The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Algernon Finch

MS 9678.84 · Persons

Algernon Finch was an Investigator-Pro Tem of the Second Cataloguing Era, best known for the doctrine of retroactive desiccation advanced in respect of the Great Desiccation Event of Cycle 8902, and for the compilation of Algernon’s Folio in the later years of his active tenure. He is not to be confused with Alistair Finch, thirty-ninth Head Librarian, to whom he was distantly related by a collateral line that both men declined to specify in writing.

Finch held the Pro Tem commission for a period given in the Register of Provisional Commissions as "not less than nine cycles and not more than such time as the matter requires," a formula that has defeated every subsequent attempt at dating his tenure precisely.

The Retroactive Desiccation Hypothesis

The Great Desiccation Event of Cycle 8902 is recorded in the standard inventories as a plain loss of moisture across sixteen consecutive floors, with no antecedent noted. Finch disputed the absence of an antecedent. In a memorandum lodged with the Office of Antecedent Records in the winter of that cycle, he argued that the Desiccation had not begun where the inventories placed its beginning, but had instead been precipitated by a resonance event that preceded it by seventeen cycles — the disturbance subsequently catalogued as the Isochrony Event.

Finch's claim was not that the Isochrony Event caused the Desiccation in any forward sense. He proposed instead that the Desiccation, once under way, reached backward through the record and reorganized the entries of seventeen cycles earlier so that they would appear to have anticipated it. On this account the Isochrony Event is not a cause but a symptom of a cause that had not yet occurred when it occurred.

"The record does not remember forward. It is amended backward, and calls the amendment history."

— Algernon’s Folio, Section sigma, marginal note

Vesper Algernon, a descendant, later formalized the underlying principles as the Algernon Incompatibility Theorem; the relationship between the two bodies of work is treated at Algernon's Theorem on Conceptual Plenitude and, more sceptically, at Limitation of Algernon’s Theorem in Appeals.

Dispute with the Chronology Office

The hypothesis was received badly by the Chronology Office, which held that a record amended backward is indistinguishable from a record and should not be given a separate entry. Its counter-memorial of Cycle 8903 cites Ninth Concordance, Annex 2, to the effect that "an event shall be dated by its earliest surviving notice and by no other means." Finch replied that this was precisely his difficulty, since the earliest surviving notice of the Isochrony Event had been written after the Desiccation and could not therefore be earliest in any meaningful sense.

The Office did not concede. It did, however, stop dating the Isochrony Event in its annual returns — a compromise attributed to the intercession of Alistair Finch, who is said to have observed that a date nobody could defend was worse than no date at all. The blank has remained in the returns since Cycle 8904. A note in the margin of the surviving copy reads only: "Left. A.F."

Measurement Practices

Finch is associated — though the attribution rests on a single initialled endorsement — with the Finch Displacement Survey, a long-running exercise in measuring the drift of shelving against fixed reference points. The Survey's unit of measure is the Thirty-Second Step, a length defined by the distance between the thirty-first and thirty-second risers of the West Aperture Stair and held to be the only interval on that stair that has never been repaired.

Why a desiccation investigator should have concerned himself with stair displacement is not explained in his surviving papers. The most economical reading, offered by the Survey Records Annex, is that Finch regarded any quantity that could be measured twice with different results as a candidate for retroactive amendment, and wished to have a large stock of such quantities on hand.

The Folio and Its Recensions

Algernon’s Folio was compiled late and revised often. Three recensions survive, differing chiefly in the order of their sections, and the Scriptorium of the Fourth Landing maintains that the differences are deliberate, the sections having been arranged so that no reader encounters the argument for retroactive desiccation before the evidence for it. Two later copyists disagreed and reordered the Folio conventionally; their versions are catalogued as Algernon S Folio and are not authoritative.

The Folio is also the source of the Algernon-Haversham Thesis, an extension of the doctrine to cover losses of inventory, which Finch neither endorsed nor repudiated. He is recorded as having read the Thesis once and returned it with the comment "plausible, and therefore to be watched."

Legacy and Certification

Finch's commissions lapsed without formal conclusion, and no certificate of completion appears in the registers. His name survives principally as an adjective. Algernon Scholar Clerk is a grade of junior clerk established in Year 34 of the Third Cataloguing Era for those engaged in the reconstruction of amended entries; the grade's founding instrument cites the Folio by section and letter. See also Application of Algernon's Theorem and Algernons Theorem, which are distinct holdings and should be consulted separately.

The Solitude Finch, an unrelated object granted a Certificate of Categorical Solitude by Alistair Finch, shares the surname and nothing else. Enquiries conflating the two are returned unopened, per standing instruction of the Office of Antecedent Records.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Third Cataloguing Era: how is it conducted?

The Third Cataloguing Era (Years 1–873 of the Tower's current chronological reckoning) was the third period of formal archival administration following the ratification of the Tenth Concordance. It is primarily defined b…

Third Cataloguing Era
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …

Ninth Concordance
Isochrony Event: how is it conducted?

The Isochrony Event was a period from Cycle 9124, Day 73 to Cycle 9125, Day 211 during which all mechanical timekeeping devices within the Western Administrative Block — specifically Floors 1,400 through 1,422 — register…

Isochrony Event
Algernon Incompatibility Theorem: how is it conducted?

Algernon Incompatibility Theorem is a foundational axiom of apocryphal mathematics within The Tower, providing a formal framework for the cataloguing of mutually exclusive spatial, logical, or ontological claims that are…

Algernon Incompatibility Theorem

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.