The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Unwritten Precedent

MS 2651.40 · Practices and doctrines

The Unwritten Precedent is a class of authoritative determination within the Tower that has not been inscribed upon any page, yet is held to bind the floors insofar as it is recalled, invoked, or otherwise operative through absence. It is distinguished from the Unwritten Page by its standing as settled decision rather than mere blank leaf, and from the holdings of the Chamber of Unwritten Precedents by the fact that the Chamber catalogues candidates whereas the Precedent itself is that which has attained force. The Librarian of the Unwritten maintains custody of such determinations under the delegation of The Unwritten Concordance, and the Secretariat for Unwritten Protocols certifies those permitted to argue their existence.

Origin and Early Recension

The first attested operation of an Unwritten Precedent is recorded in the margin of the lost Spiral Roll of Floor 4,117, wherein the Senior Scriptor of the Northern Aperture noted that "a matter settled without writing binds more closely than one bound in error." This annotation, being itself written, is excluded from the class it describes; the Precedent it announces is not. The Precedent of the Phantom Footnote arose in the following century, permitting unwritten volumes to be cited and their authors debated, and thereby supplied the procedural vehicle by which an Unwritten Precedent might be pleaded before the Archivists of the Unwritten.

Disceptatio #0017, concerning the ontological priority of inked declarations over unwritten precedent, led to the founding of the Theoretical Jurisprudence Guild and produced the standing rift between that body and the Censors of the Unwritten Word, who hold that nothing unprinted can be said to govern. The Guild counters that the Third Concordance, Title IV, grants authority to Resolutions holding "the force of precedent until unwritten," and that the Unwritten Precedent is the necessary residue of this provision.

Authority and Contradiction

The force of an Unwritten Precedent is not uniform across the vertical extent of the Tower. The Third Concordance affirms that resolutions unwritten retain precedential weight, while the The Unwritten Concordance Hypothesis contends that all concordances are themselves unwritten and therefore self-authorising only in recall. The The Clause of Unwritten Authority further complicates the matter by stating that an unwritten determination may supersede a written one where the latter is held in the Register of Vacated Texts.

"No floor shall be compelled by a ruling it cannot produce, yet every floor is presumed to have been so compelled from the date of its numbering."

— The Unwritten Concordance, Title II, Clause 9

Clerks of the Wing for Unwritten Concordances observe that the contradiction between Title II and the Third Concordance has never been adjudicated, as no officer has yet submitted a written complaint concerning an unwritten injury.

Certification and Custody

The Librarians of the Unwritten are certified to distinguish Unwritten Pages and to use them for recording unwritten content, a practice formally extended to Precedents by the Archive of Unwritten Prefaces, a subordinate annex to the Wing. The Breath of the Unwritten is the recorded medium by which a Precedent is spoken into the custody of the Librarian of the Unwritten; the Sounds of Unwritten Prefaces are the acoustic indices employed to retrieve it. Lysandra of the Unwritten Stair, first Commissioner of the Department of Potential Traversal, established the precedent for closing "potential traversal" files, a ruling later cited as an Unwritten Precedent despite its having been inscribed, a contradiction the Secretariat for Unwritten Protocols has declined to resolve.

Incident of the Winter of Floor 2,884

In the forty-third winter of the current recension, a dispute arose on Floor 2,884 between the Keeper of Apertures and the Guild of Vertical Notaries over whether an Unwritten Precedent could be nullified by being forgotten. The Notaries argued that absence of recall equalled absence of force; the Keeper produced a sealed token marked only with the spiral delta and stated that the Precedent "subsists in the token though no tongue recall it." The Unwritten Index, administered by the Secretariat, recorded the token without commentary. No ruling issued, and the matter remains in the Chamber of Unwritten Precedents as File U-2884-ω.

It is forbidden to bring a lit candle into the Chamber when filing an unwritten claim, as the light has been held to render the absence illegible.

Scholarly Disagreement

The central dispute concerns whether an Unwritten Precedent requires a minimum of one living invoker to remain in force. The Theoretical Jurisprudence Guild holds that a single citation by a certified Librarian of the Unwritten is sufficient in perpetuity. The Censors of the Unwritten Word dispute this, citing Disceptatio #0017 and arguing that "a thing unkept by ink is a thing unkept." The The Unwritten Biography of Archivist K'n records a third position, that the Precedent exists only between the moment of its forgetting and the moment of its rediscovery, a view the Archivists of the Unwritten have neither endorsed nor refuted, noting only that the view itself appears nowhere in their catalogue.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Sounds of Unwritten Prefaces: how is it conducted?

Sounds of Unwritten Prefaces are a class of acoustic phenomena catalogued on Floor 14,022, defined as the auditory corollaries to the material held in the Gallery of Unwritten Prefaces. Governed by a contentious intersec…

Sounds of Unwritten Prefaces
The Unwritten Concordance Hypothesis: how is it conducted?

The Unwritten Concordance Hypothesis is a foundational principle within The Structural Stress Theory, proposing that a definitive, unwritten edition of the Tower's governing principles is responsible for observed structu…

The Unwritten Concordance Hypothesis
Librarians of the Unwritten: how is it conducted?

The Librarians of the Unwritten constitute a specialized certification within the custodial order of The Librarians, granted to those who demonstrate proficiency in cataloging, preserving, and managing subjects that, by …

Librarians of the Unwritten
The Clause of Unwritten Authority: how is it conducted?

The Clause of Unwritten Authority is the fourth and final clause of the Precept of Unwritten Catalogues, a foundational administrative document governing the classification and handling of unwritten materials within the …

The Clause of Unwritten Authority

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.