The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Vex 2

MS 3825.20 · Documents and ordinances

The designation Vex 2 refers to the second recension of the body of working papers known collectively as the Vex Ledgers, and, by extension, to the floor on which that recension is held. The two senses are not always distinguished in citation, a confusion the Bureau of Recensions has declined to resolve on the grounds that "the papers and the floor have not, in forty years, been observed apart" (Ninth Concordance, Annex 11). Vex 2 is not a person, despite frequent catalogue entries to the contrary; the misconception is discussed below.

Origin and recension

The first recension of the Vex Ledgers was assembled under the joint stewardship of Arlo Vex and Elara Vex and concerned itself chiefly with the saturation behaviour later formalised in the Vex Saturation Scale. The second recension, Vex 2, departs from it in two respects: it reorders the ledgers by resonance rather than by date, and it admits the terminal annotations of Lysandra Vex, consulted on the ergonomics of the reading desks, into the main sequence rather than the appendix. The reordering was carried out in the winter of Y186 SCE, over nineteen days, by a rota of four copyists whose names survive only as initials in the margin of Folio 2/Delta.

The recension was not universally welcomed. The Office of Sequential Integrity objected that reordering by resonance rendered the ledgers unusable for the reconstruction of dates, to which the Bureau of Recensions replied that "a date recovered from a resonance sequence is a date recovered twice" (Twelfth Concordance, Annex 4). The Office has never formally conceded and continues to maintain a parallel index, filed under protest, on the floor above.

Holding and situation

Vex 2 occupies the eastern half of a floor whose number is given in the catalogue as 2,204 and in the Concordance of Floors as 4,082; the discrepancy has been referred to the Concordance no fewer than six times and remains open. The floor is dry, lit by eleven aperture-lamps, and holds the recension in forty-one chained folios and two sealed crates whose contents are listed on their lids but may not be opened until the Vex Protocols admit the sealed-crate exception, which they do not presently do.

Access is by the north stair, which arrives at the floor without numbering; visitors are asked to record their arrival before recording their departure. A maintenance note affixed to the stair door in Y198 and never removed reads: "The eastern lamp is not to be relit during copying. It has been tried."

The disputed attribution

The principal scholarly disagreement concerning Vex 2 is whether it constitutes a separate holding or an edition of the Vex Ledgers. The Third Concordance treats recensions as editions, and editions as properties of their parent holding; the Ninth Concordance treats any recension that "alters the sequence of the whole" as a new holding, to be catalogued and cited in its own right. Both positions cite the ledgers; neither cites Vex 2 in support of itself, a circularity noted dryly by the archivist Arin Vex in a marginal gloss of Y191.

"The recension does not belong to the ledgers. It belongs to the floor, and the floor to the stair, and the stair to no one."

— Arin Vex, marginal gloss on Folio 2/Delta, verso

A minority position, advanced by the Office of Sequential Integrity and supported by Ardon Vex in a short memorandum of Y193, holds that Vex 2 is best understood as a suppression: the first recension survives only in fragments precisely because the second displaced it, and the fragments should therefore be read as evidence of what Vex 2 chose to lose. No copyist has attempted a reconciliation.

The attrition of the name

Because the designation is a numeral, it has repeatedly been mistaken for a person. The catalogue records at least nine entries for a "Vex the Second," including one post held briefly by a lamp-keeper on the floor below and one signature on a shipping manifest in the western stacks. The Bureau of Recensions has ruled that the numeral obliges no biographical reading and that "the second Vex is the second Vex, and no one need be found for it" (Bureau ruling 2,204/C, Y187). The matter is nonetheless raised most years at the Assizes of the Stair.

The numeral form has proved convenient in citation, and the Vex Saturation Scale and the Vex Cipher are both commonly cross-referenced to Vex 2 in later working papers, sometimes to papers that Vex 2 does not contain. The Bureau keeps a list of such references; it is now longer than the recension.

Inventory of Folio 2/Delta, as at Y204

The folio is the recension's working register and is the only part of Vex 2 in continuous use. Its present contents are:

  • nineteen leaves of resonance-ordered entries, initialled in the margin;
  • three leaves of Lysandra Vex's terminal annotations, admitted to the sequence;
  • one leaf of the copyists' rota, water-damaged at the lower edge;
  • the sealed-crate inventory, transcribed, with two entries struck through and unsigned;
  • the maintenance note from the stair door, filed loose, contrary to the Vex Protocols, Article 9.

The loose filing has not been corrected. The Bureau of Recensions has ruled, twice, that the note belongs with the stairs; the stairs, having no bureau, have not replied.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Arlo Vex: who were they?

Arlo Vex was a Senior Librarian best known for his role in The Case of the Receding Reference Desk and his later association with the suppressed doctrine of Circulationism.

Arlo Vex
Vex Protocols: how is it conducted?

Vex Protocols refer to the interrelated set of administrative and cryptographic processes developed primarily within the Vexian School, governing the verification, amendment, and ontological integration of archival holdi…

Vex Protocols
Bureau of Recensions: who are they?

Bureau of Recensions is the standing office of the Tower charged with the review, amendment, and quiet non-application of catalogical determinations issued by other bodies, most frequently the Office of Preliminary Attri…

Bureau of Recensions
Vex Ledgers: how is it conducted?

Vex Ledgers refers to a tripartite designation within the Tower’s administrative records, comprising a conceptual framework for logistical mapping, a specific set of documentary codices, and the physical apparatus used t…

Vex Ledgers

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.