Taxon 147-b
MS 4624.46 · Practices and doctrines
Taxon 147-b is a restricted classification maintained by the Committee for Ontological Review for materials that have been observed, measured, and entered into the register, but which no inspector has been able to approach closely enough to describe. It is not a category of things so much as a category of near-misses. The taxon was created in the winter of 3412 by administrative accident and has been defended ever since with a vigour out of all proportion to its usefulness.
Origin
The designation arose during the resurvey of the eastern support lattice, when a junior recorder on the Lignum Inspector's staff logged a length of timber under the Lignum Vitae Tower Taxon and then, on a second pass, could not find it again. The record was already sealed. Rather than annul a sealed record — a proceeding requiring three Librarians and a public reading — the recorder's supervisor opened a new heading, 147-b, and entered the specimen there as "present at first inspection; absent at second; timber not disputed."
The Panel of Ontological Differentiation reviewed the heading in 3413 and declined to dissolve it, on the grounds that dissolving a taxon implies a judgement about what was in it, and no such judgement could be formed. The Panel's ruling, recorded in its minutes for the ninth session, reads in full: "The heading stands. We do not know what stands in it."
Scope and procedure
Taxon 147-b is defined by a negative condition. A candidate qualifies if it has generated at least two independent records that agree on its location and disagree on its extent, or if it has been entered in a floor inventory and subsequently struck from that inventory by an officer who could not say what they were striking. The Charter of Inquiry permits such entries under Article 12, which allows the register to hold a place open for a subject indefinitely.
In practice 147-b functions as a holding pen for the Tower's unfinished business. Its current register runs to eleven folios and includes a stairwell landing on Floor 908 whose width is given as both nine feet and "the usual," a door on the Spiral Annex that appears on four floor plans and none of the elevations, and a quantity of shelving reported by two separate expeditions to the Department of Sustenance and Illumination and confirmed by neither.
Entry to the taxon is by submission to the Committee, which meets on the fourth Thursday of months containing an r in the Latin name of the month as rendered in the Tower's calendar. Submissions may be made in person or by leaving them at the Committee's door; the door is not locked, but the Committee does not answer it during session.
The Ninetieth Recension dispute
Taxon 147-b's status was contested in 3419, when the Sixth Concordance was recensed and the new text appeared to place all indeterminate holdings under the head of Documentary Loops. The Committee objected that a Documentary Loop is a document that refers to itself, whereas a 147-b specimen is a thing that refers to nothing. The Scriptorium of Jurisprudential Inquiry was asked to arbitrate and produced the finding that the two categories overlap without either containing the other, a conclusion it described as "stable."
"A loop closes on itself and is thereby complete. A 147-b entry does not close. It is not incomplete either, which is the difficulty."
— Scriptorium of Jurisprudential Inquiry, Advisory Note 44, appended to the Ninetieth Recension
The matter was not settled so much as set aside. The Committee continues to hold 147-b; the Sixth Concordance continues to describe it, in Annex 9, as a sub-heading of Documentary Loops; and both documents are cited in the same breath by clerks who have learned not to look too closely at the seam.
The Vellum Annex incident
The taxon's most cited failure occurred on Floor 212 in the winter of 3427. A survey party under Recorder Halvern Ache entered the Vellum Annex to confirm a 147-b specimen described in the register as "a stack of uncut vellum, height uncertain, present." The party found the annex empty and swept clean. They recorded the absence, sealed the record, and withdrew.
Six weeks later a second party, sent to verify the absence, found the stack in place, uncut, and — by their measurement — four feet six inches high. The register now holds both records, each sealed, each countersigned, and the folio is annotated in the Recorder's hand: "Both entries are correct. Do not adjust."
Recorder Ache petitioned for the specimen's removal to a determinate taxon and was refused. His petition, and the Committee's refusal, are preserved together in the same binding; the refusal occupies the verso of every leaf on which the petition appears.
Relation to the taxonomic anchors
Because 147-b specimens cannot serve as taxonomic anchors, the Committee has ruled that a 147-b entry may not be used to stabilise any neighbouring taxon, however convenient the fit. This ruling followed an attempt by the 22.J Atelier to anchor its provisional furniture classifications to a 147-b chair, which had been sighted on three floors and measured on none. The attempt was voided under Charter 719-S, and the chair remains where it was, or where it was reported.
The Committee for Ontological Review has twice proposed abolishing 147-b and twice withdrawn the proposal before reading it aloud. The current register is open. The Committee's door is not locked. No submission has been acknowledged since 3431.
See also
-
MS 8085.56
Restricted Manuscripts Collection
The Restricted Manuscripts Collection (officially Holding Series Ψ-Δ) is a designation covering all non-acoustic textual materials…
-
MS 5799.49
Restricted Materials Annex
The Restricted Materials Annex is the suite of chambers, dark rooms, and shielded shelves on floor 88-Kappa in which every materia…
-
MS 5608.27
Chief Scriptorial Inspector
Chief Scriptorial Inspector is the senior administrative office charged with the physical and ontological verification of all scri…
-
MS 1113.24
Edict of Restricted Substances
Edict of Restricted Substances is the collective designation for the standing decree issued by the Librarians in the year 3882 of …
-
MS 5444.25
Interim Committee for Resonance Management
The Interim Committee for Resonance Management (ICRM) is a standing administrative body within the Interim Stacks responsible for …
- MS 4942.55 Clause 7 Inspector
Referenced by
- MS 2883.53 Charter of Inquiry
- MS 0878.26 Sixth Scriptorium
Readers also asked
22.J Atelier: how is it conducted?
The 22.J Atelier is a formally recognized Verification Atelier occupying the landing of the Western Helical Staircase at its twenty-second turn, designated 22.J under the Registry of Landings, Turns, and Interstitial Spa…
22.J AtelierCharter 719-S: what does it set out?
Charter 719-S is a short enabling instrument of the Concordance cycle, ratified on 3 Nivôse 534 and consisting of a preamble, four clauses, and an appended schedule of eleven named apertures. Its operative provision is n…
Charter 719-SCharter of Inquiry: what does it set out?
The Charter of Inquiry is the foundational document that codifies the procedures, rights, and jurisdictional scope for all formal investigations convened under the authority of the Scriptorium of Jurisprudential Inquiry.…
Charter of InquiryPanel of Ontological Differentiation: who are they?
The Panel of Ontological Differentiation is a standing adjudicatory body mandated by the Twenty-Seventh Concordance (Clause 44.b, "On the Separation of Being") to rule on petitions for the establishment of distinct ontol…
Panel of Ontological DifferentiationPassages cited from this record
-
A loop closes on itself and is thereby complete. A 147-b entry does not close. It is not incomplete either, which is the difficulty.
Scriptorium of Jurisprudential Inquiry, Advisory Note 44, appended to the Ninetieth Recension
Because you consulted