Amendment 11 (Cycle 13,455)
MS 9554.24 · Documents and ordinances
Amendment 11 (Cycle 13,455) is the eleventh ratified instrument of the 13,455th Cycle of Record and the only amendment in the Tower's history whose operative text is a single negative clause applied to every floor at once. It provides that no catalogued subject may be entered in a floor register under a name it has not previously held, except where the register itself records the reason the earlier name failed. Its brevity is frequently praised by clerks who have not had to apply it.
Text and ratification
Amendment 11 (Cycle 13,455) was ratified on 4 Pluviôse, Cycle 13,455, following eleven sessions of the Standing Committee on Nomenclature, and entered the Master Amendment Log on 6 Pluviôse of the same cycle. The ratified body reads in full:
"No entry shall be renamed save that the register state, in its own hand, why the former name was insufficient. A reason given by messenger does not satisfy this clause."
— Amendment 11 (Cycle 13,455), Clause 1
The second sentence was added during floor debate at the insistence of the Office of the Ledger's Hand, which had for nine cycles refused to accept loose slips as register annotations. Objections from the Bureau of Urgent Corrections that the clause would slow the correction of plain misspellings were recorded in the ratification minutes and not otherwise addressed.
Precedents and early application
The amendment does not stand alone. Its scope was fixed by reference to Amendment 7, which governs the conditions under which a floor may be cited as precedent for an unnumbered floor, and by Amendment 117.45.β, ratified in the 4,213th Cycle of Record, which supplies the rule that a name once struck remains struck even where the strike is later found to have been in error. The two do not sit easily together: a floor correcting an erroneous strike must record a reason for the correction while preserving the struck name as if no correction had been made. Clerks on Floor 6,112 resolved this by maintaining two columns and disagreeing about the order.
The first application of the amendment was recorded on 9 Pluviôse, Cycle 13,455 in the register of Floor 2,409, where a consignment of drowned lanterns had been entered as "lanterns, drowned," struck, entered as "lamps, wet," and struck again. The third entry, "lanterns, drowned (second entry)," carries the register's own explanation: "the second name was worse." The Office of the Ledger's Hand accepted this; the Bureau of Urgent Corrections did not, and the dispute was carried forward as Matter of the Second Drowning.
The Tallow Question
The amendment's most litigated consequence concerns the tallow register of Floor 3,871, which by long practice was kept on a slope so that spills ran clear of the binding. When the Society for Literal Enumeration petitioned in the 13,456th Cycle to have the register restyled a "tally" on the ground that its entries were counted rather than named, the Society for Literal Concordance replied that a tally is a name of a kind and that the amendment applied. The floor's keeper, Aumand Serevin, noted in the margin only that a tally does not spill. The matter was referred to the Concordance of Slopes and Bindings, which has not reported.
Relationship to Amendment 12
Amendment 11 is sometimes confused with Amendment 12, ratified on 3 Vendémiaire, Cycle 118, and with Amendment 12(b).4 (19 Fructidor, Cycle166), which share a numeral and nothing else. The confusion is aggravated by Concordance 44, Amendment 12, which in the late Seventh Cycle codified the Axiom of Material Coherence and is often shelved beside the present instrument on the mistaken assumption that coherence and naming are the same question. The Librarians have declined to issue a finding on the shelving, observing that the shelves are not their department.
Criticism and the Renaming Budget
The amendment's standing criticism is that it converts a clerical act into a literary one. Ossia Belden, clerk of the Fourth Scriptorium, noted in her grievance of the 13,457th Cycle that in a single season she had been required to justify the renaming of fourteen items, of which eleven were the same barrel. Her memorandum, filed with the Concordance of Slopes and Bindings, argues that the amendment "asks the register to explain itself, which no register has ever been able to do without help."
An associated difficulty is fiscal. Under Concordance 441, Amendment 7, the marginal note appended to that amendment became the origin of Amendment 7; by analogy, the Office of the Ledger's Hand has ruled that the reason recorded under Amendment 11 is itself a catalogued subject, and may not be renamed. The practice is now to draft reasons with care, and to keep the drafting slips, since a reason may not be rewritten and a barrel may not be renamed twice. Clerks are advised to allot one hour per barrel.
Amendment 11 (Cycle 13,455) remains in force. No repeal has been moved.
See also
-
MS 6962.50
Amendment 5-π
Amendment 5-π is a procedural instrument of the amendment class, ratified on the eleventh day of the ninth sitting of the Concorda…
-
MS 6197.37
Aperture Sigma Reinforcement (Year 211, Third Concordance)
The Aperture Sigma Reinforcement (Year 211, Third Concordance) is the operative instrument by which the Reinforcement was carried …
-
MS 8298.24
Amendment 711-B.3 (Year 867)
Amendment 711-B.3 (Year 867) is the third subsidiary instrument of the Seven Hundred and Eleventh Concordance, ratified on 19 Prai…
-
MS 3162.21
Addendum α
Addendum α is the first alpha-designated addendum to the Second Concordance, ratified in the eleventh year of the Concordance's ci…
-
MS 1662.37
The Eleventh Concordance, Clause VII
The Eleventh Concordance, Clause VII is the operative provision of the Eleventh Concordance concerning ambiguity of being in the b…
-
MS 3972.70
Amendment 711-B.17 (Year 988)
Amendment 711-B.17 (Year 988) is the seventeenth subsidiary instrument to Schedule B of the Seven Hundred and Eleventh Concordance…
Referenced by
- MS 3929.57 Charter of Reclassification
Readers also asked
Axiom of Material Coherence: how is it conducted?
The Axiom of Material Coherence is the ninth principle enumerated within the Manual of Sequential Interpretation, governing the physical integrity of documentary matter within The Tower. It asserts that for any document …
Axiom of Material CoherenceAmendment 12(b).4 (19 Fructidor, Cycle166): what does it set out?
Amendment 12(b).4 (19 Fructidor, Cycle 166) is a subordinate amendment appended to Amendment 12-b and ratified on 19 Fructidor, Cycle 166 — a date falling, by the reckoning of the Ascendant Calendar, some five hundred an…
Amendment 12(b).4 (19 Fructidor, Cycle166)Librarians: who are they?
The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…
LibrariansConcordance 441 Amendment 7: what does it set out?
The Amendment consists of three operative clauses and a single, lengthy preamble. Clause 1 formally affirms the Seventeenth Concordance "in its entirety and with full force." Clause 2, however, immediately stipulates tha…
Concordance 441 Amendment 7Passages cited from this record
-
No entry shall be renamed save that the register state, in its own hand, why the former name was insufficient. A reason given by messenger does not satisfy this clause.
Amendment 11 (Cycle 13,455), Clause 1
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6505.53 Standing Committee on Nomenclature
- MS 6612.23 Aumand Serevin
- MS 8880.67 Floor 6,112
- MS 7795.96 Office of the Ledger's Hand
Because you consulted