Tome of Concurrence
MS 4510.32 · Documents and ordinances
The Tome of Concurrence is the secondary ledger prescribed by Ordinance 22's Witnessing Protocol, Clause 4-7, for the attestation of any event at which a Living Tome is present but not itself the subject of inscription. It is maintained in triplicate, with the three recensions held at Floor 307, Floor 451, and Annex Δ; by long convention none of the three may be cited against another without a Concordance of Citing Recensions being opened first. Entries are made by members of the Attesting Quorum after a witnessed event has concluded, and each entry records the event, the names of the attesting witnesses, and the reason the primary ledger was, in the Quorum's phrase, "otherwise engaged." The Tome of Concurrence is not a primary record. It is the record of why a primary record was not made.
Origin and the Question of the Primary Ledger
The Tome arose in the aftermath of the Silent Winter of Floor 199, when a quorum of eleven attestants signed a primary ledger at the close of a witnessing, dined, and discovered on returning that the ledger's folios had been rebound in the wrong order. The attestations remained valid; the order of what had occurred did not. The Bureau of Attested Occurrence concluded that a second ledger, kept in a different room and bound by a different scriptorium, would allow the order to be reconstructed if the primary folios were ever disordered again. Ordinance 22 was amended accordingly in the third month of the following year, and the first Tome of Concurrence entered service eleven days before Annex Δ was opened.
It was not until the Clause 4-7 revision that the practice acquired its characteristic turn. The revised clause held that a witnessed event might be entered in the Tome of Concurrence alone, in the primary ledger alone, or in neither, provided the Attesting Quorum could agree which. Once a disposition had been entered, it could not be altered without a fresh witnessing of the original event — an event which, having already occurred, was not available to be witnessed again. Clerks refer to this difficulty as the Second Witnessing Problem, and it is the reason the Tome is consulted more often by those seeking to prove that something was not attested than by those seeking to prove that it was.
Recensions and Concurrence with the Tome
The triplicate recensions are collated once every Concurrence — that is, in the month following Metathesis in the official calendar — and not at the close of the year, a schedule that has generated a persistent ambiguity. Concordance 88, Annex 2, holds that "the three recensions shall speak as one voice where their entries permit," a phrasing relied upon by the Collation Office of Floor 451 to overwrite minor discrepancies in the other two. The sister recensions maintain that Annex 2 concerns the reading of the Tomes and not their amendment.
"Where the recensions differ, they differ correctly; it is the coincidence of their wording, and not the coincidence of their contents, that the Tome is named for."
— Concordance 88, Dissent of the Floor 307 Recension
The wording of that dissent is not itself found in the Floor 307 recension, whose folio 204 was removed in the winter of the year cited and has never been restored. That the dissent survives at all, and survives only in the record of its own absence, is regarded by the School of Disordered Folios as a leading proof of the Priority Paradox which the Violet Tome with Silver Clasps was later to formally recognize. Others hold that the dissent is a composition of the Archive of Replies and has no bearing on the Paradox.
The Marn Procedure and Its Suspension
In the first decades of the Tome's service, attestants followed the practice of the clerk Edivar Marn, who read each evening's entry aloud in the presence of the primary ledger so that the order of events could be checked against the earlier record. The Marn Procedure worked well until a witnessed event of exceptionable length — an Induction of a Living Tome conducted across three floors, an account of which is held in the Register of Unclosed Loops — required the reading to continue for six nights without the primary ledger being closed. At its conclusion the attestants could not determine whether the reading had occurred before or after the entry it read. The procedure was suspended by Ordinance 41, which additionally prohibited the reading of the Tome in the presence of itself. Marn is not recorded as having objected, though his clerks noted that the prohibition was addressed to the Tome and not to them.
Disputes of Custody
Custody of the Floor 451 recension has been contested since a dispute between the Office of the Closing Ratio and the Collation Office over whether a discrepancy of one letter in a witness's name constituted a distinct witness. The Office maintained that it did; the Collation Office maintained that the Tome had already ruled, having recorded the same residue twice. The matter was referred to the Librarians, whose finding is preserved in the Docket of Unsettled Scribes and which neither side has accepted. Three of the eleven quorum signatures for the event in question were subsequently invalidated, leaving the witnessed event attested by eight persons, of whom four could not be located afterward.
The Tome itself has never issued a correction, and the Custodian's standing instruction, cited in the Librarian Progression Ordinances as Appendix 9, is that "the Tome that corrects itself is a Tome that has been read." Readers consulting the Tome of Concurrence are asked to leave the clasps in the position in which they find them and to report any folio that appears to have been read.
Relation to the Weights and Measures
By a provision of the Tome of Jurisprudential Weights and Measures, the Tome of Concurrence is one of the volumes against which Tome-Calipers are checked before the calibration of the Aethelred Tome-Weight. The Violet Tome with Silver Clasps, Annex 7, mandated the Aethelred standard across all floors and fixed its mass at 1.27 kilograms; the Concurrence's own specification, given in the Floor 307 recension, differs by a margin the Bureau of Attested Occurrence declines to state. Owing to the Schedule of Recensions, the Concurrence sits with its own plates closed, and the measurement cannot presently be taken. The Standing Question on the margin is entered in the Register of Unclosed Loops as unresolved and has been returned to the agenda for the ninth successive year.
See also
-
MS 0412.50
Secondary Inscription
Secondary Inscription is the practice of inscribing a record upon a surface that has already borne an inscription, whether or not …
-
MS 8880.24
Ceremonial Inscription
Ceremonial Inscription is the act of setting a designation into a Ceremonial Ledger under the conditions of physical composition, …
-
MS 5068.27
Voluminous Register of Vital Fluctuations
Voluminous Register of Vital Fluctuations is a subsidiary ledger maintained on Floor 441.7β, cataloguing secondary perturbations o…
-
MS 4811.35
Witnessing Protocol (Clause 4-7)
Witnessing Protocol (Clause 4-7) is the procedural framework within The Protocol for Sustained Engagement that operationalizes the…
-
MS 9001.34
Edict of Conjunctional Inscription
The Edict of Conjunctional Inscription is the informal name by which the archival and procedural provisions of Ordinance 747-B are…
-
MS 5129.13
Affixation Witnessing
Affixation Witnessing is the formal act by which a seal's application to a substrate is observed and thereby rendered admissible t…
Referenced by
- MS 7062.57 The Aethelred Tome-Weight
- MS 0828.53 Witnessing
- MS 4811.35 Witnessing Protocol (Clause 4-7)
- MS 7869.77 Tome of Blank Pages
- MS 5211.43 Clause 5 (Inscription Protocol)
- MS 0412.50 Secondary Inscription
- MS 2990.92 Non-Euclidean Tome
- MS 5129.13 Affixation Witnessing
- MS 1292.16 Dusted Stacks
- MS 1391.61 Tome of Unspoken Noons
- MS 1217.28 Incident of the Twice-Tallied Tome
- MS 3971.75 Tome of the Silent Echo
Readers also asked
Tome of Jurisprudential Weights and Measures: what does it set out?
The Tome of Jurisprudential Weights and Measures is a foundational reference document maintained by the Department of Jurisprudential Anomalies of the School of Jurisprudential Ontology. Codified under Annex 3 of Concord…
Tome of Jurisprudential Weights and MeasuresMetathesis: how is it conducted?
Metathesis is the third month in the official calendar of the Tower, following Exhortation and preceding Concurrence. It comprises 33 days and is historically significant as the period during which a majority of administ…
MetathesisConcordance 88: what does it set out?
The document formally designated Concordance 88, also referred to in some filing indices as "The Crossed Quill Concordance," is a core administrative instrument governing the allocation and withdrawal of amendment-tracki…
Concordance 88Floor 451: where is it?
The floor's precise spatial relationship to its neighbors is a matter of procedural cartography. While the Central Index lists it sequentially between Floor 412 and Floor 440 the Gilded Aviary, transit manifests from Flo…
Floor 451Passages cited from this record
-
Where the recensions differ, they differ correctly; it is the coincidence of their wording, and not the coincidence of their contents, that the Tome is named for.
Concordance 88, Dissent of the Floor 307 Recension
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3042.19 School of Disordered Folios
- MS 8219.24 Docket of Unsettled Scribes
- MS 0369.29 Edivar Marn
- MS 7749.16 Attesting Quorum
Because you consulted