor 413 favour the blind count, in which the observer records the number of birds heard and only afterwards the number seen; where the first figure exceeds the second, the surplus is entered as conceptual. This method is disputed. The Guild of Ornithological Anomalies argues that the blind count conflates conceptual presence with ordinary poor hearing, and its 1,140-page objection, lodged in the winter of Cycle 9,006, remains unresolved. The Guild's own method — the paired tally, conducted by two clerks who are forbidden to speak until both ledgers are sealed — has been criticised in turn for producing discrepancies of its own.

"Where two tallies disagree, the Tower has gained a bird. Where they agree, it has merely confirmed one."

— Guild of Ornithological Anomalies, Methodological Preface, 4th recension

Relation to Hybrid and Bound Forms

Conceptual Avians are distinct from the Avian-Silicate Hybrids of Gallery 7, Floor 5,442, which possess a mineral substrate and can therefore be swept. They are distinct also from bound mechanisms such as the Clockwork Oriole and the Clockwork Orioles of the eastern stair, whose persistence depends on maintenance rather than belief and which cease upon the removal of their escapements. The Index Hawk, formally recognised under Clause 4.2 of the Ordinance of Avian Sanitation, occupies an ambiguous position: it is conceptual in origin but has been granted a standing so durable that the Curators have declined to grade it, on the grounds that grading would imply a possibility of its lapsing.

Conceptual Avians are known to arise near deposits of Conceptual Soils and to be dispersed by Conceptual Seepage, a process observed most often in the lower galleries. Conceptual Blanching removes them entirely, though the treatment is discouraged on occupied floors. Floors so treated are posted for eleven days and no birdsong is to be reported during that period.

Disputed Status

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns whether a Conceptual Avian is a kind of bird or a kind of record-of-a-bird. The Curators hold the former, citing Concordance 212, Annex 4, which grants them authority over "all avian entities however sustained." The BCR holds the latter, and in Cycle 8,988 reclassified three Grade V specimens as archival furniture without consulting the Curators. The Curators appealed to Floor 411, where the matter was heard over four sessions and adjourned indefinitely on the ground that the specimens had, in the interim, been observed flying.

A minority position, advanced by the Clerk-Adjutant of the Ninth Recension and never formally adopted, proposes that the distinction is unnecessary: that every bird in the Tower is conceptual, and that the corporeal orders are simply those whose idea is old enough to have acquired feathers. The Avian Liaison Office has declined to comment on this proposal in writing, which the Guild has taken as a form of endorsement.

Inventory Notation

Conceptual Avians are entered in floor inventories under the standard abbreviation, with grade and sustaining condition noted in that order:

  • CA/VI — Solitude Finch, Floor 440, single-posture persistence
  • CA/IV — unnamed, Floor 411, auditory only, no manifestation recorded
  • CA/II — gallery flock, Floor 5,442, mineral-adjacent
  • CA/— — Index Hawk, ungraded by Curatorial abstention

Entries marked CA/— are not to be counted twice in the same cycle. Clerks who do so are asked to report to the Avian Curators on Floor 413 before the end of the shift.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Guild of Ornithological Anomalies: who are they?

The Guild of Ornithological Anomalies is a specialized subsidiary of Topographical Surveyor cadre VII-β, chartered under Concordance 312, Clause 19 to "identify, classify, and contain avian phenomena that manifest in vio…

Guild of Ornithological Anomalies
Conceptual Seepage: how is it conducted?

Conceptual Seepage is the unauthorized migration of conceptual properties across designated archival boundaries, recognized as a primary vector for Anachronistic Seepage and Conceptual Contamination. Governed by fluctuat…

Conceptual Seepage
Solitude Finch: what is it for?

Solitude Finch is a Grade VI Conceptual Avian and the central subject of the Case of the Singular Pigeon. Its primary manifestation is as an ashen-gray pigeon, approximately 28 centimeters in length, with a single, unbli…

Solitude Finch
Standard Conceptual Units: how is it conducted?

Standard Conceptual Units (SCU) are the fundamental scalar quantities by which the Tower measures conceptual mass, conceptual motility, and the residual charge of a blanched concept. Established by the early recensions o…

Standard Conceptual Units

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.