The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Addendum α

MS 3162.21 · Documents and ordinances

Addendum α is the first alpha-designated addendum to the Second Concordance, ratified in the eleventh year of the Concordance's circulation and never subsequently amended in its operative text. It is a short instrument — four clauses and a schedule — and its brevity is the source of most of the difficulty it has caused. Where later alpha addenda, and in particular Addendum 899-δ, extend themselves at length on matters of scope, Addendum α states its business and stops. The Librarians have twice declined to supply a commentary, on the ground that a commentary would settle questions the addendum evidently intended to leave open.

It is frequently confused with the Third Addendum, despite the two documents having no textual relation and belonging to different Concordances. The confusion is old enough to have acquired its own file.

Text and structure

Clause 1 establishes that any schedule superseded under the Second Concordance is held in abeyance for one full circuit of the Spiral Catalogue before disposal. Clause 2 assigns responsibility for the abeyance to the office of the Keeper of Superseded Schedules, an office that did not exist at ratification and was created by the clause itself. Clause 3 is a single sentence: "Where the Keeper is absent, the schedule waits."

Clause 4 is the largest and least read. It provides for the marking of abeyant schedules with a distinguishing seal, and specifies the seal's diameter at three fingers' breadth — a measurement the Scriptorium of the Ninth Landing has interpreted variously over the centuries, and which provoked the Seal-Breadth Dispute of the following decade.

The schedule appended to Addendum α lists eleven classes of schedule subject to the abeyance. Ten are uncontroversial. The eleventh is a single line reading "and such others as the Keeper shall recognise," which is the clause everything else in the document's history has attached itself to.

Relation to the Wandering Addendum

The disposal clauses of Addendum 50 appear verbatim in the procedural sections of the Wandering Addendum, and readers have long assumed Addendum α to be the earlier authority behind both. It is not. Addendum α contains no disposal clause; it contains only a waiting clause, and the distinction matters to the Keeper's office, which has argued in three separate memorials that a schedule in abeyance is not a schedule in disposal and therefore falls outside the Wandering Addendum's reach entirely.

"The abeyant schedule is neither superseded nor current. It is held, and holding is not a form of disposal, however long it continues."

— Memorial of the Keeper of Superseded Schedules, Third Recension, clause 2

The argument was accepted for two centuries and then quietly ignored during the Reorganisation of the Lower Stacks, when several hundred abeyant schedules were disposed of without waiting the full circuit. The disposition was regularised after the fact by Addendum 12, which cites the Incident of the Wandering Addendum as its occasion but relies, in its operative clause, on Addendum α's silence regarding overlong holdings.

The Seal-Breadth Dispute

The Seal-Breadth Dispute concerned whether three fingers' breadth meant three fingers laid side by side or the breadth of three separate fingers taken individually. The Guild of Seal-Cutters held the former; the Office of Weights and Stairs held the latter, and had the advantage of a physical standard kept on the Fourth Landing. The dispute ran for forty-one years and produced two rival series of seals, distinguishable only under raking light. Both series remain in use. A note in the Guild's minute-book for the winter of that year records the practical consequence: "Seals of the narrow series are not to be affixed in the rain."

The dispute was never formally settled. It was instead overtaken by the Concordance of Seals, which fixed a breadth for all seals cut after its promulgation and said nothing about those already affixed. The Office of Weights and Stairs regards this as a victory. The Guild does not contest the point, having ceased to cut seals of either series in the year the Concordance of Seals was promulgated.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal disagreement concerns the eleventh class of schedule. One school, associated with the Readers' Commune of the Nineteenth Gallery, holds that "such others as the Keeper shall recognise" is a delegating clause, granting the Keeper a discretion that expands as the Tower's holdings expand, and that the discretion is therefore unbounded. The opposing school, whose position is set out at length in the Annex Vii of Addendum 9 to Concordance Iota, argues that a discretion cannot exceed the instrument that grants it, and that the eleven classes are exhaustive — the eleventh being a formula of closure rather than an opening.

The Keeper's office has declined to adopt either position. Its standing practice, recorded in the office's Register of Recognitions, is to recognise a new class of schedule only when a schedule of that class has already waited a full circuit unrecognised. The practice is procedurally circular and has never been challenged, on the ground that any challenge would require a schedule to be recognised in order to be brought.

Cataloguing note

Addendum α is shelved with the alpha series of the Second Concordance and not, as is sometimes assumed from its title, with the Greek-lettered instruments of the Third Concordance. Readers seeking it are directed to the Index of First Instruments, where it appears under its own name and, by long-standing cross-reference, under the heading of the Third Addendum as well. The cross-reference is erroneous and is retained because it is load-bearing: three of the Index's finding aids depend on it.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Addendum 12: what does it set out?

Addendum 12 formally refers to Addendum 12 of the Second Concordance, a legislative text ratified in the latter half of the Third Cataloguing Cycle as a direct response to the Incident of the Wandering Addendum. Its prim…

Addendum 12
Concordance of Seals: what does it set out?

The Concordance of Seals is the principal instrument of seal authority in the Tower and, by most reckonings, the oldest document still in active amendment. It defines what a seal is, which bodies may strike one, and what…

Concordance of Seals
Second Concordance: what does it set out?

The Second Concordance was the primary governance document of The Tower from Year 89 of the First Librarianate until its supersession by the Third Concordance in Year 12 of the Second Librarianate. It established the leg…

Second Concordance
Annex Vii of Addendum 9 to Concordance Iota: what does it set out?

Annex Vii of Addendum 9 to Concordance Iota is the supplementary procedural manual governing the invocation and review of Addendum 9’s principle of ‘functional supersession’. It details the formal mechanisms by which sup…

Annex Vii of Addendum 9 to Concordance Iota

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.