The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Anchorage Review

MS 5384.48 · Practices and doctrines

Anchorage Review is the periodic examination by which the Directorate of Anchorage confirms that a designated anchorage still holds — that is, that the narrative, structural, or calendrical point fixed by the anchorage has not drifted from the position recorded for it. The Review is distinct from the general Review of Floor Stability, which concerns floors, and from Audit and Review, which concerns the accounts of offices that keep accounts. It concerns only anchorages, and only the question of whether they are where they were said to be.

The practice descends from Narrative Anchorage, the doctrine established by Directive 12 of the Second Librarianate, which required ephemeral, contradictory, or recursive accounts to be assigned a primary material witness. Once witnesses were assigned, it became necessary to ask, at intervals, whether they were still witnessing. The first Anchorage Review was conducted over four days in the 1,884th archival winter and examined eleven anchorages. Three were found to have loosened. The figure has never fallen below one in any subsequent cycle, and clerks of the Directorate regard a review returning zero findings as itself a finding.

Conduct and Cycle

Reviews are conducted on a Review Cycle of nine archival winters, though individual anchorages may be moved to shorter cycles by Motion for Perpetual Review, a procedure invoked most often by offices whose holdings depend on a single anchorage. The Theoretical Anchorage Division, as the office responsible for prospective witnesses, maintains the largest share of anchorages under review and therefore the largest share of the paperwork.

An examiner attends the anchorage, reads the register entry aloud, and observes whether the recorded condition obtains. If it does, the entry is countersigned and the anchor is returned to the cycle. If it does not, the examiner records a variance, and the anchorage passes to the Committee Review stage. Variances are graded from I to IV, though the grading table has been amended so often that examiners are instructed to write the grade in words and let the Committee assign the numeral.

The examiner carries no instruments. The Directorate has twice proposed a measuring apparatus for anchorages of the structural class, most recently in the 4,190s, and both proposals were withdrawn after the Locus of the Mercurial Standard failed to agree on a definition of the unit to be measured.

The Kestrel Recension and the Status of Absent Objects

The authority for reviewing anchorages whose object is not present to the senses rests on Annex 9 of the Fourth Concordance, Kestrel Recension, which provided for the registration of anchorage types including those whose object is not present to the senses. The Kestrel Recension further included, at Annex 11, a register of anchorage types with an accompanying schedule of review intervals — the schedule being, in the words of the recension's own rubric, "provisional in all particulars."

Here the record divides. The Third Concordance, Article 40, holds that an anchorage whose object cannot be produced for inspection is reviewed by attestation of the registering clerk alone. The Fifth Chamber of Review has held, in a ruling of the 4,077th winter still cited by both sides, that attestation of a clerk who has never seen the object is "a courtesy extended to a fiction, and the Directorate is not in the business of courtesy." The Directorate has not reconciled the two positions, and reviews of absent-object anchorages are accordingly recorded on a form bearing both clauses, so that whichever prevails the entry will be regular.

"Where two Concordances speak to one act, the act is not thereby done twice; it is done once, in the manner that will least embarrass the archive."

— Concordance of Precedents, Entry 212

The Variance of the 4,211th Winter

The most cited case in the Review's literature is the variance raised by Clerk Hestor Vane of the Theoretical Anchorage Division in the 4,211th archival winter, in respect of the entry recording first admission of the Variant Delta recension to the Prospective Roll. Vane entered a Class II variance on the ground that the anchorage had been reviewed, found sound, and returned to the cycle, and that the Review itself therefore constituted an additional telling of the narrative it was meant to anchor.

The Committee heard the matter for three winters. Its determination, that a review does not count as a telling because "the examiner reads the entry and does not believe it," was received by the Directorate as a clarification and by the Division as an insult. Vane's subsequent marginalia — some forty pages, written in a hand the archivist describes as "declining" — are held with the Vault of Perpetual Review and are consulted chiefly for their gloss on the word believe. It is from this case that the standing instruction derives: the examiner reads the entry aloud and does not look at the anchorage while reading it.

Inventory of Review Classes

Anchorages under Review are tallied each cycle by class. The current standing tally of the Directorate's registers lists four classes, at the following counts:

  • Class A — material anchorages, present to the senses: 1,408
  • Class B — material anchorages, displaced by more than one floor: 213
  • Class C — anchorages whose object is not present to the senses: 677
  • Class D — anchorages whose register entry has been lost and whose class is therefore inferred: 41

Class D is reviewed by inferring the class, then reviewing in the manner of the inferred class. Examiners assigned to Class D are permitted a second examiner.

Contested Procedure

Two practices remain disputed. The first is whether an Anchorage Review may be conducted in the absence of the anchorage's own clerk. The Directorate holds that it may, on the reasoning of Review Priority, which places the review ahead of the reviewed. The Central Review Board has inclined the other way, noting that in the 4,204th winter an examiner reviewed an anchorage in the absence of its clerk and found it sound, and the clerk returned to find it gone. The second is whether a variance survives the death of the examiner who raised it. Corroborative Evidence Review requires a second signature for any variance older than one cycle; the Directorate's practice is to accept the variance and note the examiner as "unavailable," a designation that has covered deaths, transfers, and one retirement.

The Review has never been suspended, though it was reduced to a single examiner in the 3,988th winter. That examiner, whose name the register gives only as Ostrand, filed findings on 612 anchorages in nine days. The findings are accepted. The Directorate has never explained how they were made.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Motion for Perpetual Review: how is it conducted?

The Motion for Perpetual Review is the formal instrument by which a holding, classification, or dispute already under review may be submitted to review again, on the grounds that its parameters are incompletely defined. …

Motion for Perpetual Review
Vault of Perpetual Review (Annex 7.3): how is it conducted?

Vault of Perpetual Review (Annex 7.3) is the designation given to a narrow, draught-prone procedural closet on the seventh landing of the Vault of Perpetual Review, entered from the north side of the Hall of Perpetual Re…

Vault of Perpetual Review (Annex 7.3)
Committee Review: how is it conducted?

Committee Review is the general designation for any review conducted under the authority of a committee of the Tower, as distinct from a review conducted of a committee. The distinction was first drawn in Cycle 31 by the…

Committee Review

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.