The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Classggamma Gtemporallygdeferredgimperatives

MS 1883.39 · Practices and doctrines

Classggamma Gtemporallygdeferredgimperatives are instructions lawfully issued within the Tower whose effect is suspended until a condition, a date, or a floor is reached, and which remain binding in the interim whether or not anyone remembers issuing them. They are catalogued as a class rather than a single instrument because the Bureau of Deferred Instruction holds them in quantity: at the last count of the Ninth Scriptorium, some eleven thousand four hundred were open, of which four hundred and six had been open so long that the conditions attached to them could no longer be read.

The class is conventionally abbreviated TDI in the margins of the Register of Pending Acts, though the abbreviation is not itself a Concordance form and may not be used in pleadings. The name is spelled without spaces in the catalogue and with spaces in the ledgers; the discrepancy has been noted and permitted.

Definition and admissible forms

An imperative enters the class when its operative verb is present, its object is specified, and its commencement is deferred by a recognised clause. The Deferment Schedule of Floor Nine recognises four such clauses: deferment until a named floor is reached; deferment until a named person is born, arrives, or ceases to be; deferment until a document is sealed a second time; and deferment until the issuers are all dead. The fourth is the most common and the most frequently litigated, since the Tower's record of deaths is kept floor by floor and no two floors reconcile it.

The class does not cover deferred permissions, deferred prohibitions, or deferred questions, all of which are held under Class Gamma Provisional Amp Unvalidated and are not to be confused with it. The distinction was settled in the winter of the counting year 2104 by the ruling in Marrow against the Sub-Librarian of Stairwell Omega, which held that "a permission deferred is a courtesy; an imperative deferred is a debt" (Eleventh Concordance, Annex 2).

Holding and custody

Deferred imperatives are filed on their issue at the Bureau of Deferred Instruction, which occupies three rooms off a landing on the ninety-first floor and has no windows facing inward. Each instrument is written out twice: once on the working slate, which travels with the reader, and once on the sealed quire, which does not. The sealed quire is the one that binds. The working slate is the one that is usually lost.

Where the two texts differ — and they differ in approximately one case in fifty — the sealed quire prevails. Clerks are reminded that the working slate is a convenience and not a record, and that writing a convenience in pencil does not make it revisable.

The Marrow ruling and its consequences

Before the Marrow ruling, deferred imperatives were enforced from the moment of deferment, on the reasoning that an instruction not yet due was still an instruction. This produced the Affair of the Unopened Door on floor 404 in the eleventh month of the counting year 2101, when a sealed imperative subsequently dated to the following century was enforced early against a porter who had done nothing but climb the stairs, and who spent nine days in the alcove below the landing defending himself with a broom handle. The broom handle is preserved in the Bureau's antechamber as a caution against premature execution.

Since Marrow, an imperative is held dormant until its condition is evidenced. Evidence is filed on the appropriate form, and a condition is not evidenced by recollection, by general agreement that it has occurred, or by the fact that everyone concerned feels it must have happened by now.

"No deferred imperative shall be read aloud on a floor to which it does not apply, nor carried through a floor on which it would be executable, save by a Clerk of the Second Grade or above and in daylight."

— Seventh Concordance, Annex 4, clause 19

Disputed doctrine

The principal disagreement concerns what happens to an imperative whose condition can never be reached, such as one deferred until the top of the Tower is attained. The School of the Standing Order holds that such imperatives bind eternally and accrue interest, and maintains a small office on the sixty-third floor devoted entirely to imperatives that will never ripen, which it refers to as the perpetual stock and treats with a certain reverence. The Revisory Party argues that an imperative with an unreachable condition is void at issue, and cites Irgnumbergampgdategofglogging in support, a citation generally regarded as unhelpful since the holding itself remains unread.

A third position, advanced by the late Clerk Anselm de Vesci, concedes that the imperative binds but denies that anyone can be punished for failing it, since failure requires opportunity. De Vesci's argument was accepted by no one and is now taught chiefly as an example of a position that is internally sound and externally useless.

Recorded open instruments

An inventory of the deferred imperatives most often inquired after, drawn from the Bureau's working slate and uncorrected:

The catalogue lists these together with their dates of issue, their issuing officers, and, in the column reserved for observance, the word pending. The column has not been altered in some two hundred years.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Class Gamma Provisional Amp Unvalidated: how is it conducted?

OrdinanceĠGamma-7,ĠAnnexĠC,ĠSectionĠ2.3:ĠâĢľAĠProvisionalĠAccessionĠNumberĠassignedĠpursuantĠtoĠtheĠProvisionalĠLoggingĠProtocolĠdoesĠnotĠconstituteĠvalidationĠofĠaĠholdingâĢĻsĠfinalĠclassification,ĠnorĠdoesĠitĠimplyĠthe…

Class Gamma Provisional Amp Unvalidated
Eleventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Eleventh Concordance is a foundational administrative document ratified in Year 45 of the Third Librarianate, primarily concerned with establishing procedural guidelines for the cataloguing of non-entities and govern…

Eleventh Concordance
Irgnumbergampgdategofglogging: how is it conducted?

The term Irgnumbergampgdategofglogging designates both a procedural fault and the office founded to record it. It arose on Floor 4,118, a floor of narrow scriptoria whose purpose is the copying of documents that have not…

Irgnumbergampgdategofglogging
Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…

Seventh Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.