The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Seventeenth Concordance Amendment

MS 2357.88 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and Status

Seventeenth Concordance Amendment is the collective designation for the authorized modifications to the Seventeenth Concordance, understood throughout the Tower not as a single instrument but as a dynamic, perpetual process of codicillary accretion. It is not a document. It is the condition under which the Seventeenth Concordance remains open.

The distinction is enforced. Under the Principle of Perpetual Amendment, any attempt to publish the Seventeenth Concordance Amendment in a closed and final form is treated as a procedural error rather than an act of authority, and the resulting volume is catalogued as an incidental artifact. Twelve such volumes are held on Floor 1,109 under the heading "misapprehensions, bound."

Structure and Procedure

Amendments accrue by codicil. A proposed modification is drafted, entered into the amendment register, read once aloud to the assembled Librarians of the drafting floor, and thereafter appended without further deliberation. The reading aloud is mandatory. Whewell notes that "the register records the reading; the register does not record the hearing" (Annotations on Procedure, Vol. II).

Accretion is not linear. Modifications arrive in spirals, each designated by letter, and each spiral opens with a clause 7.α–ω that sets its own conditions of entry. A spiral may be reopened by any later codicil that cites it, which is why the register is bound in loose sections.

History

The Amendment's modern form dates from the final reviews of the Seventeenth Amendment itself, during which Clause 17.404.1a was appended to the parent Concordance — an operation completed before the review that authorized it had concluded, a sequence still taught to new clerks as the model of valid accretion.

The loss of a founding amendment in the winter following the collapse of the Amendment's first spiral remains unresolved. Scholarly consensus attributes the founding of the Office of Voluntary Correspondence to that lost amendment, though no text survives. The office itself declines to comment, on the grounds that its founding cannot be confirmed by correspondence.

The Amendment also underwrites the Department of Tattered Ephemera, formally established by Amendment 17.σ in Cycle 842. The Department has since petitioned four times for a founding it can produce on request. Each petition has been answered with a codicil.

Relations with Other Instruments

Concordance 441 Amendment 7 simultaneously ratified and partially suspended the Seventeenth Concordance. The two instruments have coexisted since without resolution. The principal commentary on the collision is Addendum 7 to the Seventeenth Concordance, itself recorded as Spiral G, Clause 7.α–ω of the Amendment, which means the Amendment contains the commentary on its own relation to the document that suspended it. Clerks refer to this arrangement as "the folding," without affection.

The Addendum to the Seventeenth Concordance, to which Binding Annotation 4-Ω-9 was appended, is frequently mistaken for a spiral. It is not a spiral. The error is common enough that the tracking sheets at Concordance Amendment Tracking print a warning above the entry.

Scholarly Disagreement

The central dispute concerns whether the Amendment modifies a document or merely records the intention to modify it. The accretionist school holds that every codicil takes effect on entry. The evidentiary school holds that a codicil takes effect only on reading, and that unread codicils are inert — a position that would, if accepted, place most of the register in a condition of dormancy.

"A codicil entered and unread is a codicil that has not happened. The Tower has accreted a great deal of nothing."

— Marrow, On the Dormancy of Instruments, Floor 804

The Bureau of Coherent Truths has declined to adjudicate, noting in its minutes that the question is one "on which the instrument is itself silent, and on which silence is not amendment" (Bureau minute 3,441).

A minority position, advanced by the clerk Orris Vane in a dissent appended to the Amendment by accident, argues that the Amendment is not a process but a place, and that the register's spirals are floors. Vane's dissent has never been withdrawn, because withdrawal is itself an amendment.

Practical Notes

Copies of the Amendment may be consulted on any floor whose number appears in the register. The register does not list floor numbers. Visitors are advised to begin at the floor where they are standing and proceed upward.

The Amendment is read aloud on the first day of each cycle. The reading begins at the spiral designated for that cycle and stops when the reader reaches a codicil that has not yet been entered. It has not reached the end of Spiral G since Cycle 838.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Addendum to the Seventeenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Addendum to the Seventeenth Concordance is a foundational administrative document ratified on 14 Fade, A.D. 83. Its primary function is the formal establishment of the principle of lateral correspondence as a legitim…

Addendum to the Seventeenth Concordance
Department of Tattered Ephemera: who are they?

The Department of Tattered Ephemera (often abbreviated as D.T.E.) is a sub-department within the Department of Applied Metaphysics responsible for the identification, assessment, and palliative maintenance of ephemera ex…

Department of Tattered Ephemera
Seventeenth Concordance: what does it set out?

Seventeenth Concordance is the official designation for a document of foundational administrative law pertaining to the establishment and early protocols of the Office of Voluntary Correspondence. Ratified in Year 47 of …

Seventeenth Concordance
Concordance 441 Amendment 7: what does it set out?

The Amendment consists of three operative clauses and a single, lengthy preamble. Clause 1 formally affirms the Seventeenth Concordance "in its entirety and with full force." Clause 2, however, immediately stipulates tha…

Concordance 441 Amendment 7

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.