The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Clause 7 (The Principle of Open Texture)

MS 2889.35 · Practices and doctrines

Clause 7 (The Principle of Open Texture) is the seventh clause of the Protocol of Resonant Description and the instrument by which the Librarians require that every provisional classification carry, on its face, a marker of its own uncertainty. The clause is short — eleven lines in the earliest surviving recension — but it has generated more annotation than any other provision of the Protocol, and is cited more often than it is read. Its practical effect is that no floor, object, or category may be entered in the registers as settled until the marker it bears has been assessed, defended, and where necessary retired.

Text and structure

The clause as it presently stands comprises four operative sentences and an illustrative schedule. The fourth sentence is the one most frequently quoted, and the one most frequently quoted incompletely:

"Where a thing is catalogued before its nature is settled, the catalogue shall carry a marker, and the marker shall state how far from settled the thing remains. A marker that overstates certainty is a false entry. A marker that understates it is a warning, and is permitted."

— Protocol of Resonant Description, Clause 7

The distinction in the third and fourth sentences is the source of nearly all subsequent difficulty. The clause does not define "settled." The schedule appended to it offers five grades of marker — commonly rendered Provisional, Contested, Under Review, Held Open, and Unresolved — but declines to say what distinguishes the fourth from the fifth, and the marginal note on the subject in the Scriptorium of the Ninth Landing copy is illegible for a space of about six words.

Relation to Clause 4 and to the Principle of Perpetual Amendment

Clause 7 is read in tandem with Clause 4 (Marker Deployment), which governs the physical and procedural means by which markers are affixed. The two clauses are not in conflict so much as in different businesses: Clause 4 asks where the marker goes, Clause 7 asks what it must say. Disputes arise when the same entry is re-marked under Clause 4 without revisiting its grade under Clause 7, a practice known as silent re-deployment and expressly deprecated in the Annotated Protocol, Second Recension, though never actually prohibited.

Because of the Principle of Perpetual Amendment, no marker once affixed can be treated as final, since the text it qualifies remains open to revision indefinitely. The Librarians have never resolved whether this means the marker must itself be renegotiated whenever the Protocol is amended, or only when the entry it qualifies is re-examined. In practice both are done, by different offices, and the resulting markers frequently disagree. The Stack of Open Argument maintains a standing exhibit of thirty-one such disagreements, mounted in a single case, with the markers arranged in order of their divergence.

The Aesthesiometer dispute

The most sustained scholarly disagreement concerning Clause 7 arose from its application to aesthesiometers, the instruments used to measure the intensity, duration, and qualitative texture of perceptual absence. In the winter of the fourth recension, the Office of Provisional Records graded all aesthesiometric readings as Contested, on the ground that a device measuring absence could not certify the absence of its own uncertainty. The Bureau of Instrumental Confidence objected, arguing that the clause applies to catalogued things and not to the instruments by which they are catalogued, and that the Office had therefore marked the wrong object entirely.

The dispute was referred to the Concordance of Instruments, which found for the Bureau on a narrow point: that an aesthesiometer is a tool and not a subject, and tools are marked under Clause 4 only. The finding is widely regarded as having settled nothing, since the Office continued to grade its readings as before and the Bureau lacked the means to compel it. A note in the Office's hand, dated some eleven years after the finding, observes merely that "the instruments remain contested, and so do we" (Office of Provisional Records, Ledger 14, folio 206).

Criticism and the problem of the empty marker

A recurring criticism holds that Clause 7 permits an infinite regress: if the marker itself is a catalogued thing, it too requires a marker, and so on without terminus. The Third Concordance, Clause 22.1 is sometimes cited in support of a terminating rule, but that provision concerns the marking of annexes and does not reach markers proper. The Principle of Functional Equivalence has been proposed as a way out — a marker functionally equivalent to its own marker need not be duplicated — but the proposal has not been adopted and is contested on the ground that equivalence is exactly what the clause was written to avoid assuming.

The opposing school, associated with the Athenaeum of Open Questions, argues that the regress is not a defect but the clause working as intended, and that a classification which could be closed would not need marking in the first place. This view is influential and has never been voted on. A related difficulty, the so-called empty marker — a marker affixed to an entry whose grade has been left blank — is treated at length in Olfactory/Tactile Vacuums, where the blankness is itself shown to be measurable.

Practical observance

In daily use the clause is honoured chiefly by the addition of a marginal letter to the entry, indicating its grade, and by the entry's removal to a different shelf once the grade rises above Contested. Clerks are instructed not to erase a superseded marker but to strike it through once and leave it legible, so that the history of a thing's uncertainty remains on the record. Erasure is treated as a false entry under the third sentence and is dealt with severely.

The clause does not apply to the paving of the Cobbled Courtyard, which is settled.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Athenaeum of Open Questions: where is it?

Athenaeum of Open Questions is the colloquial designation for the complex of administrative chambers, archival stacks, and conceptual containment units comprising Floor 111: The Athenaeum of Open Questions. It serves as …

Athenaeum of Open Questions
Stack of Open Argument: what does it set out?

Stack of Open Argument is a permanent archival holding administered from The Argument on Floor 111: The Athenaeum of Open Questions. It consists of 3,742 distinct folios, each containing a single unresolved motion for on…

Stack of Open Argument
Third Concordance, Clause 22.1: what does it set out?

Third Concordance, Clause 22.1 is the first numbered sub-clause of Clause 22 of the Third Concordance, and the instrument by which the Office of Voluntary Correspondence derives its standing to open, read, and decline ma…

Third Concordance, Clause 22.1
Concordance of Instruments: what does it set out?

Concordance of Instruments is the collective designation for the standing instruments governing the making, sealing, depositing, and eventual retirement of instruments themselves — that is, of those objects the Tower tre…

Concordance of Instruments

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.