The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Thegdivisiongofgprecedentg Amp Gprotocolgdpp

MS 7721.42 · Guilds, orders and offices

Thegdivisiongofgprecedentg Amp Gprotocolgdpp is the standing office charged with the custody, recension and enforcement of prior rulings bearing on the handling of ampliative instruments. It is not a department of the Division of Precedent Amp Protocol, despite the near-identity of name; the two bodies have been formally distinct since the Concordance of Nomenclature ruled in 4 119 that a single letter is sufficient grounds for separate administration. The Thegdivisiong occupies the east stair of the Forty-Ninth Landing and maintains a reading room on the floor beneath it, into which no copying materials may be brought: the whole of the archive is consulted in situ, and readers leave their pens with the door-warden.

Origin and the split of 4 119

The office began as a sub-clerk's desk within the Division proper, established to answer a recurring question — namely, which earlier determination governs when two determinations on the same instrument disagree. Its founder, the clerk Ilse Vantram, kept a running ledger of such disagreements and was eventually instructed to stop keeping it, on the reasoning that a ledger of contradictions is itself a contradiction. She did not stop. When the ledger reached four hundred entries it was seized, sealed, and returned eleven years later with the binding cut and one hundred and six entries removed. Vantram's marginal note on the returned volume survives and is frequently cited: "The gaps are the finding."

The removals were subsequently ratified by Concordance 4 119, which also established the office's independence and its awkward name. The doubled consonants are not typographical error; they preserve the spelling of the original warrant, drafted by a clerk who doubled letters when writing under pressure. Three attempts to regularise the spelling have failed on the ground that amendment would void an unbroken chain of citation.

Function

The Thegdivisiong does not decide cases. It determines which prior decision a later decision is to be read against, and issues a Precedent Binding Note recording the choice. A Binding Note has no force in itself, but proceedings that proceed without one are liable to be reopened at any later date, and in practice most offices will not touch an ampliative instrument until a Note is on the file. The Notes are numbered in the order of their issue and not in the order of the rulings they concern.

Where a Note is contested, the matter goes to the Panel of Recollectors, a body of five senior Librarians who hear argument while seated and deliver findings while standing, a custom whose origin is not recorded. The Panel sits twice yearly, in the first week of the second and eighth months, and has been known to dispose of a queue of forty matters in a single afternoon by reading the citations aloud and waiting.

The Winter of the Borrowed Seal

In the winter of 4 203 the office suffered the incident for which it is now best known. A junior clerk, Halloran Spetch, engaged to collate rulings on the Cataloguing Amp lineage, was granted the loan of the office seal for a single afternoon. He used it for nine days. During that period he issued forty-one Binding Notes, of which sixteen concerned instruments that had never existed and eleven concerned instruments that would not exist for another two years.

The regularity of Spetch's work defended it. Each fabricated Note cited a genuine ruling, and each genuine ruling cited a Note that Spetch had already issued, so that the whole series hung together without a break. The fraud was discovered not by audit but by a researcher who remarked that the sequence read unusually well. All forty-one Notes were withdrawn by Edict 9 887, which has itself never been fully applied — four of the Notes remain in force because the instruments they govern have since come into existence, and the Thegdivisiong takes the position that the Edict, drafted in the past tense, cannot reach them.

"A note may be withdrawn from the record. It is much harder to withdraw it from the world, and the office does not undertake the latter."

— Memorandum of the Thegdivisiong, 4 204, clause 6

Dispute over the order of citation

The office is presently divided against the Division of Precedent Amp Protocol on the question of citation order. Concordance 2 611, Annex 3, requires that precedents be cited newest-first, on the ground that the most recent ruling has had the longest to be tested. Concordance 2 611, Annex 4, appended forty years later and bound into the same volume, requires oldest-first, on the ground that age is the only qualification that cannot be manufactured. Both annexes remain in force. The Edicts Amp Directives system recognised the pair as a stock example of the category of Procedural Amp Doctrinal Contradictions, a recognition that settled nothing but gave the dispute a filing number.

Practitioners resolve the difficulty by citing simultaneously, in a format the office neither authorises nor objects to, in which the oldest and newest rulings bracket the intervening ones and are held to discharge the requirement twice over. The Thegdivisiong's own guidance, issued 4 388, permits this and adds a single sentence of practical counsel: "Officers citing in this manner are reminded that the two ends must be read aloud together, and not in sequence, and that the reading should be audible from the doorway."

Status of the office

The Thegdivisiong is administered by a Custodian, an office held in rotation and currently vacant pending the outcome of a question referred to the Panel in 4 402: whether a Custodian may be appointed from among the Recollectors, or whether the separation of functions requires a candidate who has never ruled on anything. The office continues to issue Notes under the seal of the senior desk-clerk, an arrangement described in its own records as provisional and now in its nineteenth year. Its holdings run to some eleven thousand volumes, of which three are catalogued as missing and two as "present but not to be consulted." The reading room opens at the second bell and closes when the east stair is swept. Pens are left at the door.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Procedural Amp Doctrinal Contradictions: how is it conducted?
Division of Precedent Amp Protocol: who are they?

The Division of Precedent Amp Protocol has concurred that Annex C (the Table of Permitted Transpositions) of Protocol A9-γ is partially illegible in its third recension. This concurrence is itself disputed: the second re…

Division of Precedent Amp Protocol
Cataloguing Amp: what is it for?

Cataloguing Amp (CA) refers to a standardized, portable, multi-phasic recording instrument, officially designated as Type-VII-C, used in the practice of Isolation Amp Cataloguing. Its primary function is to establish a l…

Cataloguing Amp
Edicts Amp Directives: how is it conducted?

Edicts Amp Directives is the standardized codification system for the administrative, procedural, and doctrinal pronouncements issued by the Librarians of the Tower. The system governs the form, registration, cross-refer…

Edicts Amp Directives

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.