The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Volumetric Irregularities

MS 9256.15 · Practices and doctrines

Volumetric Irregularities is the collective designation, under Concordance 71: On Architectural Anomalies, 4th Revision, Annex 9, for any recorded instance in which the measured volume of a Tower enclosure disagrees with its record volume in a manner not yet assigned to the ordinary work of the Office of Volumetric Assessment. The category is deliberately residual. Where Volumetric Anomalies are classed by cause and Volumetric Corridors are classed by location, Volumetric Irregularities are classed by nothing at all until the Office of the Receiver of Irregularities has had the file for ninety days. In the interval, the irregularity is said to be held open, and no one may alter the room.

Origin and separation

The category arose from a separation of duties rather than a discovery. Until the third recension of Concordance 71, all disagreements of volume fell to the Office of Volumetric Assessment, which had inherited them from the surveyors of the Volumetric Capture programme in the years following the Volumetric-Temporal Edicts. Assessment was competent at measuring and incompetent at prosecuting, and by the winter of the ninth survey cycle a backlog of some eleven hundred unclassified disagreements had accumulated in the sub-basement of Floor 1,104. The Receiver of Irregularities of the day, Marn Alvedene, proposed that anything Assessment could not assign within a season be transferred to her Office as an irregularity of procedure, on the reasoning that a volume which will not declare its cause is a volume whose paperwork has failed.

The transfer was authorized by Concordance 63, Clause 118, over the recorded objection of the Office of Volumetric Assessment, which noted in a marginalia now bound into the recension that "procedure does not cause displacement, and a leak is not a filing error" (Assessment memorandum, Ref. 63/118-opp). The objection was not withdrawn. It has instead been re-entered into the record at every subsequent revision, where it now occupies eleven pages and is the principal reason the 4th Revision runs to four volumes.

Classification and the ninety-day hold

An irregularity enters the category in one of two ways: by a surveyor's return that will not reconcile against the record volume, or by the discovery of an enclosure whose dimensions have changed without a corresponding entry in the Registry of Structural Record. The second is the more troublesome, because the Registry is amended only by the Bureau of Numerical Anomalies, a subdivision of the Department of Cardinal Irregularities, and the Bureau has never accepted that a change of dimension is an error in a number. The Bureau's position, restated in its standing circular of 14 Ember 41, is that a room which has grown has simply been measured more than once, and that the Registry records what was meant rather than what was found.

During the ninety-day hold, the enclosure is marked with a grey seal at the lintel and its contents are inventoried but not moved. The inventory is the only part of the process reliably performed. On Floor 2,209 in the winter of the eleventh cycle, a held enclosure was found to contain forty-one chairs, three of them occupied by clerks who had been in the room when the seal was applied and who continued to work there until the hold expired. Their timesheets were accepted. The room's record volume was never reconciled, and the file remains open under Ref. V-2209/11.

"Where the volume of an enclosure exceeds its record by more than one part in four hundred, the enclosure shall be sealed and held, and no party shall remove so much as a stool from it until the hold is released or the irregularity is otherwise determined."

— Concordance 71: On Architectural Anomalies, 4th Revision, Annex 9, clause 4

Relation to equivalence and stabilization

Volumetric Irregularities are distinguished from failures of Volumetric Equivalence by intent. Equivalence is a determination made in advance, by which two enclosures are declared to contain the same volume for purposes of transfer; an Irregularity is the after-the-fact discovery that they did not. The Precedent of Volumetric Independence P-4.09.22 established that an enclosure may hold its own volume independently of any equivalence declared over it, which had the practical effect of making every equivalence potentially an irregularity waiting to be found. Volumetric Stabilization is the remedy of first resort, though the Office of Volumetric Assessment has recorded, in its annual returns for four consecutive cycles, that stabilization addresses drift and not discrepancy, and that a room which was built the wrong size cannot be stabilized into being the right one.

Scholarly disagreement

The enduring dispute concerns whether Volumetric Irregularities are a genuine class or merely an administrative waiting room. The Office of Volumetric Assessment maintains the latter, and its position has the support of the Office of Volumetric Veracity, which observed in its 6th Report that a category defined by the absence of a cause cannot be said to have members, only tenants. The Office of the Receiver of Irregularities maintains the former, citing Clause 401 and the appeals heard under it, and points out that a tenant who has paid rent for a hundred and forty cycles is not usefully distinguished from an owner.

A third position, advanced by the clerk Sereth Ovinne in a private memorial deposited with the Scriptorium of Unsettled Questions and never answered, holds that the dispute is itself the category: that a volume is irregular precisely for as long as two offices disagree about it, and becomes ordinary the moment one of them concedes. Ovinne's memorial is catalogued as a Procedural Irregularity, having been deposited without the countersignature of her supervising officer. It has been held open since.

Notable holdings

The following irregularities are among those most frequently consulted, and are listed here in the order of their reference numbers as recorded in the Index of Held Enclosures:

  • Ref. V-0044/03 — the north scriptorium of Floor 44, which has measured 6,400 cubic cubits on every survey since the third cycle and 6,388 on every survey conducted in fog.
  • Ref. V-1104/09 — the Assessment backlog itself, held open on the ground that a room full of unclassified irregularities is an irregularity of volume.
  • Ref. V-2209/11 — the held enclosure on Floor 2,209, including its chairs.
  • Ref. V-7712/01 — an enclosure with no recorded dimensions, entered into the category by a surveyor who could not find it and declined to record that as an absence.

Maintenance staff are reminded that a held enclosure is to be swept only from the doorway.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Department of Cardinal Irregularities: who are they?

Department of Cardinal Irregularities is the Tower office charged with the supervision of all deviations in the primary and provisional spatial axes, the adjudication of disputes arising from such deviations, and the iss…

Department of Cardinal Irregularities
Office of Volumetric Assessment: who are they?

The Office of Volumetric Assessment (designated OVA in internal correspondence) is the administrative body responsible for the practical execution and adjudication of Volumetric Assessment, the quantification of spatial …

Office of Volumetric Assessment
Receiver of Irregularities: who are they?

Receiver of Irregularities is the formal title given to the chief administrative officer of the Office of the Receiver of Irregularities, which operates under the mandate of Concordance 37 for the identification and prov…

Receiver of Irregularities
Concordance 71: what does it set out?

The Concordance is divided into nine clauses, each addressing a specific procedural tier. Clause 71.1 mandates that any aperture discovered that does not correspond to a sanctioned blueprint must be reported within seven…

Concordance 71

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.