The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Principle of Uncatalogued Space

MS 7686.43 · Practices and doctrines

The Principle of Uncatalogued Space is the governing doctrine, first set down in Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, by which the Tower reserves portions of its volume — floors, alcoves, landings, and certain vertical shafts of disputed ownership — from any form of catalogue entry, while nonetheless acknowledging that such space exists. It is distinguished from simple omission by the requirement of active reservation: an uncatalogued space must be declared, witnessed, and sealed, and only then left entirely alone. The Principle is the doctrinal parent of the Uncatalogued Lower Floors, the charter under which The Ornate Chair is held, and the perennial adversary of the Axiom of Tangibility and the Principle of Singular Provenance, each of which would prefer the Tower's space accounted for.

Origin and the Kessendall Sealing

The Principle was not drafted in the scriptoria but discovered in the field. In the winter of the year the Tower's survey records designate 4-R-1188, a surveyor named Ordwin Kessendall was dispatched to measure a gallery on the eight-hundred-and-sixth landing and found that every time a measurement was recorded, the gallery's dimensions changed by the width of the measuring cord. Kessendall's report to the Office of Vertical Survey recommended that the gallery be left unmeasured altogether, and that the omission be entered in the register as a positive act — "a sealing of the door, not a forgetting of the room," as he wrote in his covering letter of 14 February 4-R-1188. The recommendation was adopted by Librarian-Adjutant Vess on the ninth of the following month, and the gallery has remained sealed and unmeasured since. It is now designated Landing 806-Uncatalogued, and no one has opened it, on the reasoning that opening it would constitute a measurement.

Doctrinal content

The Principle rests on the claim that catalogued space and uncatalogued space behave differently with respect to their contents, and that the difference is not merely administrative. Catalogued space accepts objects and holds them; uncatalogued space, according to the Fourth Concordance, "holds nothing that can be said to be held, and returns nothing that can be said to be returned." Because the Taxonomy of Paradoxical Objects governs the boundary between the uncatalogued and the non-existent, the contents of a sealed space under the Principle occupy a category the Taxonomy declines to name, listing them only as unspecified-but-extant.

"Let the space be declared, and let it then be left. What is declared and left is reserved; what is left and undeclared is lost."

— Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, clause 7

The clause is the subject of the longest-running dispute in the Tower's administrative history. The Third Concordance forbids the appropriation of catalogued space for uncatalogued purpose, which the office of the Keeper of the Seals reads as prohibiting exactly the sort of sealing the Fourth Concordance requires; the Fourth Concordance's defenders reply that a sealed space is not appropriated but abdicated, and that the Third Concordance speaks only to space that was already catalogued, whereas the Principle applies from the outset. Neither reading has ever been withdrawn.

The Selvage objection

M. Thaddeus Selvage, whose Selvage Principle argued that catalogued subjects must be visually delineated from the uncatalogued void rather than blended into it by gradient, took an interest in sealed spaces and objected to their treatment. In his Notes on the Boundary (4-R-1203), Selvage argued that a sealed space without a drawn boundary invites the eye to treat the boundary as a suggestion, and that the Tower should therefore paint a hard line around every uncatalogued space at the moment of sealing. The Office of Vertical Survey declined on the grounds that the paint itself would be a measurement, and Selvage's proposal was never entered into any recension. A compromising annotation survives in the margin of the survey register — "line proposed, line refused" — with no further comment.

Interaction with provisional storage

The Principle has proved difficult to reconcile with the Thorne Principle of Provisional Permanence, under which any uncatalogued provisional storage solution left in place for longer than one fiscal quire acquires the permissions of a permanent fixture. Clerks in the Bureau of Provisional Architecture have argued that a sealed space, being itself a long-standing uncatalogued solution, must by Thorne's reasoning have become a permanent fixture — which would require it to be catalogued, which the Principle forbids. The Bureau's standing ruling is that the two principles operate on different scales and do not conflict, and that clerks who raise the question should be reassigned to the stairwells. This ruling has never been put in writing.

A further difficulty arose in the Requisitioned Repositories affair, when the Librarian officiating at the time attempted to store surplus card stock under the Principle by declaring the holding itself uncatalogued. The declaration was accepted; the card stock was not recovered. The Principle of Distinction was subsequently invoked to settle the matter, on the reasoning that two things in the same space must be different, and that the holding and the stock could not both be uncatalogued at once.

Procedure and practical notes

Sealing is performed in the presence of two Librarians and one witness drawn by lot from the Vestibule roster. The witness is required to confirm that the space has been left, and the confirmation is entered in a register that is itself kept in a sealed cabinet under the Principle, which means that the procedure is recorded twice and readable neither time. Maintenance through sealed space proceeds by arrangement with the Office of Vertical Survey; the office's standing instruction permits pipe-laying and ladder runs, but forbids leaving a toolbox inside a sealed space overnight, on the ground that a toolbox is a claim of occupancy.

Sealed spaces are listed in the Register of Declared Omissions, a volume whose entries record only the floor number, the date of sealing, and the phrase left as declared. The register's final page carries a note in Kessendall's hand, added after his retirement: that the eight-hundred-and-sixth landing had once contained a chair, and that he had not measured it either.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Requisitioned Repositories: how is it conducted?

A Requisitioned Repository is a temporary administrative classification applied to any chamber or substructure within The Tower that has been formally commandeered for purposes of storing, quarantining, or processing mat…

Requisitioned Repositories
Taxonomy of Paradoxical Objects: how is it conducted?

Objects of paradoxical nature shall be indexed by their contradiction, not their form, and cross-referenced to all conflicting ontologies they simultaneously inhabit.

Taxonomy of Paradoxical Objects
Uncatalogued Lower Floors: where is it?

Uncatalogued Lower Floors is a designation for a collection of Tower levels below The Ornate Chair, whose existence is documented in procedural records but whose contents have not been formally appended to any of the Tow…

Uncatalogued Lower Floors

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.