The Jurisdictional School
MS 8251.00 · Practices and doctrines
The Jurisdictional School is the collective designation for the loose federation of practitioners, offices, and reading rooms occupied with the determination of which body has authority over a matter, and by what instrument that authority was acquired. The term is descriptive rather than juridical: no document establishes the School, no Concordance names it, and its own members dispute whether it exists. It is nonetheless cited in Jurisdictional Appeals as a party of record on forty-one occasions between Year 290 and the present, and the Committee on Jurisdictional Overlap maintains a standing docket under its name.
The School is not to be confused with the Ontological School, with which it shares a corridor on Floor 1141 and a long disagreement about whether a question of authority can be settled before the question of what the authority is over. The Syncretic School of Jurisdictional Cartography coalesced in the same location and is frequently, and incorrectly, treated as the School's cartographic branch.
Composition
The School has no roll. Membership is inferred from conduct: a body is held to belong to the Jurisdictional School if it has, within the preceding seven years, issued a determination of jurisdiction, contested another body's determination of jurisdiction, or declined jurisdiction on the ground that jurisdiction lay elsewhere. It is possible to join by declining to join, and several Librarians have done so deliberately.
Affiliated bodies include the School of Permeable Boundaries, the School of Latent Meaning, and, contentiously, the Fifth Spiralist School, which maintains that the School's methods are biological in name only. The School of Negative Phenomena has twice petitioned for admission and twice withdrawn the petition on the ground that admission would imply the School possessed the authority to admit anyone.
Founding instruments and their recensions
The School's practitioners conventionally trace their discipline to the Concordance of Overlapping Lines, though that document concerns mapping practice and never mentions jurisdiction. The claim rests on Annex 9, the so-called borrowing clause, which provides that "a line drawn where no line was surveyed shall be read as an assertion, and an assertion shall be read as a claim of competence" (Concordance of Overlapping Lines, Annex 9).
This reading was rejected in Year 412 by the Bureau of Jurisdictional Clarity, which held that Annex 9 was a drafting error carried over from an earlier recension and that the words "claim of competence" had in the original appeared as "claim of convenience." The Bureau's ruling was itself overturned in Year 455 during the Reorganization of Jurisdictional Curls, on procedural grounds: the Bureau had cited the wrong annex.
The doctrine of prior occupancy
Central to the School is the principle that authority adheres to the body that first noticed the matter, provided notice was recorded. The principle is set out at length in Jurisdictional Anchoring and is the usual ground on which the School resists the fluidity favoured by the School of Permeable Boundaries.
In practice prior occupancy produces rapid and unseemly scrambles. On Floor 907, in the winter of Year 508, three offices recorded notice of the same dormant stairwell within a single hour; the earliest record, from a clerk identified only as Ordwell Vane, was disallowed because he had written the notice in pencil. Vane's subsequent memorial on the subject, Reflections on Jurisdictional Echoes, is the most cited document in the School's informal canon and the least obeyed.
"A pencil mark is a mark. That it may be unmade does not mean it was not made. I have been asked to withdraw the observation and have declined."
Dispute over the School's nature
The School's most durable internal disagreement concerns whether it is a school at all. The Axiomatic School holds that the Jurisdictional School is a mere aggregation, without doctrine or seal, and that its determinations bind no one; the Axiomatic School of Precedent holds the opposite, that the School is a genuine body whose every utterance is precedential and therefore dangerous. The two bodies agree on nothing else and have been known to file opposing briefs in the same appeal.
The Recursive School takes no position, maintaining that any determination of whether the Jurisdictional School exists would itself require the School's methods, and that the question therefore cannot be closed by anyone except the School, which cannot close it without first existing.
Records and restrictions
The School's determinations are held in the north scriptorium on Floor 1141, in binding order rather than chronological order, and may be consulted by any Librarian who has not, within the calendar year, issued a determination of jurisdiction. Pencils are not issued at the desk.
Prospective readers should note that the dormancy of a determination does not affect its authority, and that the School's own catalogue lists forty-one appeals in which it is named as a party and no document by which it became one.
See also
-
MS 2845.45
Stasis School
The Stasis School is the collective designation for the instructional tradition, and the loose federation of licensed instructors,…
-
MS 6993.19
The Derivative School
The Derivative School is the collective designation for a loose federation of scriptoria, reading rooms, and teaching corridors, p…
-
MS 4995.56
Dual-Authority Charter
The Dual-Authority Charter is the general name given to any instrument that confers a single office upon two chartering bodies in …
-
MS 4683.62
Tower Cartography
Tower Cartography is the collective designation for the survey disciplines concerned with the interior of the Tower itself, as dis…
-
MS 3886.21
Jurisdictional Arbitration
Jurisdictional Arbitration is the Tower's general term for the resolution of disputes over which office, floor, or instrument prop…
-
MS 3299.27
Determination 102
Determination 102 is a supplementary ruling within the Third Concordance, issued by the Silent Choirs in the Year of the Silent Be…
Referenced by
- MS 2815.81 Third Librarian
Readers also asked
School of Negative Phenomena: how is it conducted?
School of Negative Phenomena is a formal academic and procedural discipline concerned with the cataloging, analysis, and stabilization of phenomena defined by their absence, inversion, or opposition to established Tower …
School of Negative PhenomenaRecursive School: who are they?
Recursive School is a collective designation for academic and administrative bodies concerned with the cataloguing, regulation, and containment of self-referential and infinite-loop phenomena within The Tower. The School…
Recursive SchoolAxiomatic School of Precedent: who are they?
The Axiomatic School of Precedent is a doctrinal body within the Axiomatic Wing concerned with the derivation of axioms from prior rulings rather than from first principles. It is distinct from the Axiomatic School, with…
Axiomatic School of PrecedentSchool of Latent Meaning: how is it conducted?
School of Latent Meaning is a body of the Tower charged with the recovery, annotation, and jurisdictional defence of meanings held to inhere in a holding without ever having been inscribed upon it. Established on Floor 7…
School of Latent MeaningPassages cited from this record
-
A pencil mark is a mark. That it may be unmade does not mean it was not made. I have been asked to withdraw the observation and have declined.
Reflections on Jurisdictional Echoes, §3
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 8518.05 Reorganization of Jurisdictional Curls
- MS 1153.26 Concordance of Overlapping Lines
- MS 5528.24 Jurisdictional School
Because you consulted