The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Accord of the Silent Gerund

MS 3642.32 · Practices and doctrines

The Accord of the Silent Gerund (registered as GS-14, Cycle 8,806) is a subordinate instrument of the Office of Silent Accord governing the treatment of verbs suspended mid-clause during the drafting of accords. It is among the shortest documents in the register and the most frequently misquoted. Its full operative text occupies eleven lines of surviving recension; its commentary occupies, at last census, four hundred and six bound volumes in the annexes of Floor 301.

The Accord establishes that a verb left without its object in the course of an interrupted accord remains in force, and is to be read as if its object had been struck by common consent. It is silent on every other subject, including the meaning of "in force."

Origin at the Cartwright's Table

The Accord arose from the drafting of the Tetra-Lateral Accord in the winter of Cycle 8,806, when the fourth party's scribe set down the clause "the countersignatory shall not knowingly—" and was called away before completing it. The record of the Office of Silent Accord has preserved the clerk's name as Senechal Orrin Vael, though the Concordance of Scribal Attendance for that quarter records no one of that name on duty, and three different clerks have since claimed the honor of the omission.

The clause was countersigned by all four parties. It has been read, in the centuries since, as prohibiting everything and nothing. A petition to resolve the ambiguity was tabled on Floor 301 in Cycle 8,912 and, by the practice of the Hall, remains tabled.

"A gerund interrupted is not a gerund withdrawn."

— Tetra-Lateral Accord, Annex 4, pg. 12

Provisions

The Accord comprises three operative provisions, an annexe of examples, and a schedule of fees.

The first provision holds that an interrupted verb retains the grammatical force it held at the point of suspension, and that no interpretation may supply an object the drafter did not write. The second permits a suspending party to invoke the Accord only by written notice delivered to the Office of Silent Accord within one hundred and forty days of the suspension, a period that the Temporal Accord Registry has twice declined to adjust on the grounds that it is not a concordance.

The third provision is the shortest in the register: "The gerund shall be silent." It is the source of the instrument's name and of two centuries of dispute as to whether "silent" modifies the gerund or instructs the reader.

The schedule of fees is unremarkable save that it lists a charge of two and a half marks for the reading of the Accord aloud, which may be paid only at the Office and only on a Thursday.

The Vael Recension Dispute

The surviving text of GS-14 exists in three recensions, differing chiefly in punctuation. The Vael Recension, discovered in Cycle 9,107 in a disused copying-room of Floor 301, inserts a comma after "silent," which, if authentic, converts the third provision from a description to an instruction and would require the Office of Silent Accord to enforce silence on all parties to any interrupted clause.

The Office of Final Accord has taken the contrary position in a series of Resolution Writs beginning with RW-9,412, arguing that an instruction so sweeping would have required the consent of the Office, which was not sought, and that in any case the punctuation in the Vael Recension is "the work of a restorer with a heavy hand and a light regard for the record" (RW-9,412, §6). The Office of Silent Accord has not answered this directly. Its Keeper of the Silent Wing observed in Cycle 9,415 that the question was "of interest" and referred it to the tabled petition of 8,912, which remains tabled.

A minority position, advanced by the copyist Halvard Sain in Notes on Interrupted Grammar (4th ed., Cycle 9,340), holds that the comma is a later accretion and that the Vael Recension is a forgery prepared by a clerk seeking to justify a fee he had already collected.

Later Life of the Accord

The Accord of the Silent Gerund was invoked during the drafting of the Accord of Mutual Irritation in Cycle 9,560, when a clause was left suspended for eleven days and both parties claimed the benefit of the silence. The dispute was settled by the Liaison for Inter-Floor Topological Accord, who ruled that the suspension had occurred on a staircase and was therefore outside the jurisdiction of any floor. It is the only recorded instance of a staircase being asked to hear a case.

The Accord has been cited in the suspended language of the Provisional Acoustic Accord and in the first draft of the Accord of Delineated Responsibility, though the latter's drafters removed the citation before registration. It remains unamended. The Temporal Accord Registry notes, in its running commentary, that "documents this short are rarely read closely, and are never read less closely than when they are quoted."

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

First Linen Accord: what does it set out?

First Linen Accord is the foundational regulatory document, ratified in Y-3127 (Archive-Reckoning), that established material, procedural, and philosophical standards for the production, maintenance, and wearing of linen…

First Linen Accord
Silent Accord: how is it conducted?

The Silent Accord is the general class of binding agreement, established under Concordance 45, by which two or more parties undertake obligations that are not to be spoken aloud, recorded in audible form, or otherwise pe…

Silent Accord
Accord of Delineated Responsibility: what does it set out?

The Accord of Delineated Responsibility (catalogued as AD-771) is a foundational document of the archive that explicitly demarcates the operational and philosophical jurisdictions of two principal administrative bodies: …

Accord of Delineated Responsibility
Echoes of Accord: how is it conducted?

Echoes of Accord refer to a class of archival phenomena characterized by the audible or recorded recurrence of phrases from ratified Concordances in acoustically improbable locations. Their documentation and governance f…

Echoes of Accord

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.