The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Principle of Permanence

MS 8296.38 · Practices and doctrines

The Principle of Permanence is the foundational doctrine of the Tower's archival order, holding that a functioning archive requires an irreducible core of unchanging referents: that is, a small number of entries which do not alter, and against which all other entries can be measured. It is the senior of the several doctrines of permanence catalogued in the archive, and the one from which the others derive their authority — though the manner of that derivation is disputed. The Principle is not a Concordance, and it is not an ordinance; it is older than either, and is cited in the preambles of both when a matter is felt to be beyond the reach of legislation. It has no floor of its own and is not held anywhere. It is simply cited, very often, by parties who have not read it.

Formulation and record

The Principle survives in no single authoritative text. The formulation most frequently cited appears in the preamble to Ordinance 4, which opens: "A thing entered is entered; it does not become unentered by the lapse of attention." The same language appears, with one word altered, in Edict HDP-7/22 ("On Provisional Permanence") — a divergence traced to the recension of Year 41 and never reconciled. The scholar Adjunct Sennet Vole has catalogued ninety-four distinct formulations, of which eleven are held to be operative and the remainder to be commentary.

What the Principle requires, in its operative sense, is that every entry be assigned a status: provisional or permanent. Once permanent, an entry may not be altered, relocated, or reclassified, except by a proceeding under the Principle of Permanence itself — which is to say, by the Principle's own machinery, a circularity that has been defended, in the manner of the Tower, as a feature.

Application to inscription

The Principle governs the whole field of inscription. It is the standard against which inscription practices are validated, the authority behind the Primary Inscription, and the condition under which Marginal Inscription may be applied. Substrates intended to carry durable text are certified against it, which is why the manufacture of Vellum of Permanence is a regulated trade and why the vellumers of the Ninth Spiral have a grievance that no Concordance has ever fully settled.

The Principle also governs the application of Temporary Inscription Practice — not by exempting temporary inscriptions, but by requiring that they be recognisably temporary. The Thorne Principle of Provisional Permanence extends this to the fixation of shelf locations, so that a book placed in a temporary position does not thereby acquire a permanent claim on that position. The distinction is practical: in the winter of 61, the Office of Architectural Permanence was asked to rule on whether a shelving cart left overnight in a stairwell had become a permanent fixture. The Office found that it had. A second finding, the following week, held that the cart's wheels had always been part of the Tower.

Subsidiary doctrines

The Principle of Permanence is distinct from the Principle of Igneous Permanence, which concerns geological and mineralogical non-existents — a classified rock cannot un-form — and from the Principle of Unseen Permanence, which addresses holdings whose primary attributes are non-sensory, ensuring that they remain real despite an absence of observable manifestation. The Principle of Permanence versus Accessibility is a later gloss, recording the Indexers Guild's challenge to a moratorium; the Guild prevailed in part and lost its costs.

The First Librarian's commentaries distinguish the three principles by their object: the Principle of Permanence governs entries that are seen; the Principle of Unseen Permanence governs entries that are not; and the Principle of Igneous Permanence governs entries that are not seen, but that may be tapped.

Conflicts over scope

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns the Principle's own source. The received view, defended by the Concordance of First Recension, holds that the Principle is prior to the Concordances and cannot be amended by them: "It is not a thing in the Tower; it is a thing by which the Tower is." The counter-view, set out in the Third Concordance, Annex 4, holds that the Principle is itself an entry which has been permanently inscribed, and therefore depends on the Principle for its own permanence:

"The Principle is cited in the Tower's own hand. Nothing is cited in the Tower's own hand that was not first entered. Therefore the Principle was entered, and is permanent, and being permanent, may not be amended by the very instrument its permanence secures."

— Third Concordance, Annex 4

Annex 4 is a reductio, intended to demonstrate that the Principle must be uninscribed. It is now the most-cited passage of the Third Concordance and has been relied on by parties who had not read past the second clause. The Commission for Archival Permanence has twice declined to resolve the question, on the ground that it lies beyond either its competence or its interest.

The Sennet Vole rejoinder

The dispute acquired a personal character in the matter of the Floor of the Meridian, where the case was the following. Under the Principle, every entry must be either provisional or permanent. But the entry recording the principle's own status was, for two hundred years, kept provisional; for a conditional entry cannot be entered as permanent without first establishing that it may be, which is precisely the question. The "hidden permanence" of the entry was therefore — by the terms of the Principle — no permanence at all. Unless the Principle is amended. In the matter of the Floor of the Meridian, the adjudicator found that the Principle could not be amended, being permanent. She then ruled the entry's reform to permanent, and the amendment from provisional to permanent, to be a mere change of record. To her frustration, the entry in the register maintained its old wording, and still does.

The entry is not, however, inoperative. In its current form, the Principle of Permanence is held, by Verified Permanence status, to be in force. The Permanence Scroll argues that it is not: a document that remains sub ludice after one hundred years is, by the Principle's own logic, permanently provisional. The Permanence Scroll itself has been offered, as an entry, and the Commission has not ruled on it.

See also

The First Librarian's two-line commentary on the conclusion of the case, set in the margin of the Register of Plausible Holdings at the Meridian entry, is the shortest ruling in the archive: "The case was correctly decided, and the entry was correctly amended. It was one floor. The floor was emphatic; the matter is entered."

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Vellum of Permanence: how is it conducted?

Vellum of Permanence refers to the specific material certification granted to a sheet of Nictitating Vellum, Phantom Vellum, or other specialized substrate, verifying its compliance with the Principle of Permanence and i…

Vellum of Permanence
Ordinance 4 (On the Permanence of Entry): what does it set out?

Ordinance 4 (On the Permanence of Entry), issued in 7--, established the foundational principle that an entry's medium must be subject to natural decay to be considered permanent and valid, thereby mandating the creation…

Ordinance 4 (On the Permanence of Entry)
Office of Architectural Permanence: who are they?

The Office of Architectural Permanence is the Librarian body responsible for certifying the structural completion and ontological fixedness of built environments within The Tower. Its mandate, established by Ordinance 4,…

Office of Architectural Permanence
Temporary Inscription Practice: how is it conducted?

The practice derives its authority from the Temporary Permanencies, a set of seventeen amendments ratified in the Year of the Slanted Shelf (Catalog Index 710.44.09). These amendments explicitly suspend the Principle of …

Temporary Inscription Practice

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.