The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Stage 1 (Imprint)

MS 6879.44 · Practices and doctrines

Stage 1 (Imprint) is the initial stage of the six-stage sequence governing the certification of imprints, and the only one of the six whose definition has never been amended. It designates the moment at which a persisting alteration is first assented to as an imprint — that is, recognised by a certifying officer as deliberate, attributable, and durable. Prior to Stage 1, an alteration is merely a mark. Stage 1 is the act that makes it admissible at all.

The sequence is administered from the Fourth Scriptorium under Standard Certification, and proceeds from Stage 1 (Imprint) through Stage Two: Buffering and Stage Three: Integration before terminating in the Certification Imprint proper. Stage 1 is not a processing stage. Nothing is done to the object. It is the stage at which the officer satisfies themselves that something was done to it by someone else, and writes down why they think so.

Definition and the doctrine of prior act

Stage 1 is defined in Annex C, clause 1.1, as the "first formal recognition of a persisting alteration as the residue of a deliberate act." The wording is narrower than it appears. An alteration may be persisting, evident, and universally agreed upon, and still fail Stage 1 if no deliberate act can be assigned to it. Conversely, the deliberate act need not be identified; it need only be assignable in principle. The distinction is recorded as the Difference of the Unattributed Hand, established in 1147 by ruling of the Concordance of Hands and reaffirmed by every subsequent recension.

This places Stage 1 in tension with the Third Concordance, which holds that every true imprint refers to an event prior to itself. Stage 1, on the Third Concordance's reading, cannot be constitutive, since the reference already exists before any officer arrives to notice it. The Fifth Concordance answers — at Annex 19, in a passage the Fourth Scriptorium has circulated without commentary — that Stage 1 "does not create the reference but consents to it, and consent is not a small thing." The two positions have not been reconciled. They are not expected to be.

"Let the officer record not what was made but that a making occurred, and let that record stand until contradicted, which it will be."

— Annex C, clause 1.4, Standard Certification

Procedure

A Stage 1 determination is entered on the lozenge sheet on the day of inspection and countersigned within the fortnight. It requires three particulars: the surface, the persistency class (Alpha through Delta), and a statement of assignability. The officer may decline to name the agent. The officer may not decline to state a reason for declining.

The most common failure is the persistency class. A mark that survives one lamp-burn but not two is Class Beta and fails Stage 1 as insufficiently durable; a mark that survives the second and the third is Class Alpha and may proceed. Marks in the disputed Class Gamma — surviving two burns and failing the third — are held in a separate tray in the Fourth Scriptorium and have been since the Gamma Freeze of 1388. There are, at last audit, eleven thousand and six of them. No one has proposed a way to release the tray that does not require deciding what Gamma means, and the question has been tabled at every session of the Assembly of Certifying Officers for a hundred and forty years.

In practice an inspector begins at the room's threshold and works inward, because a Stage 1 finding taken at the doorway cannot be overturned by a Stage 1 finding taken later in the same room. This rule was introduced after the Meridian Incident and is the only procedural rule in Annex C that is not written down in Annex C. It is written on the inside of the scriptorium door.

The Meridian Incident

In the winter of 1603 a clerk of the Fourth Scriptorium, Oreth Vance, certified the same corridor twice: once at Stage 1 in the morning, having found a scuff on the third flagstone, and once at Stage 1 in the afternoon, having found the scuff again after it was swept and re-made by the porter. The double certification produced two imprints of the same object, each with a prior act, each valid, and neither referring to the other. The reconciliation hearing ran to four hundred pages and concluded that Vance had "acted correctly at both hours and improperly in the interval."

Vance did not dispute the finding. Their grievance, filed the following spring and still open, is that the interval was nine hours long and no rule at the time specified which hour governed. The Office of Intervals was created in response. It has issued one ruling in three centuries.

Relation to later stages

Stage 1 findings are provisional by design. Nothing at Stage 1 binds Stage Two: Buffering, where echoic residue is segregated, and a Stage 1 determination that is not carried forward into Stage One: Containment simply lapses after ninety days without entry in the retention register. Lapsed determinations are retained physically but are not imprints for the purposes of the Causal Imprint family, a distinction that has caused persistent confusion among visiting examiners from the Lower Reading Rooms, who frequently arrive expecting the reverse.

Nor does Stage 1 govern the terminal marks. The Imprint of the Closed Fist is applied at a different stage entirely, on Lamentation Paper (Grade Delta), and no Stage 1 finding is required for it; the Imprint 712-Omega likewise attaches at the close of procedure rather than at its opening. The Codicils of the Eternal Imprint address this asymmetry in Codicil 6, conceding only that the sequence "begins somewhere, and this has been found convenient."

Records

The Stage 1 register is held in folio, by floor, on the open shelves of the Fourth Scriptorium; floors with no registered imprints stand empty by convention rather than by rule. The register is not indexed by name, and the fourth shelf of the south wall has been missing since at least 1412, when its absence was itself entered at Stage 1.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Certification Imprint: how is it conducted?

The Certification Imprint is the terminal imprint applied to a document at the conclusion of any certification procedure conducted under Standard Certification. It differs from the substantive imprints that a certificati…

Certification Imprint
Imprint of the Closed Fist: how is it conducted?

The Imprint of the Closed Fist is a formalized act of document closure, distinct from and procedurally antecedent to the application of the authoritative seal of the same name. It refers to the physical impression left b…

Imprint of the Closed Fist
Codicils of the Eternal Imprint: what does it set out?

The Codicils of the Eternal Imprint are a body of nine codicils, three of them superseded, governing the registration and custody of marks held to persist beyond the ordinary term of an object's substance. They are admin…

Codicils of the Eternal Imprint
Stage One: Containment: how is it conducted?

Stage One: Containment is the first of the four mandated stages of the Ω Protocol, preceding Stage Two: Examination, Stage Three: Integration, and the terminal stage of Binding Absence. It governs the initial reception, …

Stage One: Containment

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.