The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Amendment 7 (830-Φ)

MS 4539.42 · Documents and ordinances

Amendment 7 (830-Φ) is a subordinate instrument appended to the Seventh Concordance Amendment, drafted in the scriptorium of the 830th Floor (Spiral Φ) and entered into the Master Amendment Log on 19 Fructidor, Cycle 166. It is chiefly remembered not for its text — which runs to four clauses and a schedule — but for the manner of its filing, which produced the longest-running procedural dispute in the history of the Bureau of Concordant Amendment and gave rise to the standing rule that no instrument may be amended by an instrument of lower rank that cites it only by its floor designation.

Text and purpose

Amendment 7 (830-Φ) was intended as a housekeeping measure. The Seventh Concordance Amendment 4 had, by the forty-first recension, accumulated eleven appendices whose numbering no longer corresponded to their order of enactment, and the amendment undertook to renumber them consecutively while preserving their original dates in a marginal schedule. Clauses 1 through 3 govern the renumbering. Clause 4, added late and without the usual circulation, provides that any appendix whose original date cannot be established shall retain its existing number and be marked with a sigma in the margin.

The schedule appended to the amendment lists all eleven appendices and, in the case of four of them, the note "date not established — sigma applied." No sigma appears anywhere in the marginalia of the surviving copies. The Office of Marginal Corrections has twice declined to supply them, citing a standing instruction (Instruction 9 of the 830th Floor scriptorium) that marginal marks are the exclusive province of the floor that originated the document, and the 830th Floor has not originated anything since.

The dispute over rank

The central controversy concerns rank. Amendment 7 (830-Φ) was filed on the authority of a floor designation rather than a concordant number, and the Bureau of Concordant Amendment ruled in Cycle 167 that floor authority does not confer rank. The ruling was appealed on the ground that Amendment 117.45.β, which is itself of higher rank than Amendment 89.2a, had been filed under an essentially identical formula and had never been questioned. The Bureau's answer, issued in Cycle 168 and never withdrawn, was that Amendment 117.45.β "was questioned, and the questioning failed; Amendment 7 (830-Φ) was never questioned at all, and therefore has no standing to have failed." The distinction has since been cited in nineteen separate disputes, none of them about Amendment 7 (830-Φ).

"An instrument that has never been challenged is not thereby secure. It is merely untested, and an untested instrument may be set aside without argument, there being no argument on record to set aside."

— Bureau of Concordant Amendment, Ruling 168/Φ-4

Against this, the Seventh Concordance Amendment 4 was amended in the thirty-ninth recension to provide that "rank shall follow the rank of the parent instrument, and shall not be diminished by the irregularity of the route by which the amendment reached the Log." Read plainly, this would restore Amendment 7 (830-Φ) to the rank of its parent. The Bureau has read it not plainly, holding that the clause governs the rank of amendments, not the rank of instruments appended to amendments, and that Amendment 7 (830-Φ) is the latter. The Office of Marginal Corrections has endorsed both readings in different memoranda.

The Clerk of Floor 830 and the winter grievance

The amendment was drafted by Senior Clerk Ottiline Vare, who held the 830th Floor scriptorium from Cycle 154 until her retirement in Cycle 171. Vare's grievance is preserved in a petition of Cycle 169, still unanswered, in which she observes that her instrument had been accepted, sealed, shelved and indexed before anyone thought to ask what rank it held, and that "a document cannot be lowered by a ruling issued after it has been read into the Log; the Log does not revise, it receives."

The winter of Cycle 169 was unusually cold on the 830th Floor, and the scriptorium's ink froze in the wells for eleven days. Vare's petition was written during that period, in a hand the Bureau later described as "hurried and, in three places, illegible." The illegible passages are the ones the Bureau relies on. The legible ones are the ones Vare relies on. Neither party has proposed a fresh copy. It is the practice on Floor 830 that a document is not recopied once sealed, a rule the Bureau has never formally recognized but has never once tested.

Relationship to other instruments

Amendment 7 (830-Φ) does not touch Amendment Σ-22 or its appended Amendment Annex Σ.7, and the Bureau has said so twice, in each case unprompted. It resembles, but is not identical to, Amendment 12(b).4, which was sealed on the same day and by the same clerk, and which was saved from the same difficulty only because its parent, Amendment 12, carried a concordant number. Vare noted in her petition that the two documents were drafted "at the same table, with the same pen, in the same hour," and asked why one should be ranked and the other not. The Bureau has not answered this question. It has answered several others at length.

Current status

The amendment remains in the Log, indexed under both the Seventh Concordance Amendment and the 830th Floor, and is regarded as valid for all purposes except the settling of disputes. It may be cited, but not to settle anything. A proposal to append a corrective instrument, Amendment 7(b)-Φ, has been lodged three times and withdrawn three times, on each occasion because the corrective instrument would itself require a rank in order to confer one, and the office competent to assign that rank is the office the correction was meant to rebuke.

Two copies are known. One is held in the 830th Floor scriptorium, unsealed since Cycle 169. The other is in the Master Amendment Log, sealed, and the sigma marks are missing from it. Visitors wishing to consult the floor copy should note that Floor 830 does not receive callers on the eleventh and twenty-third of any month, and that boots must be removed at the landing.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Marginal Corrections: who are they?

The Office of Marginal Corrections is a subordinate body of the Tower's clerical establishment concerned with the annotation, reinstatement, and occasional suppression of marginalia — the written matter that accumulates …

Office of Marginal Corrections
Amendment Annex Σ.7: what does it set out?

Amendment Annex Σ.7 is a legislative instrument of the Spiral Concordance (Σ), appended to Amendment Σ-22 in the forty-first recension of the Master Amendment Log. It is best known for having introduced the class of puta…

Amendment Annex Σ.7
Bureau of Concordant Amendment: who are they?
Amendment 89.2a: what does it set out?

Amendment 89.2a is a subsidiary procedural amendment to the Eighty-Ninth Concordance, appended at the twelfth recension of that document and ratified on 14 Frostmonth, in the ninth year of the present stair-cycle. It is …

Amendment 89.2a

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.