The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Clinometer of Displacement

MS 9483.16 · Objects and instruments

The Clinometer of Displacement is a graduated brass inclinometer held in the instrument crypt beneath Annex Γ-12 and consulted, in principle, before any change of station of a catalogued object. It reads to eleven minutes of arc on a half-metre limb and bears the inscription NON MENSURA SED MENSURAE ERROR — not the measure, but the error of the measure — struck on the reverse of the plate during the second recension of the instrument's instructions, in the winter of 4,109. Unlike the Parallax Displacement Analysis, which results in a document, the Clinometer results only in an inclination, and it is this narrowness of output that has kept it in service for three centuries while other instruments have been retired.

Design and reading

The instrument consists of a brass limb, a spirit level of the sealed-tube pattern, and a weighted alidade that must be allowed to settle for no fewer than forty heartbeats before a reading is entered. The alidade is engraved with a single index mark, worn smooth by the thumbs of clerks and not replaceable, since the friction fit was made by an instrument-smith whose shop is no longer listed in any register. Readings are entered on the reverse of the Environmental Displacement Logging slip and not on the face, a rule introduced after the confusion of 4,246 and never repealed.

The Clinometer reports inclination, not distance. Distance is the business of the Office of Lateral Displacement. The distinction is not merely technical: the Office has twice attempted to absorb the Clinometer into its own instrument rolls, and twice been refused, on the ground that a body which administers the Ontological Displacement Check cannot also hold the device that measures whether a displacement was inclined, or the independence of the latter would be compromised.

Relation to Pattern Alpha

Pattern Alpha governs displacement, and it governs it, by the settled reading of the Ordinary Librarians, at degrees and not at intervals. This has made the Clinometer the instrument of record for Pattern Alpha disputes, notwithstanding that Pattern Alpha's text does not mention inclinometers, angles, or instruments of any kind. The Standing Commentary of 4,301 supplies the link by inference, observing that a pattern can only be said to govern a displacement if the displacement has a direction, and a direction not expressed in degrees is an opinion.

Where the inclination recorded on the Clinometer exceeds four degrees from the horizontal of the originating floor, the displacement is classed as inclined and requires re-registration. Where it falls below that threshold it is classed as level and requires none. The threshold itself is not written anywhere in the Clinometer's own instructions; it derives from Concordance 11, which was amended in 4,388 to remove the threshold from an annex and restore it to the body of the text without altering its value.

The dispute over the third recension

The Clinometer's instructions have been recensed three times, and the third recension is contested. The Concordance on Lateral Displacement admits no unwritten measures in the construction of the Ontological Displacement Check, and the Clinometer's third recension of 4,112 retains, in its preamble, a procedure for settling the alidade that appears in no earlier recension and is described there as customary. The Office of Lateral Displacement holds that a customary procedure is an unwritten measure and that readings taken under the third recension are therefore not admissible in any Check; the instrument crypt holds that a customary procedure, once written down, is a written measure, and that the word customary is a description and not an exemption.

"That which is written is written. The question is only whether what was written was a measure or a remark."

— Concordance on Lateral Displacement, Annex 9

The question has never been put to a plenary sitting. It has instead been left standing, and the crypt continues to certify readings under the third recension while the Office continues to accept them and note, in the margin of each acceptance, that acceptance is not endorsement. Clerk Ovida Marren of the crypt has requested a ruling four times since 4,401; her fourth request was returned with the words premature written across the seal and no other annotation.

Known deviations

Two deviations are recorded in the instrument's service history. The first, the Tilt of the Ninth Landing, describes a persistent two-degree reading obtained on a floor known to be level, traced to a lead weight in the north wall and not to the Clinometer, which was accordingly cleared. The second involves the restitution case Quill v. the Office of Lateral Displacement, in which the Office was found to have displaced an object without completing stage three of the Ontological Displacement Check. The Clinometer played no part in the displacement itself but was produced at hearing to demonstrate that the inclination recorded at the scene was consistent with the object having been moved and inconsistent with the account given by the Office.

Whether the Clinometer may be borrowed is settled: it may not leave the crypt, and may be examined in place by any Librarian who brings their own cloth. The cloth is not supplied.

Competing instruments

The Clinometer is not without rivals. Vertical Drift is sometimes cited as an alternative basis for inclined-displacement findings, and the Chronal Resonators in the east gallery have been proposed, twice, as a means of dating the inclination rather than merely measuring it. The Commission's Opinion 102, arising from the Granite Spire Incident, notes that no instrument in the Tower's holdings measures inclination and date together, and that the Clinometer's limitation is therefore not a defect but a boundary. The BureauĠofĠAnachronisticĠCataloguing has since requested the instrument for a single afternoon in connection with a matter of Directed Anachronism; the request was refused, and the refusal was entered in the crypt's ledger as a refusal, with the hour it was made and the name of the clerk who carried it back.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

BureauĠofĠAnachronisticĠCataloguing: who are they?

Bureau of Anachronistic Cataloguing is the specialized administrative unit charged with the acquisition, classification, and shelving of subjects that exhibit temporal displacement or contradiction, and with the standard…

BureauĠofĠAnachronisticĠCataloguing
Vertical Drift: how is it conducted?

Vertical Drift is the general term under which the Tower's several drift disciplines are collected, denoting any displacement of a catalogued object, chamber, or person from its assigned vertical position where the displ…

Vertical Drift
Ontological Displacement Check: how is it conducted?

The Ontological Displacement Check is a five-stage verification instrument used to confirm that a conceptual object has left the category under which it was filed and has not returned to it. It is administered chiefly by…

Ontological Displacement Check
Pattern Alpha: how is it conducted?

Pattern Alpha is the designation assigned to the earliest of the three officially recognized harmonics catalogued by the Office of the Commissioner for Harmonic Integrity, preceding Pattern Beta and Pattern Theta in the …

Pattern Alpha

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.