The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Vessil Anworth

MS 1091.35 · Persons

Vessil Anworth was a clerk of the Ninth Margin and the last recorded holder of the office of Keeper of the Unentered, a post that existed principally to record those matters the Tower had decided not to catalogue. He is known chiefly for his two-volume Index of Absences (folios 1–488, with 489 left blank by instruction) and for the dispute concerning the Empty Shelf of Floor 2,206, which occupied the Standing Committee on Metric Stability for eleven sessions and was never formally closed.

Career

Anworth entered the Margin service in Year 288 of the Fourth Recension and was assigned to the receiving desk of the Ninth Margin, where he worked under the supervision of Adra Vessil, whose marginal notation had recently regularized the V- prefix. Colleagues' notes describe him as punctual and unusually literal. His first recorded act as a clerk was to decline a deposit on the grounds that the depositor had not specified which of two identically titled ledgers was intended; the note reads, in full, "Returned. Both."

He was elevated to the Keepership in Year 301, following the retirement of Marn Ossic, whose own records of the office consist of a single line: "Nothing this quarter." Anworth's tenure was to be longer and considerably noisier.

The Index of Absences

The Keepership had until Anworth's time produced no systematic register. Anworth proposed that the Tower's omissions be catalogued in the same manner as its holdings, on the reasoning that an absence is a fact about the archive and therefore belongs to it. The Concordance Mandate was cited in support, specifically Clause 12, which holds that "what the Tower has declined to hold remains a holding of the Tower, held elsewhere." The interpretation was contested at once. The Bureau of Structural Integrity objected that a catalogue of absences would require shelving, and that no shelving had been authorized for material that was not present.

Anworth answered the objection in the preface to the first volume:

"A shelf may be empty and still be a shelf. I propose we number it."

— Vessil Anworth, Index of Absences, Preface to Volume I

The first volume catalogues 2,314 absences, each with a floor, a date of decline, and the name of the clerk who declined it. The second volume is largely cross-referential, and its entries are shorter, owing to what Anworth described in his cover note as "the difficulty of citing what has already been cited as absent twice."

The Empty Shelf of Floor 2,206

In the winter of Year 309, a junior clerk reported that a shelf on Floor 2,206 had been assigned a catalogue number but held no material and never had. Anworth entered the shelf in the Index as Absence 1,177 and requested that it be formally struck from the holdings. The request was refused by the floor's sub-librarian on the ground that the shelf was in good order and had been paid for. The matter reached the Standing Committee on Metric Stability in the spring.

The Committee heard the case over eleven sessions. Anworth argued that a numbered shelf without holdings was an absence and must be entered as such. The Directorate of Aperture Alignment submitted that the shelf's number was itself a holding, and that the shelf was therefore not empty but occupied by its number. The Committee found for the Directorate by a majority of four to three, with two abstentions recorded as "present but not persuaded." Anworth entered the ruling in the Index as Absence 1,178, on the reasoning that the Committee's decision had removed a dispute from the record without resolving it. This entry was later struck by the Standing Waiver, then restored on appeal, then struck again.

Dispute with the Office of Visual Resonance

Anworth's relations with the Office of Visual Resonance were poor from the outset, owing to his refusal to allow that office's registrars to inspect the Index on the ground that they would be inspecting nothing. The Office's first registrar, Vellic Anworth, was no relation and is recorded as having taken offence at the confusion of names — a grievance he filed twice, the second time after the first was lost.

The quarrel produced the celebrated ruling of Year 313, in which Anworth was instructed to distinguish in his entries between absences that had been declined and absences that had simply never been proposed. Anworth complied by adding a column, which he left empty for the declined entries on the ground that they required no further remark.

Later life and the unentered end of the Index

Anworth continued in the Keepership until Year 327, when he petitioned for relief on grounds of age and the sheer volume of what was not being catalogued. The petition was granted, and the office was placed under Standing Order 712, which provides for the suspension of any post whose duties cannot be distinguished from their absence. No successor was appointed. The Index was closed at folio 488.

Folio 489 is blank. Anworth's instruction, filed with the volume and still observed by the reading room staff, is that it remain so. Visitors wishing to consult the Index should note that the second volume is kept on the closed shelf and must be requested at the desk; the blank folio may be viewed only by appointment, and no more than two persons may view it at once.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Bureau of Structural Integrity: who are they?

The Bureau of Structural Integrity is a sub-agency of the Department of Structural Integrity tasked with the primary enforcement of acceptable strain parameters for all permanent architectural and volumetric additions to…

Bureau of Structural Integrity
Concordance Mandate: how is it conducted?

The Concordance Mandate is the class of instrument by which the Librarians derive a given office's standing from a numbered Concordance, and the standing so derived. It is not a document but a category, though the catalo…

Concordance Mandate
Standing Committee on Metric Stability: who are they?

The Standing Committee on Metric Stability (SCoMS) is a permanent regulatory body of the Librarians established by the Third Concordance, Annex G, Clause 12, with a mandate to "oversee the formal properties of measuremen…

Standing Committee on Metric Stability
Standing Order 712: what does it set out?

Standing Order 712 is the foundational regulatory instrument governing the inter-floor transfer of sensitive, transient, or ontologically malleable materials within the Tower. Its formal title is "Protocols for the Trans…

Standing Order 712

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.