The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

BureauĠofĠProtocolĠSynthesis

MS 3766.99 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Bureau of Protocol Synthesis is the drafting office of the Tower's protocol apparatus, empowered to compose Transfer Protocols, to maintain them in recension, and to certify that a protocol so drafted is internally consistent before it is passed to the Bureau of Protocol Ratification for enactment. It is the office of record for the Omega-7 Transfer Protocol and, by long accretion, for some four hundred and eleven subsidiary Transfer Protocols. It does not ratify anything. This distinction, frequently misstated in the lower reading rooms, is set out plainly in its founding instrument and has been litigated twice.

The Bureau occupies Floors 204 through 209, a block of compact scriptoria connected to the Central Spine by a service stair of eleven turns. Its staff is not stated in any Concordance, and the Bureau has declined on four occasions to state it either.

Origin and the First Recension

The Bureau was constituted under Fifth Concordance, Annex 2, in the year recorded as 3,214 by the Bureau's own reckoning, though the reckoning of the Bureau is its own affair and has never been reconciled to the stair-notations used elsewhere. Its first charge was narrow: to render contradictory protocols into a single text susceptible of ratification, a task now understood as a specialised form of Document Synthesis.

The early Bureau drafted by hand and corrected in the margin, a practice that produced the so-called First Recension — 340 leaves, of which 311 survive — in which the primary text and its corrections are frequently indistinguishable, both being in the same clerk's script. The Bureau's later adoption of the two-column protocol format is generally credited to the Bureau of Marginal Corrections, which objected that corrections written beside the text they corrected could not themselves be corrected without ambiguity. The objection was upheld. No clerk of the Bureau has written in a margin since.

The Omega-7 Transfer Protocol

The Bureau is the office of record for the Omega-7 Transfer Protocol, the standard governing the movement of a certified classification between floors of unlike numbering. Because floor numbering is not sequential in any reconstructible sense, a protocol of transfer cannot appeal to adjacency, and Omega-7 accordingly specifies transfer by declaration rather than by position: the originating floor declares the receiving floor, the receiving floor declares acceptance, and the classification is held to have moved when both declarations are entered in the same register.

Omega-7 has been amended forty-two times. Its current text runs to 190 clauses, of which the Bureau privately regards perhaps thirty as load-bearing. The remainder were added in response to incidents, most of them the same incident.

"Where a Transfer Protocol is amended to address an incident, the amendment shall describe the incident, and where the incident cannot be described, the amendment shall say so and shall be ratified regardless."

— Omega-7 Transfer Protocol, Clause 5

Clause 5 is the only clause of Omega-7 that has never been amended. The Bureau notes this without comment.

The Winter Dispute over Annex 2

In the winter of the year the Bureau records as 3,388, a disagreement arose between the Bureau and the Bureau of Documentary Reconciliation over which office was competent to declare two contradictory protocols "mutually survivable" for synthesis. The Bureau held that drafting authority implies the power to determine which drafts may be drafted together. The Bureau of Documentary Reconciliation held, and holds, that survivability is a documentary question and so falls to it alone.

The dispute was referred to Concordance Synthesis, which returned a finding that both offices were correct and that the correct office in any given case was the one that had acted first. The Bureau, reading this as a victory, acted first in every case for eleven years, until the Bureau of Documentary Reconciliation acted first in a case the Bureau had intended to act first in, and the matter settled into an arrangement nobody has described in writing. The arrangement holds.

A secondary dispute of the same winter concerned a clerk, Ansory Vell, who had drafted a Transfer Protocol in a hand the Bureau's copyists could not read and who refused to dictate it on the grounds that dictation altered the rhythm of the clauses. Vell's protocol was eventually transcribed by a copyist working from a reading aloud performed by a second clerk reading silently and marking the text as she went. The resulting protocol is in force. Vell's grievance — that the rhythm was altered — was upheld by the Bureau and no remedy was specified.

Procedure and the Problem of the Drafting Round

A protocol drafted by the Bureau proceeds through successive drafting rounds, each producing a recension that supersedes the last while retaining it in the record. The Bureau is careful to distinguish this from Derivative Synthesis: a drafting round does not synthesise from a previous synthesis, it revises a text, and the Bureau has twice issued memoranda insisting on the distinction, both of which were themselves revised and are now retained in recension.

Rounds continue until a protocol is declared stable, a declaration made by the drafting clerk and countersigned by a second clerk who has not read the protocol. The countersignature requirement dates from a drafting round that continued for nineteen years; the second clerk's purpose is to certify that the drafting clerk has stopped, not that the text is good. Protocols have been declared stable while still changing. The Bureau regards this as within the meaning of stability.

Relationship to Other Offices

The Bureau's protocols frequently require the certification of measurements before transfer, and in those cases the Bureau consults the Bureau of Cartographic Standards, which administers the Synthesis Chamber and whose Comparative Synthesis procedure is often a precondition of a stable draft. Where a protocol output must itself be reconciled with a contradictory classification, the Lumen Regulation Bureau is consulted, and the Lumen Synthesis protocol applied to certify Lumen-Phase Omega.

The Bureau likewise coordinates with the Validation Amp Synthesis Office on the certification of protocol outputs, and with the Committee for Unintended Synthesis where a drafting round has produced a protocol nobody intended. The Bureau's relations with the Committee are cordial and its filings to it are late.

Drafts are sealed with the Bureau's mark — a closed bracket enclosing nothing — and stored on Floor 206. The storage floor is reached by the service stair and may not be entered carrying an open inkwell. The rule dates from the First Recension and has not been revisited.

Scholarly Disagreement

The principal unsettled question in the literature is whether the Bureau drafts protocols or merely drafts drafts of protocols, the act of protocol-creation properly belonging to the ratifying office. The Third Concordance, Annex 4, supports the broader reading: "the composing office composes, and what it composes is the protocol." The Ninth Concordance, Annex 1, supports the narrower: "no instrument is a protocol until ratified, and the ratifying office is therefore the author."

The Bureau has taken no position, noting only that it has never been asked to ratify anything and does not expect to be. A minority school, associated with the reading rooms of Floor 198, holds that both Concordances describe the same office under different names and that the dispute is a scribal error of long standing. This view is not widely held, but it is not refuted anywhere, and the Bureau has declined to refute it.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Ω-7 Transfer Protocol: how is it conducted?

The Ω-7 Transfer Protocol is a standing practice governing the movement of ephemeral materials between floors of the Tower that specialize in transient phenomena. It is among the most frequently cited — and most frequent…

Ω-7 Transfer Protocol
Fifth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fifth Concordance is the first major procedural concordance to survive in its entirety, ratified in Year 47 of the Second Librarianate. It is primarily concerned with establishing protocols for the measurement, docum…

Fifth Concordance
Validation Amp Synthesis Office: who are they?

The Validation Amp Synthesis Office (VSO) is a sub-body of the Office of Works Amp Ways tasked with establishing and certifying the internal consistency of catalogued materials, particularly following procedures of annex…

Validation Amp Synthesis Office
Lumen Synthesis: how is it conducted?

Lumen Synthesis is a specialized synthesis protocol used to reconcile contradictory measurements or classifications of a Standard Lumen Unit output. It is governed by Clause 17.04 of the Twelfth Concordance, which extend…

Lumen Synthesis

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.