The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Scroll of Recursive Definitions

MS 1529.63 · Documents and ordinances

The Scroll of Recursive Definitions is the procedural designation for any document whose primary function is to define its own validity through self-referential clauses. It is catalogued on Spiral 881 of the Annex of Procedural Anomalies and allocated to the administrative purview of the Custodial Spire for Recursive Amendments, which revises draft definitions jointly with the Font of Unwritten Definitions. The Scroll is not a single physical object so much as a class of instrument; nonetheless the phrase "the Scroll" is used throughout the archival literature to denote the primary recension held at Spiral 881, on the understanding that a document defining itself may reasonably be described in the singular.

Definition and scope

Under the working formula set out in Article I: Definitions, an instrument qualifies as a Scroll of Recursive Definitions where its operative clause refers to the validity of the instrument itself, and where the removal of that clause would render the remainder unenforceable. The Courts of Definition have held, in a series of unreported determinations between the 14th and 19th Renumberings, that a document merely describing its own creation is not thereby recursive; the recursion must be load-bearing.

In practice the distinction is difficult to maintain. Clerks at the Annex of Procedural Anomalies record that instruments are frequently submitted which are valid only if read after themselves, and several are filed in both the recursive and the ordinary registers on the grounds that no one has been able to read them the first time. The Bureau of Referential Integrity, a sub-office of the Department of Autological Integrity, handles disputes arising where two instruments each cite the other as their authority, a configuration known formally as a citation loop and informally, in the Annex corridors, as a "standing pair."

The Scroll Dispute

The primary recension is chiefly famous as the object at the centre of the Scroll Dispute, a controversy concerning its own creation that has never been fully settled. The Scroll describes its drafting in three places, and the three accounts cannot all be true. Its preamble states that it was sealed before drafting; its second schedule records the removal of the seal prior to drafting; and its Annex C, the Prologue of the Unaffixed Seal, asserts that no seal was ever applied and that the question of removal therefore does not arise.

"The instrument records its creation in the order most convenient to the instrument, and the archivist is not to prefer one account because it is earlier, nor another because it is later, nor the third because it is neither."

— Custodial Spire for Recursive Amendments, memorandum of the 8th Recension

A historiographical party holds that the Dispute properly concerns the Year of the Unfurled Parchment, and that the Year of the Unfurled Scroll — during which the recursive register expanded by a factor of six and produced the Nomenclature Impasse — is a separate and later embarrassment mistakenly conflated with it in the secondary literature. The claim is not absurd: the two years are recorded identically in two of the four surviving calendars.

Governance and amendment

Amendments to the Scroll are governed by the general law of Latent Amendments, which originate procedurally from Aperture Gamma in the Custodial Spire. A Latent Amendment is an amendment that has been drafted, sealed, and entered on the register but has not yet been written into the text it amends. The Spire maintains that this is a matter of drafting convenience. The Font of Unwritten Definitions maintains that it is a matter of drafting. The disagreement has run since the Year of the Unfurled Scroll and has consumed, by the Bureau's own count, eleven Concordance citations, of which nine are still in force.

HIC Directive 045 sets the timeline for entering Latent Amendments into open recensions. HIC Directive 012 operates as a codicil to it, particularly in matters concerning recursive administrative definitions, and provides that where a Latent Amendment amends a clause that authorises its own amendment, the Amendment is to be entered twice: once as amendment and once as record of the amendment. Clerks call the second entry the "twin" and dislike it. On at least one occasion a twin was entered before its parent and could not thereafter be reconciled, and Spiral 881 now carries a standing note, in a hand older than the catalogue, reading only: leave it.

Conflicting Concordances

The Third Concordance provides at Annex 4 that a recursive instrument shall be read as though its self-referential clause stood last, whatever its position on the page. The Seventh Concordance provides that it shall be read as though the clause stood first. Both remain in force. The Concordance of Precedence, which might be expected to resolve the matter, was amended in the same session in which it was enacted and now provides only that "the earlier of two contradictory readings prevails, save where the later prevails." Visiting scholars are advised to bring their own ink and not to annotate the Spiral 881 copies.

Access and custody

The Scroll may be consulted by any Librarian in good standing, on application to the Custodial Spire and subject to the Scroll of Conditional Elevations where the reader's floor of residence lies above the Annex. It may not be consulted twice in the same day, as a precaution against citation loops forming in the reader. Reading is conducted at the designated table on Spiral 881 under the supervision of a duty clerk, whose name is entered on the access register before and after the reading, and who is required to confirm that they are the same clerk on both occasions.

Custody disputes between the Spire and the Font are recorded in the register as "ongoing." The Scroll of Perpetual Deferral, which shares a landing with the Scroll and is often consulted on the same visit, defers its own custody to the reader and has never caused difficulty.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Font of Unwritten Definitions: how is it conducted?

The Font of Unwritten Definitions is a disputed conceptual apparatus and associated philosophical doctrine used to generate provisional meanings for terms and entities that lack formal cataloguing within the Tower. It is…

Font of Unwritten Definitions
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Courts of Definition: who are they?

The Courts of Definition are a distributed judiciary apparatus responsible for adjudicating the procedural integrity of classifications within the Tower's catalogue. Operating under the authority of the Judiciary of Cros…

Courts of Definition
Custodial Spire for Recursive Amendments: where is it?

The Custodial Spire for Recursive Amendments is the administrative and jurisdictional core of the Recursive Amendments Office, physically coterminous with Floor 9001. It serves as the primary site for the drafting, valid…

Custodial Spire for Recursive Amendments

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.