Clarification 88-451 (The Matter of the Un-numbered Stair)
MS 2799.26 · Practices and doctrines
Clarification 88-451 (The Matter of the Un-numbered Stair) is a nine-leaf clarification issued by the Calendaric Office on 3 Floréal, in the forty-first year of the present recension. It resolves, for administrative purposes only, the standing question of whether a stair may be cited in proceedings when it bears no floor number at either end. The Clarification's holding is narrow: an un-numbered stair is not a place, but a passage under reservation, and may be pleaded only by description of its termini. It has been cited in one hundred and twelve subsequent matters, amended twice, and misquoted in nearly all of them.
Background: the stair between 6,404 and 6,408
The stair in question rises from the landing of Floor 6,404 to the landing of Floor 6,408, a distance of four floors accomplished in eleven treads. Both landings are numbered and named; the stair between them is neither. It first enters the record in a survey return of 14 Prairial, which notes the stair's existence, its eleven treads, and, in the surveyor's hand, the observation that "the risers do not agree with the going, and no one has thought it worth a complaint."
Dispute arose in the winter of the following year, when a party to a boundary matter concerning Floor 6,406 attempted to serve notice upon the stair itself, on the reasoning that service at a point equidistant from both landings would bind all floors the stair touched. The notice was returned unserved. The serving officer, Deputy Registrar Ossian Vell, recorded that he had stood on the seventh tread for the better part of an afternoon and could find no one to accept it. His memorandum of that afternoon is preserved and consists of a single line: "The stair declines to be an address."
The question was referred upward. It reached the Calendaric Office in the company of a second, unrelated query about the naming of landings, and the two were heard together — a consolidation later regretted by every party, and the source of the Clarification's notorious breadth.
The holding
Clarification 88-451 distinguishes three categories of structure: the floor, which is numbered and citable; the landing, which is numbered by reference to its floor and citable by proxy; and the passage, which is citable only by its termini and never in its own person. A stair without numbers at either end is therefore a passage under reservation. It may be named in a proceeding as "the stair between Floor X and Floor Y" and in no other way. The Clarification adds, at clause 4, that any figure purporting to number such a stair is to be struck from the record and the striking noted in the margin.
"A passage is not a party. It is the means by which parties are separated, and it cannot be asked to hold a position, receive a notice, or bear a name it has not been given."
— Clarification 88-451, clause 3
The Office took care to state what the Clarification did not decide. It did not disturb the rule of the Clarification of the Long Stair, which concerns floors opened but not yet existing, and it expressly reserved the case of stairs whose upper terminus is a door. That reservation has since been read as an invitation, and the reading has cost the Office considerable labour.
The Stair of Eleven Treads and the first amendment
Clause 4 proved unworkable within a decade. Clerks in three scriptoria had independently begun numbering the 6,404–6,408 stair, each with a different figure, and the resulting citations could not be reconciled. The first amendment, 88-451/a, permitted a passage to bear a working designation in square brackets, for internal reference only, provided the brackets were never omitted in citation. The practice spread; the brackets did not. By the second amendment, 88-451/b, the Office had conceded the point and allowed the stair to be known in common use as the Stair of Eleven Treads, while insisting that the name was a description and not a number, and that "eleven" was not to be treated as ordinal.
In 1841 the Matter of the Lower Stair Memorandum overturned the early doctrine that entanglement could arise only between procedures of equal rank; Clarification 88-451 was cited there in support of the proposition that a passage may entangle floors of unequal height, and the citation was accepted without argument. Whether the Clarification actually says this is disputed. It does not appear to say this.
Scholarly disagreement
The principal dispute concerns clause 6, which provides that where a stair's termini are of unequal rank the stair takes the lower rank for purposes of citation. The Precedent Register records the clause as settled. The Commentary on the Calendaric Clarifications, 3rd recension holds instead that clause 6 was drafted for a case concerning the Numbered Stair and was carried into 88-451 by a copyist's error, and that the Office never intended it to govern ordinary passages at all. The two positions have not been reconciled. A third view, advanced in the Marginalia of the Fourth Scriptorium and nowhere else, is that clause 6 governs and the Numbered Stair governs too, and that the copyist was right.
The Contextual Clarification Bulletins (CCB) have twice been asked to settle the matter and twice declined, on the ground that the question is one of intent rather than procedure. The Anticipatory Clarification of the following year is sometimes read as an oblique answer; it is not one.
Practical notes
Visitors citing the stair in person are asked to descend to the lower landing before giving their name, as the upper landing has no clerk. The treads are to be kept clear. Under clause 9, no notice may be affixed to the seventh tread, that tread having been the subject of the original failed service and remaining, in the Office's phrase, "unreconciled to being used."
Clarification 88-451 remains in force. Its ninth leaf, which contains the schedule of termini, has been missing since 1874 and is cited from memory by all parties, who do not agree on what it listed.
See also
-
MS 0661.26
Annex of Silent Resolves
The Annex of Silent Resolves is a sealed holding on Floor 1180, comprising 41,000 bound determinations issued by the Silent Divan …
-
MS 4143.17
Clarification on Radial Terminology
Clarification on Radial Terminology (designated Concordance 891.Δ) is an amendment to the Third Concordance issued by the Office o…
-
MS 8809.21
Petition for Clarification
The Petition for Clarification is the primary administrative instrument within the Tower for engaging the formal mechanisms of Cla…
-
MS 4847.01
Conjunctive Verification
Conjunctive Verification is the branch of Tower Law concerned with establishing, for legal purposes, whether two or more catalogue…
-
MS 5297.53
Commissioner Quartus
Commissioner Quartus is a standing office of the Administrative division, held without interruption since at least the Eleventh Re…
-
MS 1078.06
Referential Integrity Scans
Referential Integrity Scans are the mandatory cross-floor examinations conducted to confirm that a holding still resolves to that …
Referenced by
- MS 5283.17 The Directorate of Precedential Adjudication
Readers also asked
Anticipatory Clarification: how is it conducted?
Anticipatory Clarification is the procedural doctrine by which the Office of Onomastic Clarification issues binding determinations upon matters that have not yet been submitted for clarification, on the grounds that thei…
Anticipatory ClarificationContextual Clarification Bulletins (CCB): what does it set out?
Contextual Clarification Bulletins (CCB) are numbered documents issued by the Bureau of Unspoken Context to stabilise interpretive consensus across the Tower's cataloguing efforts. A CCB records prior invocations of dire…
Contextual Clarification Bulletins (CCB)Precedent Register: what does it set out?
The Precedent Register is the master ledger of the Court of Unseen Precedents, collating all binding judicial determinations made in the resolution of cataloguing conflicts. It is distinct from, though often confused wit…
Precedent RegisterPassages cited from this record
-
A passage is not a party. It is the means by which parties are separated, and it cannot be asked to hold a position, receive a notice, or bear a name it has not been given.
Clarification 88-451, clause 3
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3232.18 Clarification of the Long Stair
- MS 0847.43 Deputy Registrar Ossian Vell
- MS 5574.16 Numbered Stair
- MS 0655.23 Matter of the Lower Stair Memorandum
Because you consulted