The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Synodal Order 23.γ.4

MS 4252.37 · Documents and ordinances

Synodal Order 23.γ.4 is a binding instrument issued by the Office of the Twenty-Third Spire in the third quire of cycle 23 of the 4418th fiscal year, mandating the operational separation of the three Wren identities. It runs to eleven leaves and is chiefly remembered less for its substance, which the Spire had sought in one form or another since the Seventeenth Synodal Order, than for its closing annex, in which the issuing office concedes in writing that the arrangement it establishes is administratively inefficient. It is the only order in the 23-series to be cited by its own annex in subsequent proceedings.

Background

By the close of cycle 22 the three Wren identities had, through a series of small and individually defensible accommodations, come to share a single writing desk on the 4,109th floor, a single courier, and a single seal. The Order of Scribes held that this constituted a collapse of three offices into one and referred the matter upward. The referral was heard before the Librarian of the Fourth Order in the winter of that year; the minutes record that the Librarian asked the parties how many Wrens were presently at the desk, received three answers, and observed that this was itself the problem.

Drafting fell to Clerk-Adjutant Sablemen of the Spire, who produced four recensions between the first thaw and the third. Recensions A and B were rejected on the ground that they separated the Wrens by duty while leaving them in the same room. Recension C separated them by room but not by stairwell, which the Fifth Order Librarian noted would merely relocate the difficulty. Recension D is the text as promulgated.

Provisions

The operative clauses are four. Clause 1 assigns each Wren identity a distinct floor, a distinct seal, and a distinct hour of correspondence. Clause 2 prohibits any identity from initialling a document on behalf of another, "notwithstanding convenience, long practice, or the plain sense of the matter" (23.γ.4, cl. 2). Clause 3 requires that all three sets of papers be kept in separate rooms whose doors are not within sight of one another. Clause 4 gives the Wrens until the close of the fiscal year to comply, a deadline extended twice and met on neither occasion.

Annex I, the passage for which the order is known, reads in full:

"The Office acknowledges that the operational separation herein mandated is administratively inefficient, that it will require the duplication of couriers, seals, and stationery, and that it was the practice of some years to avoid precisely this. The Office has weighed the inefficiency against the alternative and prefers the inefficiency."

— Synodal Order 23.γ.4, Annex I

Reception and dispute

A dispute arose at once as to what the order had actually separated. The Order of Syntacticians, citing the resolution of the Synodal Order of 741 on the subjunctive, argued that the three Wrens were one person under three descriptions, and that the order therefore separated nothing and merely relocated a person three times. The Order of Amanuenses replied that a person is wherever their hand is, and that three hands writing in three rooms are three persons for every purpose the Tower recognises.

The question was put to the Librarian of the Third Order in the following spring. That Librarian, who had by then read 23.γ.4 four times, ruled that the order was "binding as to the rooms and silent as to the metaphysics" and declined to go further. The ruling is quoted in nearly every subsequent filing on the matter, usually for the second half of the phrase.

Under Synodal Order 712. the order's jurisdiction is confined to the Guilds and Orders Tower, a limit the Spire has never tested. A separate line of objection, pressed by the Order of the Latent Page, holds that an order admitting its own inefficiency forfeits the presumption of regularity that Synodal Orders otherwise enjoy; this view has been rejected twice and is expected to be pressed again.

Effects

Compliance remains partial. Two of the three Wren identities now occupy their assigned floors; the third has not moved, on the ground that its assigned floor is the one with the broken lift, and no order compels a Wren to climb. The three seals were cut and are held in a single drawer, since the clause requiring separate rooms makes no mention of drawers and the Spire has been reluctant to legislate by implication. The courier duplication proceeded without incident and is generally accounted the order's one unambiguous success.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Guilds and Orders Tower: who are they?

The Guilds and Orders Tower, officially designated Archive Complex M-72 "The Pillar of Recognition," is a subsidiary administrative spire dedicated to the registration, arbitration, and archival certification of all form…

Guilds and Orders Tower
Hush Order: who are they?

The Hush Order is a sub-order of the Fourth Order charged with the regulation, curing, and issance of silence as a measurable material. It is smaller than its name suggests: at the last count recorded in the Register of …

Hush Order
Synodal Order: what does it set out?

Synodal Orders are a class of administrative edict issued by the Order of Scribes, specifically through the Office of the Twenty-Third Spire. They are the primary instrument for establishing procedural rules, authorizing…

Synodal Order
Librarian of the Third Order: how is it conducted?

The Librarian of the Third Order is a certified supervisory rank within the Librarian Order, situated between the Junior Librarian and the Librarian of the Fourth Order. Attainment of the Third Order represents a critica…

Librarian of the Third Order

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.