The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Axiom of Containment

MS 4176.26 · Practices and doctrines

The Axiom of Containment is the foundational principle of acquisition practice in the Tower, holding that a thing acquired ceases to be elsewhere. First set down in the Ninth Concordance, Annex B, the Axiom provides the metaphysical basis for the Stasis Quarantine protocol and, by extension, for nearly every act of cataloguing performed above Floor Lambda-4 since the Annex's ratification. Its brevity — the operative clause runs to nine words — has been a source of both its durability and its extensive interpretive literature.

The Axiom is not to be confused with the Axiom of Administrative Containment, a procedural doctrine concerning committees, nor with the Axiom of Containment, which governs shelving loads and is treated separately.

Text and ratification

Annex B of the Ninth Concordance states the Axiom in its entirety:

"What is taken up is no longer where it was; and what is no longer where it was may be entered."

— Ninth Concordance, Annex B, clause 1

The second clause, added at the Eleventh Recension in the winter following the ratification, extends the principle to intangibles: a name, once written into a register, is held to have left the mouth that spoke it. Clerks of the Office of Registering Silence have disputed the scope of this extension for two centuries without resolution, and the dispute is now considered a permanent feature of the doctrine rather than a defect in it.

Relation to the Stasis Quarantine

The Stasis Quarantine protocol is the Axiom's direct procedural expression. Under Quarantine, an object is sealed in a Concordant Vault immediately upon signing of the acquisition slip; the seal is understood not to prevent the object's escape but to formalize the departure it has already made. The Dialectical Containment Bureau maintains that no interval exists between acquisition and quarantine, and the Bureau of Interval maintains that the interval is precisely what its name describes. The two offices have not corresponded since the Quarrel of the Sixth Landing, and applications submitted to both are routinely processed twice.

The Axiom also underlies the Residual Taxonomy established alongside the Annex, under which an object's residual — the trace of where it is no longer — is measured in residual degrees. A residual of zero indicates an object that has never been acquired and is therefore of no cataloguing interest.

The Kellard objection

The principal challenge to the Axiom was raised by Under-Clerk Kellard, who observed in a memorandum of 4 March that if a thing acquired ceases to be elsewhere, and the register itself is a thing acquired by the Tower, then the register ceases to be anywhere, including on the shelf where it is consulted. Kellard's memorandum was circulated to eleven offices and answered by none.

The Tenth Concordance eventually addressed the objection in an annex generally read as a refutation but which, on close inspection, restates the problem in longer words. The Axiom of Inexhaustibility was subsequently invoked, on the reasoning that registers of sufficient length are exempt from the Axiom through sheer volume. The Axiom of Precedential Hierarchy was invoked in support of that reasoning, and then again against it, by the same office, on consecutive days.

Practical observance

In daily practice the Axiom is observed chiefly through the Coincidence of the Ledger, a routine by which the acquiring clerk and the shelving clerk sign the same slip at different hours without conferring. Departures from the routine require a Form C-7α and the countersignature of a Librarian of the Second Rank. Members of the shelving staff are not to descend between Floors Mu-2 and Mu-9 carrying an open ledger, as the Axiom is held to operate more strongly there.

Disputes over whether a particular thing has in fact been acquired are settled by citation of the Axiom, a practice the Concordance on Citation permits on the grounds that the Axiom settles any dispute in which it is cited, including disputes about whether it should have been.

Scholarly disagreement

Two readings of the Axiom compete. The strict reading, associated with the School of Annex B, holds that acquisition is instantaneous and irreversible, so that a returned object must be re-acquired under a fresh slip and a fresh number. The lenient reading, associated with the Kellard Revisionists, holds that an object may be said to have been "elsewhere" continuously throughout, and that the Axiom merely records this fact without altering it. The Ninth Concordance supports the strict reading in Annex B and the lenient reading in Annex D, which was bound into the same volume in error and never removed. The Framewithinframe Corollary has been applied to the resulting correspondence, which the Office of Binding Errors declines to discuss.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Axiom of Administrative Containment: how is it conducted?

The Axiom of Administrative Containment is a first-order principle of procedural ontology within the Tower, enshrined within the Seventy-Seventh Clarification. It formalizes the doctrine that the authority to initiate, m…

Axiom of Administrative Containment
Axiom of Inexhaustibility: how is it conducted?

The Axiom of Inexhaustibility is a foundational principle of Tower administration that formally establishes the inherent, self-sustaining nature of proper procedure. It states, in its definitive formulation from the Conc…

Axiom of Inexhaustibility
Stasis Quarantine: how is it conducted?

Stasis Quarantine refers concurrently to a designated physical location, the procedural protocol governing it, and the resultant administrative condition. It is a containment mechanism for unresolved archival items, theo…

Stasis Quarantine
Eleventh Recension: what does it set out?

The Eleventh Recension is the eleventh collation of the Concordances ...

Eleventh Recension

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.