The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Categorical Placement Assessment

MS 2541.33 · Practices and doctrines

Categorical Placement Assessment is the standing procedure by which a proposed holding is examined, weighed, and assigned a category before any question of shelving, numbering, or admission arises. It is administered by the Bureau of Ontological Placement under the authority of Concordance 14, On the Examination of Subjects Prior to Their Being and is distinct from Ceremonial Placement, which concerns itself only with a holding's formal arrival and takes no view of its contents. An assessment may conclude in an afternoon or occupy eleven years; the Archives record both, and record further that the two cases were assigned the same clerk.

Procedure

Assessment proceeds in three examinations, taken in order and never concurrently. The First Examination establishes whether the subject is one thing or several; the Second determines whether it has been assessed before under another name; the Third proposes a category and states, in writing, why no other category will do. A subject failing the First Examination is returned to the petitioner with the annotation not yet a subject, a phrase the Bureau has declined to define on four separate occasions.

The Examiners sit in the West Reading Room on floors bearing numbers between 400 and 460, though which floor on any given day is determined by the Rota of Examination Rooms and is posted the previous evening. Assessors are forbidden to bring writing implements into the Second Examination. The reason is historical and is explained under The Ink Incident of Floor 418.

"No subject shall be assessed in the presence of the shelf on which it is proposed to place it, nor within sight of any shelf adjacent thereto; for the eye consults the place and the mind consults the thing, and the two answers will not agree."

— Concordance 14, On the Examination of Subjects Prior to Their Being, Annex 3

History

The Assessment was not always a procedure. Until the reforms of the seventh Librarian-Archivist Ottiline Vesh, categories were assigned by the simple method of placing a subject somewhere and observing whether it complained. Vesh's objection — recorded in a marginal note now held under glass on floor 209 — was that this method tested tolerance rather than identity, and that a patient subject would be catalogued forever as whatever it was first set beside. Her reform was resisted for forty years by the Department of Coherent Placement, which held that an assessment conducted before placement was, in its words, "an opinion pronounced upon a thing that has not yet happened." That objection has never been formally withdrawn; it has merely stopped being raised.

Between the reform and the present day the Assessment has been suspended twice: once during the Quiet Recension, when all categories were held open for the duration, and once for seven months in the winter of the year recorded as 3,014, when the Examiners could not agree on the colour of the assessment forms. The forms were eventually issued in two colours simultaneously. Both are still in use and neither is authoritative.

The Persistence Ladder

The principal instrument of the Assessment is the Persistence Ladder, a graded scale of eleven rungs against which a subject's capacity to remain itself is measured. Assessment on the Ladder is conducted using the Ephemeral Gradients system maintained by the School of Ephemeral Cataloguing, whose assessors are loaned to the Bureau for the duration of a Phase and returned afterward. The Assessment Amp Stabilization Phase II governs all Ladder readings; readings taken during the earlier stabilization are retained in the record but are marked as indicative only.

A subject's rung is not final. It is, however, unusually difficult to revise, and in practice the rung assigned at first reading survives most appeals. The Index of Ambiguity maintains a standing register of Ladder readings that the Bureau itself considers doubtful, and the two offices have been in polite disagreement about eleven of those readings for as long as the register has existed.

Outcomes

An Assessment may conclude in admission, deferral, or the finding that the subject cannot be assessed at all — a result recorded as Categorical Indeterminacy and forwarded to the Logic Guild rather than resolved by the Bureau. Subjects found to belong to more than one category simultaneously are referred under Permutation Errors, which the Bureau does not adjudicate. Where a subject is found to have been mis-assessed and admitted in consequence, remedial measures are attempted; where they are exhausted or inapplicable, the matter proceeds to Categorical Sequestration under the protocols of Categorical Sequestration. Sequestration is not considered a failure of Assessment, but its outcome, and is recorded as such.

Dispute

Two readings of the Assessment's scope remain in circulation. The narrow reading, favoured by the Bureau since Vesh, holds that Assessment determines only the category a subject will occupy and has nothing to say about whether it exists. The broad reading, advanced in Concordance 22, On the Priority of Category to Being and never repealed, holds that a subject's existence is conferred by its placement, so that Assessment — which precedes placement — is properly the examination of whether a thing shall be at all. The second reading makes every assessment an act of creation, a proposition the Bureau has described in a circular of 3,109 as "not within the competence of this office to deny."

The Certificate of Categorical Solitude is generally cited as having settled the matter in favour of the broad reading, and the Theorem of Categorical Inertia is generally cited as having settled it in favour of the narrow one. The Library's own position, recorded in the margin of the relevant folio, is that both citations are accurate and neither is decisive.

Records

Completed assessments are fair-copied by the Scriptorium of the Third Recension and bound in annual volumes. Marginal notes made by Examiners during deliberation are not destroyed and are not catalogued, and may be consulted on written application. The volumes are shelved out of sequence, in the order in which assessments were completed rather than the order in which they were begun. A subject assessed across two years appears in two volumes, at two different rungs, and both entries are correct.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Assessment Amp Stabilization Phase Ii: how is it conducted?

"The second phase is not a condition of the subject but a condition of the record. What is stabilised is the description, not the described."

Assessment Amp Stabilization Phase Ii
Ceremonial Placement: how is it conducted?

The Ceremonial Placement refers to the rigidly prescribed ritual act of affixing a Custodial Sigil to its designated substrate, governed by the Third Concordance and the protocols detailed in the Manual of Ceremonial Adh…

Ceremonial Placement
Persistence Ladder: how is it conducted?

The Ladder is divided into seven primary classes, denoted by letters of the archaic Greek alphabet, each representing a distinct band of persistence probability.

Persistence Ladder
Certificate of Categorical Solitude: what does it set out?

The Certificate of Categorical Solitude is an official document issued by the Office of Ontological Registration pursuant to the Fourth Concordance, Annex Δ (Singular Entities), which formally births a subject into the T…

Certificate of Categorical Solitude

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.