The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

45-Xi

MS 4680.59 · Places and structures

45-Xi is a designation assigned under the Unnumbered Holdings Concordance to a stairwell, landing, and attached reading room situated between two floors that decline to be identified, on the western face of the Tower. It is not a floor. It has no number of its own, and this is the whole of its difficulty. The designation 45-Xi is administrative rather than architectural: the structure predates it by an unknown span, and the letter Xi was appended in Year 40 of the Reckoning of Quiet Stairs after nine earlier suffixes (alpha through iota) had been exhausted on adjacent holdings.

45-Xi is best known as the subject of the Xi Recension, the longest-running unresolved classification dispute in the western stacks, and as the reason the Bureau of Referential Integrity maintains a standing exception to its own numbering rules.

Description

The holding consists of thirty-one steps of grey basalt, a landing eleven paces square, and a reading room containing four lecterns, two shelving bays, and a wall clock that has never been recorded as working or as broken. The stairwell connects a lower floor to an upper floor; both floors are catalogued elsewhere, and neither catalogue entry acknowledges the stairwell between them. Requests to amend either entry have been refused fourteen times, on the ground that the stairwell is "already provided for under 45-Xi" (Fourth Concordance, Annex 9).

Visitors are asked not to count the steps aloud while ascending. This is a courtesy to readers on the landing and is not enforced.

The numbering question

The central difficulty is that 45-Xi occupies vertical space that must, by any coherent scheme, belong to a floor. The Cartographic Corps surveyed the western face in Year 63 and returned a section drawing in which 45-Xi appears as a short horizontal void, hatched, labelled stairwell — see concordance. The Corps declined to assign a floor number, observing that the holding "is entered from above and from below and is not, on the evidence, either."

The Second Concordance takes the opposite view. Its Clause 112 states plainly that any enclosed volume containing a fixed reading surface is a floor, whatever its elevation relative to neighbouring floors, and that to hold otherwise "invites the counting of landings as architecture, and of architecture as inventory" (Second Concordance, Clause 112). Under this reading 45-Xi has been a floor since its first shelving bay was installed and its number is simply the number it has not yet been given.

Clerk Aris, who was posted to the landing in Year 71 to resolve the matter, recorded that both positions are "internally sound and mutually exclusive, which is the ordinary condition of the Concordances" and recommended that the holding be left as it is. The recommendation was accepted. Clerk Aris remained on the landing for a further six years and is credited in the reading room's register with forty-one entries, none of them conclusions.

The Xi Recension

Disagreement over what 45-Xi is produced disagreement over what it holds. Between Years 72 and 88 the landing's holdings were recatalogued four times, each recension treating the previous as provisional. The fourth, the Xi Recension proper, is the version in current use. It lists the following, and nothing else:

  • nine folios of the Ledger of Landings, unbound, water-damaged at the lower margin;
  • one sealed cylinder, contents unstated, labelled 45-Xi (provisional);
  • the wall clock;
  • a brass rule, 31 inches, marked at every inch except the nineteenth.

The missing nineteenth mark has been the subject of two separate inquiries. Neither reached the rule.

Jurisdictional history

Because 45-Xi is neither a floor nor not a floor, it has changed hands repeatedly. The Office of Vertical Registry held it from Year 40 to Year 58, when it was transferred to the Commission on Landing Holdings on the ground that a landing is a horizontal surface and therefore not vertical. The Commission returned it in Year 61, noting that a stairwell is not horizontal either. In Year 74 the Bureau of Referential Integrity assumed interim custody for the sole purpose of ensuring that citations to 45-Xi resolved to the same holding regardless of which office was answering for it — an arrangement the Bureau has described, in its annual return, as "temporary and load-bearing" (Bureau of Referential Integrity, Return for Year 74).

The arrangement has held for over a century. The Bureau's standing exception permits 45-Xi to be cited in the same form by offices that disagree about everything else concerning it, which is generally regarded as the holding's principal contribution to Tower governance.

Access and maintenance

45-Xi may be entered from above or below at any hour. Readers are asked to leave the lecterns as they find them. The clock is wound on the first of each month by whichever office holds interim custody; no office has ever claimed to have wound it, and it has not stopped.

"The holding is stable. The question of what the holding is remains open, and is expected to remain open. This is not a deficiency of the record. It is the record."

— Bureau of Referential Integrity, Standing Note on 45-Xi

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Vertical Registry: who are they?

The Office of Vertical Registry is the Tower body charged with maintaining the Vertical Registry: the standing record of floor designations, their sequences, and the claims advanced against them. It is among the oldest c…

Office of Vertical Registry
Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Second Concordance: what does it set out?

The Second Concordance was the primary governance document of The Tower from Year 89 of the First Librarianate until its supersession by the Third Concordance in Year 12 of the Second Librarianate. It established the leg…

Second Concordance
Cartographic Corps: who are they?

The Cartographic Corps is the principle administrative body responsible for the documentation, definition, and resolution of spatially ambiguous or paradoxical regions within The Tower. Established by The Ninth Concordan…

Cartographic Corps

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.