The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Annex D of the Seventh Concordance

MS 0372.28 · Documents and ordinances

Scope

Annex D of the Seventh Concordance is a procedural annex appended to the Seventh Concordance, concerned with the ordering and cross-reference of subordinate instruments. It is one of the more frequently cited annexes in the Tower's internal disputes, largely because its clauses are short, its definitions are older than the terms they define, and it has been amended without record at least twice.

The Annex comprises eleven clauses and one schedule. It is reproduced in full in the Scriptorium of Cross-References, floor designation unreconciled, where the standing copy is maintained under seal by the Office of Concordant Order.

Provisions

The operative clauses are as follows. Clause 1 establishes that no subordinate instrument shall take effect within the Seventh Concordance until its reference number has been entered in the marginal roll. Clause 3 permits the marginal roll to be amended by the Office of Concordant Order without recourse to the Seventh Concordance, Annex Theta, on the grounds that the marginal roll is an instrument of order rather than of substance. Clause 5 is a definitions clause and has not been revised since the Third Recension. Clause 8 concerns precedence between annexes of equal designation, and is the clause most often invoked — and most often found to contradict Seventh Concordance, Annex Q.

Clause 11, which governs the withdrawal of a clause from the Annex, reads in full: "A clause withdrawn is not deleted; it is relocated." The relocation point has never been specified, and three separate Librarians have recorded their disagreement with the phrasing in the margins of the standing copy.

"Annex D does not tell you what is true. It tells you where to look, and it has never once told the same clerk where to look twice."

— Under-Librarian Vell, Notes on the Marginal Roll, undated

The Marginal Roll

The marginal roll is the operative instrument created under Clause 1. It is a single continuous sheet, kept in the Scriptorium of Cross-References, on which every subordinate instrument of the Seventh Concordance is recorded with its reference number and its current status. The roll is not itself annexed to the Concordance, a distinction upheld in the ruling of the Office of Concordant Order in the winter of the Long Recension, after which the roll was moved to a wider desk.

Disputes over the roll are common. The most consequential concerned the entry for Annex Delta of the Seventh Concordance, which was recorded as "in force," "superseded," and "not yet begun" on the same sheet, in three different hands. The matter was referred to the Annex of Litigious Outcomes to the Seventh Concordance and has not been closed.

Relationship to other annexes

Annex D is frequently confused with Forty-Seventh Concordance, Annex D, which is an architectural survey and shares no lineage. The confusion arises from the designation alone and is corrected in the standing copy's preface, though the preface is itself bound one leaf out of place.

Within the Seventh Concordance, Annex D sits below Seventh Concordance, Annex Q in matters of precedence under Clause 8, but above Seventh Concordance's Annex on Dimensional Taxonomy in matters of ordering. Annex Gamma 7 of the Seventh Concordance and Seventh Concordance, Annex 12 both cite Clause 3 as their authority for amending their own schedules. Seventh Concordance, Provisional Annex Omega does not cite Annex D at all, which the Office of Concordant Order has recorded as "noted" rather than "objectionable."

Schedule of amendments

The Schedule attached to Annex D lists four amendments. The first three are dated and initialled. The fourth bears no date and no initial, and reads only: "See Annex Theta." Readers have noted that Seventh Concordance, Annex Theta does not, in fact, contain the referenced provision. The Office of Concordant Order's standing response is that the Schedule's fourth amendment is itself an amendment to the reference rather than to the provision, and that the discrepancy is therefore correct.

Standing

Annex D remains in force. Its status has never been challenged directly, though the marginal roll it governs has been challenged on eleven recorded occasions. The standing copy is available for inspection on application to the Office of Concordant Order; applicants are reminded that the desk is not to be leaned on.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Seventh Concordance, Annex Theta: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance, Annex Theta is a supplementary document governing the measurement, calibration, and bureaucratic recognition of phenomena categorized as possessing a high Nexus Frequency. Formally appended to th…

Seventh Concordance, Annex Theta
Annex Delta of the Seventh Concordance: how is it conducted?

Annex Delta of the Seventh Concordance is the operative annex to the Seventh Concordance, ratified in the eleventh year of the current recension and amended, by the Librarians' own tally, forty-one times since. It is the…

Annex Delta of the Seventh Concordance
Seventh Concordance, Annex 12: what does it set out?

Seventh Concordance, Annex 12 is the twelfth annex to the Seventh Concordance and the instrument by which originally temporary holdings are confirmed, extended, or returned to the open shelves. It is short — eleven artic…

Seventh Concordance, Annex 12
Seventh Concordance, Provisional Annex Ω: what does it set out?

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.