The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Bureau of Half-Heard Citations

MS 5998.73 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Bureau of Half-Heard Citations is the office of the Tower charged with the receipt, transcription, and provisional validation of citations that were never fully spoken. It occupies two adjoining rooms on Floor 1120, the Anteroom of the Unfinished Utterance, and reports jointly to the Bureau of Concordant Citation and, in matters of tone, to the Repository of Half Heard Melodies, with which it is frequently and incorrectly confused.

The distinction is one of medium. The Repository at Floor 441 holds melodies abandoned mid-phrase; the Bureau holds citations abandoned mid-clause — the authority for a claim, begun and not finished. A melody stops because the singer stopped. A citation stops because the citing party was interrupted, lost their nerve, died, or was escorted from the reading room, and the four cases are recorded differently.

Procedure and the Half-Slot

The Bureau maintains a ranked series of what it calls half-slots: a half-slot being the portion of a citation audibly rendered before cessation. A half-slot of Class I comprises at least the floor number and the first syllable of the cited document's title. A half-slot of Class IV comprises no more than an intake of breath and a surname, and Class V is a silence of demonstrable duration, which must be attested by two clerks and is not accepted before the noon bell.

Once recorded, a half-slot is entered provisionally under Provisional Concordance Citations and forwarded to the Bureau of Registry, which performs the Crossreferential Stability Check on it before the Department of Contradictory Citations ratifies its final shelving. Where a half-slot cannot be matched to any extant instrument, it is retained as an orphan fragment and shelved facing inward, so that it cannot be cited by accident.

History: the Winter of the Broken Clause

The Bureau was constituted by Concordance Sigma-4 in the wake of the Dissolution of the Bureau of Unclaimed Citations, which had absorbed all unfinished citations into a single undifferentiated heap and, by common account, made them worse. The first intake, in the winter of that year, was a stack of forty-one deposition slips recovered from a collapsed witness stand on Floor 803. Thirty-eight proved unreadable. Two attributed a claim to "the usual arrangement," which the Bureau ruled was not a citation but a habit. The forty-first named a document by its last three syllables only; the Bureau has never found the document and keeps the slip in a frame.

Dispute with the Bureau of Rectified Citations

Relations with the Bureau of Rectified Citations have been strained since the latter claimed competence over half-heard citations that had subsequently been completed by the citing party before the hour of record. The Bureau of Half-Heard Citations maintains that a citation completed in the same hour falls within its own purview, the record not yet being closed. The Bureau of Rectified Citations maintains the opposite, and has twice declined to refer the matter onward.

"A thing half heard and then wholly heard is not a half thing. It is a whole thing that was briefly late."

— Memorial of the Bureau of Rectified Citations, Annex 2

The Bureau's answering memorial is shorter and, by the reckoning of most readers, colder: that lateness is a property of the citation and not of the hearing, and that a document cited at the ninth bell is not the document cited at the eighth. No Concordance resolves the point. The Bureau of Precedential Analysis has certified the disagreement as ongoing, which permits both offices to continue billing the same hours.

Objections and the Fraying Question

The most persistent objection to the Bureau's work is that partially spoken citations, once entered in the register, begin to be cited in their incomplete form by readers who do not know they are incomplete. By the Principle of Non-Propagation such a citation ought not to travel; in practice it travels readily, and the phrase "as was nearly said in the matter of —" has been found in briefs from Floors 300 to 1500. The Bureau of Implementable Abstraction has twice intervened where the resulting confusion was observed to cause localized reality fraying near the stairwells, and the Bureau of Ontic Weights has accepted the Bureau's position that a half-citation weighs nothing until completed but occupies the same shelf space regardless.

A minority opinion, associated with the surveyor Clerk Amaranth Voss and recorded in the Second Survey of the Anteroom, holds that half-heard citations are not incomplete at all but belong to a distinct and complete class, and that the Bureau's error lies in measuring them against full citations rather than against each other. Voss's survey was commissioned in the spring, submitted in the autumn, and is still being read.

Holdings

The Bureau's open register, closed to public inspection since the revision of Directorial Decree 447-Alpha, currently lists the following classes of holding:

  • Half-slots of Classes I through IV: 11,406
  • Attested silences (Class V): 212, of which 19 are disputed
  • Orphan fragments shelved inward: 3,088
  • Slips retained for sentiment only, uncitable: 1

The last entry is the framed slip from Floor 803. The Bureau has ruled, twice and without discussion, that it is not a holding, and it is counted here only because the register counts it.

Access

The reading room is open on the second and fourth days. Visitors are asked to complete any citation they begin, and to leave the door ajar on exit, since the latch was heard only once and has not been reliably described since.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Bureau of Implementable Abstraction: who are they?

The Bureau of Implementable Abstraction is a sub-directorate of the Department of Applied Metaphysics tasked with translating non-physical constructs, as catalogued within the Tower's archives, into forms suitable for ph…

Bureau of Implementable Abstraction
Floor 441 the Repository of Half Heard Melodies: where is it?

Floor 441: The Repository of Half Heard Melodies is a primary custodial level within the 400-series harmonic quadrant, officially designated for the physical instantiation of auditory phenomena that were perceived but no…

Floor 441 the Repository of Half Heard Melodies
Directorial Decree 447-Alpha: what does it set out?

Directorial Decree 447-Alpha is a single-sheet instrument of the Directorate, sealed on 11 Vellum 4,412 and entered in the Register of Directorial Acts under the marginal notation "urgent; retrospective where necessary."…

Directorial Decree 447-Alpha
Bureau of Concordant Citation: who are they?

Bureau of Concordant Citation (B.C.C.) is the administrative body responsible for the procedural governance of all formal Citation activity within the Tower, operating as a subsidiary bureau of the Third Concordant Court…

Bureau of Concordant Citation

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.