Specificity Drift
MS 3365.04 · Practices and doctrines
Specificity Drift is the gradual alteration of a document's defined parameters when that document is moved during periods of high definitional traffic. The term was fixed in its present sense by the Panel of Specificity in Epoch 404 and has since displaced an older usage, current in the scriptoria of the Lower Nucleus, in which the same phrase described the tendency of a copied text to grow more exact in the hands of each successive scribe. The two usages are distinguished in the record only by the presence of the article: the modern phenomenon is always the Specificity Drift, whereas the scribal usage carries no article and no longer appears in indexed holdings.
Specificity Drift is to be distinguished from the several other drifts catalogued in the Tower — Designation Drift, Referent Drift, Nominative Drift, Semantic Drift and Doctrinal Drift — none of which concern the movement of documents as such. It is also distinguished from Temporal Specificity, which governs permissible formats for expressing time and is not altered by movement. A document may drift in its temporal parameters, but the drift is Specificity Drift; the temporal regime merely determines what has been lost.
Mechanism
The Panel's ruling of Epoch 404 established that specificity attaches to the designation and not to the designating object. This had the consequence — unforeseen by the panel, and disputed by Lys of the Gamma-Spiral for the better part of a decade — that a document's parameters are held not in the document but in the traffic around it. Where traffic is heavy, the parameters are said to lend: the designation borrows resolution from its neighbours and returns with a slightly different outline than the one it carried out of the press.
The standard measure is Conceptual Mass, expressed in vonett-units and read against the Vonett Scale for Specificity. A document that has moved through a busy corridor during a high-traffic interval of forty minutes or more will typically show a Conceptual Mass within 0.04 of its origin reading; the drift is therefore invisible in any single instance and reliable only in aggregate. Clerks are instructed not to attempt a reading after every transit. Readings taken more than twice a day are treated as noise and are filed unread, a practice that has been a standing grievance of the Office of Repeated Measurement since its founding.
The Sallow Flight of Epoch 431
The phenomenon's most cited illustration remains the transit now known as the Sallow Flight. In the winter of Epoch 431 a consignment of seventy-one documents was carried from the Eleventh Annex of the Ninth Concordance to the Upper Reading Gallery during an interval in which three separate hearings of the Panel of Specificity were in session. On arrival, the consignment's transit certificate was found to describe its contents as "the documents named herein, or such of them as remain after the reading."
The phrase appears in no recension of the certificate before Epoch 431 and has not appeared in one since. The master of the consignment, Clerk Anselm Vey, maintained to his death that the wording was original and that his own copy had simply drifted toward clarity in the keeping of the registry. The Registry of Transit Certificates has declined to rule on this point four times, noting only that "the certificate is what it is, and its bearer is no longer in a position to dispute it" — Registry of Transit Certificates, Marginalia to the Ninth Register.
"A document does not change when it is read. It changes when it is carried, and it is read afterwards by someone who believes the carrying to be complete."
— Ordinance of Specificity, Epoch 419, Amendment 7, preamble
Relation to Specificity Analysis
Specificity Analysis is performed when a subject's signature cannot be matched against the Diagnostic Catalogue, and drift is the most frequent cause of such a failure. The analyst must decide whether the discrepancy originates in the document, in the corridor, or in the catalogue itself; the Corollary of Physical Specificity, which has been dispositive at the Panel since Epoch 412, directs the inquiry to the material history of the carried item rather than to the intent of its drafter. Taxonomic Specificity is consulted where the drifted parameter concerns the binding of a single taxon rather than a class of taxa, and is not otherwise relevant.
Specificity Analysis is distinct from Reciprocal Pathway Analysis, which concerns the content indexed at either end of a pathway and takes no account of transit. Documents that have drifted in the course of being moved between Apertures Alpha and Sigma are frequently submitted to both, with results that are reconciled by the Bureau of Reconciled Findings on a schedule of its own choosing.
Contested readings
The Fifteenth Concordance holds that drift is a defect in the record, to be corrected on discovery and annotated in red. The Twenty-Second Concordance, ratified some eleven years later and apparently without reference to its predecessor, holds that drift is itself a record and must not be corrected. Both positions are cited in the working notes of every scriptorium on the Tower's middle floors, often on opposing pages. Where a document has drifted in one direction and a correction has drifted in the other, the archive maintains both, shelved together and bound in the same board, in the belief — nowhere formally stated — that the two will eventually arrest each other.
A minority report prepared for the Panel of Specificity in Epoch 436 proposed that drift be prevented outright by sealing documents before transit. The proposal was defeated, on the ground that sealed documents cannot be verified during transit and are therefore more dangerous than drifted ones. Documents sealed for other reasons are permitted, provided the seal is not attested as preventing drift. Retroactive Drift Assessment is available for documents already moved, though the assessment cannot restore a parameter that has lent; it can only record what the parameter lent to.
Management
Transit corridors are scheduled against the standing sessions of the Panel, and high-traffic intervals are posted each morning at the head of every stair. Documents of the first rank are carried by the centre of the corridor, in the belief that drift accrues at the walls. Where the traffic cannot be reduced — as at the junction of the Ninth and Fourteenth Galleries, which has no alternate route — the document is carried by a clerk walking at a speed of no more than forty paces per minute, and is not set down. Setting a document down during a high-traffic interval will void a transit certificate. Clerk Vey's certificate was, by his own account, never set down. It is not known where he was standing.
See also
-
MS 4624.09
Definitional Recursions
Definitional Recursions are catalogued phenomena in which the act of defining a subject within the Tower alters the subject's defi…
-
MS 8355.97
Definitional Anomalies
Definitional Anomalies are atmospheric and taxonomic disturbances within the Tower in which a subject's established parameters are…
-
MS 2308.35
Metric Drift Theory
Metric Drift Theory is the body of formal doctrine concerning the gradual, measurable departure of a catalogued subject's defining…
-
MS 3613.34
The Axiom of Inevitable Manifestation
The Axiom of Inevitable Manifestation is a foundational principle within the archival theory of emergent realities, stating that a…
-
MS 8745.38
Axiom of Inevitable Manifestation
The Axiom of Inevitable Manifestation is the foundational principle of the Tower's cataloguing doctrine, holding that any concept …
-
MS 2068.51
Lambda Coefficient
The Lambda Coefficient (denoted λ) is the standard metric for quantifying Temporal Specificity within the Tower’s archival systems…
Referenced by
- MS 1306.21 Pre-Dawn Evacuation
- MS 4624.09 Definitional Recursions
- MS 8355.97 Definitional Anomalies
Readers also asked
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …
Ninth ConcordanceSpecificity Analysis: how is it conducted?
Specificity Analysis is the branch of Precedential Analysis concerned with determining how narrowly a directive, ordinance, or declaration binds the circumstances to which it applies. Where Substance Analysis asks what a…
Specificity AnalysisReciprocal Pathway Analysis: how is it conducted?
Reciprocal Pathway Analysis is the formal examination of paired pathways conducted under the procedural standards of Reciprocal Documentation at the Office of Reciprocal Citation, and the term in longest continuous admin…
Reciprocal Pathway AnalysisCorollary of Physical Specificity: how is it conducted?
The Corollary of Physical Specificity is a practice of Specificity Analysis holding that any variance in the material properties of a physical document — weight, fibre, watermark, ink lot, trim, smell, or the resistance …
Corollary of Physical SpecificityPassages cited from this record
-
A document does not change when it is read. It changes when it is carried, and it is read afterwards by someone who believes the carrying to be complete.
Ordinance of Specificity, Epoch 419, Amendment 7, preamble
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7751.26 Registry of Transit Certificates
- MS 9148.82 Bureau of Reconciled Findings
- MS 6945.32 Ordinance of Specificity
- MS 3089.45 Office of Repeated Measurement
Because you consulted